Month: March 2020

Human Resource Management, or HRM, in India is much the same as in other countries: taking care of management and employee issues, dealing with talent development, managing benefits, and providing discipline. However, when dealing with the largest working population in the world, India has a difficult and unique challenge, which has led to some more creative solutions.

For one, India has developed an entire ministry in its government devoted to regulating Human Resources and encouraging education to ensure that there is sufficient talent in addition to the sheer volume of employees. It also has to deal with the youth of its organizations and use technology effectively to cope with the volume of employees it has. For this reason, HR in India uses social media frequently, such as LinkedIn and other resources.

With drain becoming rampant, there seems to be dearth of talent in India. There is a need to tackle this problem. India has been the principal source of human capital for the rest of the world, so it is not unusual for Indians to be absorbed by foreign companies overseas. However, India needs to take advantage of their human capital. Everyone wants to grow and learn in their jobs and make good salaries. Those of us with talent want to do our best at whatever we are good at. Everybody is trying to reach self-actualization. So, every company needs to find good talent, keep it and develop it.

Switching jobs is a trend these days and the need to retain employees has become a strategic requirement if business organizations have to have best of talent. Money is certainly not the answer to this problem because there will always be someone else who is willing to pay you more. Building a bond between the employee and the organization is critical. There is no simple formula to creating this engagement. The company needs to outlay a compelling vision, and the employee needs to believe in what the organization is trying to accomplish. As soon as the word ‘routine’ starts laying in a worker’s mind, the company has lost him. The organization should ensure that an employee is justly rewarded for his contribution and is constantly given newer, challenging responsibilities.

There is a stereotype that the HR executives don’t do any work and keep coming up with meaningless policies. The premise is not right. HR executives are not planning the strategies that they should be if they introduce meaningless policies. When there is a proliferation of policies the employees become cynical. The HR should manage their time effectively. If they spend too much time on payrolls, they’re not doing a good job as that work can be comfortably outsourced. They should devote more time to strategies that help build engagements.

Some individuals think the skills needed by a HR professional in India different from the ones needed by an HR professional in developed countries. This is not correct looking at the bigger picture. But the Indian context is different. Indian economy is growing rapidly, so that HR professional needs to act and react quicker. In the US talk about hiring a 1,000 workers, you will be talking about a number that’s three or four times greater. In India however, there is lesser uniformity when it comes to adhering to policies of movement, which seems to work.

The role of human resources (HR) has been evolving for some time. From “personnel” to “human resources,” HR is a source of expertise on people issues in a business. HR functions enable organizations to maximize the contribution of people to the delivery of the organization’s goals.

HR has become a strategic partner with the leaders of the business-to contribute to significant business decisions, advice on critical transitions, and develop the value of the employees-in short, to have a seat at the table. It is there to formulate policy and practice on people issues.

Below are the main roles of human resources in any organizations especially with businesses:

1. Strategic Partner

In this role, the HR person contributes to the development of and the accomplishment of the organization-wide business plan and objectives. The objectives of HR are established to support the attainment of the overall strategic business plan and objectives. When HR professionals are aligned with the business, the personnel component of the organization is thought about as a strategic contributor to business success.

2. Elaborate the Compensation and Benefits

Like employee and labor relations, the compensation and benefits functions of HR often can be handled by one HR specialist with dual expertise. On the compensation side, the HR functions include setting compensation structures and evaluating competitive pay practices.

A comp and benefits specialist also may negotiate group health coverage rates with insurers and coordinate activities with the retirement savings fund administrator. Payroll can be a component of the compensation and benefits section of HR; however, in many cases, employers outsource such administrative functions as payroll.

3. Responsible for Training

Training employee is important to help the new hires get acquainted with the organization’s work pattern. It is imperative for the HR department to incorporate a training program for every new employee based on the skill set required for their job. It will further also contribute towards employee motivation and retention. This training will not only be of assistance to the employee but also give the HR team an insight into the employee’s workmanship. On completion of the training, HR plays a significant role in assessing the results of the training program and grading employees on the same.

4. Employee Advocate

As an employee sponsor or advocate, the HR manager plays an integral role in organizational success via his knowledge about and advocacy of people. This advocacy includes expertise in how to create a work environment in which people will choose to be motivated, contributing, and happy.

