Carry Forward and Set off of Losses from Activity of owning and Maintaining Race Horses [Sec. 115]

Section 115 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 provides special rules for the carry forward and set-off of losses from the activity of owning and maintaining race horses. Where the assessee incurs a loss from this activity and it cannot be completely adjusted against eligible income from the same activity during the relevant tax year, the unabsorbed loss may be carried forward. Such loss is ring-fenced and cannot be freely adjusted against income from salary, house property, ordinary business, capital gains or other unrelated sources. The carried-forward loss can be adjusted only against income from the same specified activity, subject to statutory conditions.

1. Meaning of Loss from Owning and Maintaining Race Horses

A loss from the activity of owning and maintaining race horses arises where the allowable expenditure incurred on the specified activity exceeds the income derived from it during the relevant tax year. The activity must involve the assessee’s ownership and maintenance of race horses and must satisfy the conditions prescribed under the Act. Expenses connected with maintaining eligible race horses are considered according to the applicable computation provisions. Where the final result is a loss, special rules apply because such loss is not treated in the same manner as an ordinary business loss. Section 115 specifically governs its carry forward and subsequent set-off.

2. Set-off of Race-Horse Loss

Under Section 115, a loss arising from the activity of owning and maintaining race horses can be set off only against income from the activity of owning and maintaining race horses. It cannot be adjusted against ordinary business profits, salary, house-property income, capital gains or unrelated income from other sources. This restriction creates a separate category for race-horse losses and prevents such losses from reducing other taxable income of the assessee. Where sufficient income from the specified activity is available, the eligible loss may be absorbed against that income. Any balance remaining after the permissible adjustment may be carried forward according to Section 115.

3. Carry Forward of Race-Horse Loss

Where the loss from owning and maintaining race horses cannot be wholly set off during the relevant tax year, Section 115 permits the eligible unabsorbed amount to be carried forward to subsequent tax years. In a later year, the brought-forward loss can be adjusted only against income arising from the activity of owning and maintaining race horses. Its character does not change merely because it has been carried forward. If sufficient eligible income is unavailable in a subsequent year, the remaining loss may continue to be carried forward within the statutory period. Thus, Section 115 maintains the ring-fenced treatment of such losses across tax years.

4. Period of Carry Forward

Loss from the activity of owning and maintaining race horses may be carried forward for a maximum of four tax years immediately succeeding the tax year for which the loss was first computed. During this period, the brought-forward loss can be set off only against eligible income from the same specified activity. Where only part of the loss is absorbed in a subsequent year, the remaining balance may continue to be carried forward within the original four-year period. After expiry of the prescribed period, any unabsorbed loss ordinarily lapses. Therefore, the assessee should maintain proper year-wise records of the loss, set-off and balance carried forward.

5. Conditions for Carry Forward and Set-off

To obtain the benefit of carry forward and set-off under Section 115, the assessee must satisfy the conditions prescribed under the Income-tax Act, 2025. The loss must arise from the qualifying activity of owning and maintaining race horses and must be properly determined under the applicable computation provisions. Compliance with the relevant return-filing and loss-determination requirements is also important for preserving the right to carry forward the loss. In subsequent years, set-off is restricted exclusively to income from the same activity. Accordingly, proper documentation of income, eligible expenditure and previous losses is necessary to establish the amount available for future adjustment.

illustration

Suppose an assessee earns ₹2,00,000 from the activity of owning and maintaining race horses but incurs allowable expenditure of ₹5,00,000.

Particulars Amount (₹)
Income from Race-Horse Activity 2,00,000
Less: Allowable Expenditure (5,00,000)
Loss from Race-Horse Activity (3,00,000)
Current-year eligible set-off available Nil
Loss carried forward u/s 115 3,00,000

If the assessee earns ₹1,20,000 from the same activity in the following tax year:

Particulars Amount (₹)
Income from Race-Horse Activity 1,20,000
Less: Brought-forward Loss (1,20,000)
Taxable Income Nil
Balance Loss carried forward 1,80,000

The remaining ₹1,80,000 may continue to be carried forward within the prescribed four-tax-year limit.

Bad Debts [Sec. 31], Provision for Bad Debts [Sec. 31], Treatment

Section 31 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 deals with deduction for bad debts and provision for bad and doubtful debts, allowed while computing income under Section 26. It permits two categories of deduction: a provision-based deduction available to specified financial entities scheduled banks, co-operative banks, public financial institutions, and NBFCs subject to prescribed percentage ceilings of total income, and a write-off-based deduction for actual bad debts, available to all assessees once the debt is written off as irrecoverable in the books, subject to conditions ensuring genuine, previously-recognised business debts.

Provision for Bad Debts [Sec. 31]:

1. Deduction for Scheduled and Co-operative Banks [Sec. 31(1), Category 1]

Under Section 31(1), a scheduled bank (other than one incorporated outside India), a non-scheduled bank, or a co-operative bank (excluding primary agricultural credit societies and primary co-operative agricultural and rural development banks) may claim deduction for provision for bad and doubtful debts up to 8.5% of total income for the tax year, computed before this deduction and before Chapter VIII deductions. An additional amount, up to 10% of aggregate average advances made by rural branches, computed in the prescribed manner, is also allowed, recognising the higher credit risk inherent in rural lending operations.