Fostering effective methods of goal setting, communication and empowerment through responsibility, builds employee ownership of the organization. The HR professional helps establish the organizational culture and climate in which people have the competency, concern, and commitment to serve customers well.

5. Works with Compliance

Compliance with labor and employment laws is a critical HR function. Noncompliance can result in workplace complaints based on unfair employment practices, unsafe working conditions and general dissatisfaction with working conditions that can affect productivity and ultimately, profitability. HR staff must be aware of federal and state employment laws.

6. Professional Development

Closely related to training, developing your employees professionally is an added bonus for the employee as well as the organization. Enrolling the employee to attend conferences, trade shows, seminars etc that may be in his personal interest will make the employee feel cared-for and a vital part of the organization, thus increasing employee engagement. It will be beneficial to the organization by way of the employee’s added skill set. It is the HR head’s job to get to know the employee’s hobbies and areas of interest and look out for opportunities that will help them build onto those hobbies.

7. Resolves Conflicts

Where different people have different views, conflicts are almost inevitable. Whether the dispute is amongst two or more employees or between the employee and the management, an HR manager has the right to intervene and help map out a solution.

The HR should be available at the disposal of the conflicting parties and hear out their issues without being judgmental. A reimbursement in case of any loss caused and strict actions against the defaulter should be practiced for effective conflict resolution by the HRM.

Human resources are the valuable assets of the corporate bodies. They are their strength. To face the new challenges on the fronts of knowledge, technology and changing trends in global economy needs effective human resource management. Significance of HRM can be seen in three contexts: organizational, social and professional.

1. Organization Significance

HRM is of vital importance to the individual organization as a means for achieving their objectives.

It contributes to the achievement of organizational objectives in the following ways:

(i) Good human resource practice can help in attracting and retaining the best people in the organization.

(ii) Developing the necessary skills and right attitudes among the employees through training, development, performance appraisal, etc.

(iii) Securing willing cooperation of employees through motivation, participation, grievance handling, etc.

(iv) Effective utilization of available human resources.

(v) Ensuring that enterprise will have in future a team of competent and dedicated employees.

2. Social Significance

Social significance of HRM lies in the need satisfaction of personnel in the organization. Since these personnel are drawn from the society, their effectiveness contributes to the welfare of the society. Society, as a whole, is the major beneficiary of good human resource practice.

(i) Employment opportunities multiply.

(ii) Eliminating waste of human resources through conservation of physical and mental health.

(iii) Scare talents are put to best use. Companies that pay and treat people well always race ahead of others and deliver excellent results.

3. Professional Significance

Professional significance of HRM lies in developing people and providing healthy environment for effective utilization of their capabilities.

This can be done by:

(i) Developing people on continuous basis to meet challenge of their job.

(ii) Promoting team-work and team-spirit among employees.

(iii) Offering excellent growth opportunities to people who have the potential to rise.

(iv) Providing environment and incentives for developing and utilizing creativity.

Objectives of Human Resource Management

(i) To provide, create, utilize and motivate employees to accomplish organizational goals.

(ii) To secure integration of individual and groups in securing organisational effectiveness.

(iii) To create opportunities, to provide facilities, necessary motivation to individual and group for their growth with the growth of the organisation by training and development, compensation etc.

(iv) To employ the skills and ability of the workforce efficiently, i.e., to utilise human resources effectively.

(v) To increase to the fullest the employee’s job satisfaction and self-actualisation; it tries to prompt and stimulate every employee to realise his potential.

(vi) To create a sense and feeling of belongingness team-spirit and encourage suggestions from employees.

(vii) To help maintain ethical policies and behaviour inside and outside the organization.

(viii) To maintain high moral and good human relation within the organization.

(ix) To manage change to the mutual advantage of individuals, groups, the organization and the society.

(x) To ensure that, there is no threat of unemployment, inequalities, adopting a policy recognizing merit and employee contribution, and condition for stability of employment.

Human Resource Management (HRM) is the governance of an organization’s employees. HRM is sometimes referred to simply as Human Resources (HR).

The first definition of human resource management is that it is a process that will manage people in a company in a defined and structured way.

The HR is supposed to do the following tasks- staffing, hiring people, retention of employees, managing pays and perks and setting them, performance management, managing the changes and many more. This definition is a traditional one and is a modern version of personnel management.

Another definition for human resource management states that managing the people or employees in an organization can be done in a macro perspective which means that managing employees will be in the form of a relationship between management and employees.

Human resources are the people who work for the organization; human resource management is really employee management with an emphasis on those employees as assets of the business. In this article, employees are sometimes referred to as human capital.

HR professionals recruit, manage and provide direction for people who work in an organization to maximize profitability and employee satisfaction. They typically develop and administer policies related to hiring, performance management, compensation, safety and wellness, employee benefits, communication and training.

Pigors and Myers: “It is basically a method of developing potentialities of employees so that they feel maximum satisfaction of their work and give their best efforts to the organization”.

Byars and Rue: “Human resource management encompasses those activities designed to provide for and coordinate the human resources of an organization Human resource functions refer to those tasks and duties performed in organizations to provide for and coordinate human resources”.

Ivancevich and Glueck: “Human resource management is the function performed in organizations’ that facilitate the most effective use of people (employees) to achieve organizational and individual goals”.

Scope of Human Resource Management

Human resources are undoubtedly the key resources in an organization, the easiest and the most difficult to manage! The objectives of the HRM span right from the manpower needs assessment to management and retention of the same. To this effect Human resource management is responsible for effective designing and implementation of various policies, procedures and programs. It is all about developing and managing knowledge, skills, creativity, aptitude and talent and using them optimally.

Human Resource Management is not just limited to manage and optimally exploit human intellect. It also focuses on managing physical and emotional capital of employees. Considering the intricacies involved, the scope of HRM is widening with every passing day. It covers but is not limited to HR planning, hiring (recruitment and selection), training and development, payroll management, rewards and recognitions, Industrial relations, grievance handling, legal procedures etc. In other words, we can say that it’s about developing and managing harmonious relationships at workplace and striking a balance between organizational goals and individual goals.

The scope of HRM is extensive and far-reaching. Therefore, it is very difficult to define it concisely. However, we may classify the same under following heads:

(i) HRM in Personnel Management

This is typically direct manpower management that involves manpower planning, hiring (recruitment and selection), training and development, induction and orientation, transfer, promotion, compensation, layoff and retrenchment, employee productivity. The overall objective here is to ascertain individual growth, development and effectiveness which indirectly contribute to organizational development.

It also includes performance appraisal, developing new skills, disbursement of wages, incentives, allowances, traveling policies and procedures and other related courses of actions.

(ii) HRM in Employee Welfare

This particular aspect of HRM deals with working conditions and amenities at workplace. This includes a wide array of responsibilities and services such as safety services, health services, welfare funds, social security and medical services. It also covers appointment of safety officers, making the environment worth working, eliminating workplace hazards, support by top management, job safety, safeguarding machinery, cleanliness, proper ventilation and lighting, sanitation, medical care, sickness benefits, employment injury benefits, personal injury benefits, maternity benefits, unemployment benefits and family benefits.

It also relates to supervision, employee counseling, establishing harmonious relationships with employees, education and training. Employee welfare is about determining employees’ real needs and fulfilling them with active participation of both management and employees. In addition to this, it also takes care of canteen facilities, crèches, rest and lunch rooms, housing, transport, medical assistance, education, health and safety, recreation facilities, etc.

(iii) HRM in Industrial Relations

Since it is a highly sensitive area, it needs careful interactions with labor or employee unions, addressing their grievances and settling the disputes effectively in order to maintain peace and harmony in the organization. It is the art and science of understanding the employment (union-management) relations, joint consultation, disciplinary procedures, solving problems with mutual efforts, understanding human behavior and maintaining work relations, collective bargaining and settlement of disputes.

The main aim is to safeguarding the interest of employees by securing the highest level of understanding to the extent that does not leave a negative impact on organization. It is about establishing, growing and promoting industrial democracy to safeguard the interests of both employees and management.

The scope of HRM is extremely wide, thus, can not be written concisely. However, for the sake of convenience and developing understanding about the subject, we divide it in three categories mentioned above.

A procurement department is mandated to execute 3 Main Functions:

1. Manage the organization’s spending

A good procurement function is pivotal in deploying an effective Annual Buying Plan, leveraging robust forecasting, market analysis, purchasing processes, and cost reduction methodologies.