2. Additional Deduction on Securities Redemption Income

For assessees falling under clauses (a) and (b) of the specified category — namely scheduled and non-scheduled banks — Section 31(1) further permits, at the assessee’s option, an additional deduction exceeding the standard 8.5% limit, restricted to the income from redemption of securities under a scheme framed by the Central Government. This benefit applies only where such redemption income has been disclosed in the return under the head “Profits and Gains of Business or Profession”, ensuring the concession aligns strictly with disclosed, government-scheme-linked securities income.

3. Deduction for Foreign Banks, Financial Institutions and NBFCs [Sec. 31(1), Category 2]

A bank incorporated outside India, a public financial institution, a State Financial Corporation, a State Industrial Investment Corporation, or a non-banking financial company (NBFC) is allowed a deduction for provision for bad and doubtful debts up to 5% of total income for the tax year, computed before this deduction and before Chapter VIII deductions. This lower ceiling, compared to the 8.5% available to domestic scheduled and co-operative banks, reflects a distinct statutory treatment for foreign banking entities and non-banking financial institutions under the Act.

Treatment and Tax Implications of Bad Debts:

A bad debt is a debt that has become irrecoverable from a customer or debtor. For income-tax purposes, its deduction is governed mainly by Section 36(1)(vii) read with Section 36(2) of the Income-tax Act, 2025. The deduction is generally available when the bad debt is written off as irrecoverable in the accounts, subject to the conditions prescribed under the Act.

1. Accounting Treatment

When a debt becomes irrecoverable, it is written off by debiting Bad Debts A/c and crediting Debtor’s A/c.

Particulars Journal Entry
Bad debt written off Bad Debts A/c Dr.
   To Debtor’s A/c
Bad debt recovered subsequently Cash/Bank A/c Dr.
   To Bad Debts Recovered A/c

2. Tax Treatment

Situation Tax Treatment
Debt is written off as irrecoverable in books Generally deductible under Section 36(1)(vii), subject to conditions
Debt relates to business/profession Must satisfy conditions under Section 36(2)
Debt was previously taken into account in computing income May qualify for deduction, subject to statutory conditions
Bad debt subsequently recovered Recovery is generally taxable as business income under the applicable provisions
Mere provision for doubtful debts Generally not equivalent to actual write-off, except where specifically permitted by law

3. Tax Journal Entry

The accounting entry for writing off the debt remains:

Bad Debts A/c Dr.
    To Debtor’s A/c

Deduction in Respect of Expenditure on Specified Business [Sec. 46]

Section 46 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 allows a full deduction of capital expenditure incurred wholly and exclusively for a specified business, in the tax year such expenditure is incurred. This provision corresponding to erstwhile Section 35AD — is designed to incentivise investment in select sectors such as infrastructure, hospitality, and healthcare by permitting 100% write-off, rather than gradual depreciation. The deduction is available at the assessee’s option, subject to specified conditions ensuring the business is genuinely new and not a reorganisation of an existing enterprise.

1. Nature and Scope of Deduction [Sec. 46(1)-(2)]

Under Section 46(1), an assessee may, at his option, claim deduction of the entire capital expenditure incurred wholly and exclusively for a specified business carried on during the relevant tax year. Notably, this allows immediate write-off instead of spreading the cost through depreciation over several years, offering significant cash-flow benefit for capital-intensive new ventures. Section 46(2) extends this benefit to pre-commencement expenditure- capital expenditure incurred before operations begin is allowed as a deduction in the tax year the business actually commences, provided such expenditure has been duly capitalised in the books of account as on that date.

2. Conditions for Eligibility [Sec. 46(3)]

Section 46(3) prescribes that the deduction applies only where the specified business satisfies all conditions cumulatively. The business must not be set up by splitting up or reconstruction of an already existing business, ensuring the incentive targets genuinely new investment rather than restructured old operations. Further, it must not be set up by transfer of machinery or plant previously used for any other purpose safeguarding against businesses claiming fresh deduction on already-used assets repurposed merely to access this benefit. These anti-abuse conditions preserve the provision’s intent of promoting bona fide new capacity creation.

3. Specified Businesses Covered

The benefit under Section 46 applies to a notified list of businesses, including laying and operating cross-country natural gas pipelines, building and operating two-star or above hotels, setting up hospitals with 100+ beds, and developing slum redevelopment housing projects, each subject to a specified commencement date for eligibility. Other sectors historically covered under this scheme (as per the earlier Section 35AD framework) include cold chain facilities, warehousing for agricultural produce, and affordable housing projects, reflecting the government’s continued policy thrust toward infrastructure and social-sector investment through tax-based incentives.

error: Content is protected !!