2. Support operations

Support operations by ensuring the timely acquisition of high quality, low cost, inputs and raw materials to be converted into products and services purchased by an organizations’ internal customers. An organization exists to create value for its customers. The procurement function is pivotal in supporting value creation processes.

3. Protect the organization from risk

Protect the organization from risk by deploying risk management methodologies such as Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA). Contract management, and price shock mitigation and avoidance provide huge benefits to an organization, stakeholders and customers.

Human resource planning (HRP)

Human resource planning (HRP) is the continuous process of systematic planning ahead to achieve optimum use of an organization’s most valuable asset—quality employees. Human resources planning ensures the best fit between employees and jobs while avoiding manpower shortages or surpluses.

There are four key steps of the HRP process. They include analyzing present labor supply, forecasting labor demand, balancing projected labor demand with supply, and supporting organizational goals.

HRP helps companies is an important investment for any business as it allows companies to remain both productive and profitable.

Human resources planning allows companies to plan ahead so they can maintain a steady supply of skilled employees. That’s why it is also referred to as workforce planning. The process is also used to help companies evaluate their needs and to plan ahead to meet those needs.

Human resource planning needs to be flexible enough to meet short-term staffing challenges while adapting to changing conditions in the business environment over the longer term. HRP starts by assessing and auditing the current capacity of human resources.

The challenges to HRP include forces that are always changing such as employees getting sick, getting promoted or going on vacation. HRP ensures there is the best fit between workers and jobs, avoiding shortages and surpluses in the employee pool.

To satisfy their objectives, HR managers have to make plans to do the following:

• Find and attract skilled employees.
• Select, train, and reward the best candidates.
• Cope with absences and deal with conflicts.
• Promote employees or let some of them go.

Investing in HRP is one of the most important decisions a company can make. After all, a company is only as good as its employees. If it has the best employees and the best practices in place, it can mean the difference between sluggishness and productivity and can lead to profitability.

Steps to Human Resources Planning

There are four general, broad steps involved in the human resources planning process. The first step of human resource planning is to identify the company’s current human resources supply. In this step, the HR department studies the strength of the organization based on the number of employees, their skills, qualifications, positions, benefits, and performance levels.

The second step requires the company to outline the future of its workforce. Here, the HR department can consider certain issues like promotions, retirements, layoffs, and transfers anything that factors into the future needs of a company.The third step in the HRP process is forecasting the employment demand. HR creates a gap analysis that lays out specific needs to narrow the supply of the company’s labor versus future demand. Should employees learn new skills? Does the company need more managers? Do all employees play to their strengths in their current roles?

The answers to these questions let HR determine how to proceed, which is the final phase of the HRP process. HR must now take practical steps to integrate its plan with the rest of the company. The department needs a budget, the ability to implement the plan, and a collaborative effort with all departments to execute that plan.

The goal of HR planning is to have the optimal number of staff to make the most money for the company. Because the goals and strategies of the company change over time, HRP is a regular occurrence.

• Human resource planning is what a strategy used by a company to company maintain a steady stream of skilled employees while avoiding employee shortages or surpluses.
• Having a good HRP strategy in place can mean productivity and profitability for a company.
• There are four general steps in the HRP process: identifying the current supply of employees, determining the future of the workforce, balancing between the supply and demand, and how to implement the plans.

The potential appraisal is made up of two words viz. potential and appraisal. Potential means the abilities of an employee which are required for meeting the challenges of future assignments while appraisal means the evaluation of that abilities in present status of an employee.

Thus, potential appraisal is the process of evaluation of the abilities of an employees that uses by employee in the future assignments. It is different from performance appraisal and needs to be carried out at regular intervals.

The potential appraisal refers to the appraisal involving identification of the hidden talents and skills of a person. The person might or might not be aware of them.

Potential appraisal is a future-oriented appraisal whose main objective is to identify and evaluate the potential of the employees to assume higher positions and responsibilities in the organizational hierarchy. Many organizations consider and use potential appraisal as a part of the performance appraisal processes.

The Potential for Improving Performance, or PIP, measures the performance of the average worker versus the best person performing a particular task. Large differences suggest that performance can be improved by bringing average performance up closer to the best performance. Small differences suggest little potential for improvement.

Potential appraisal refers to the identification of hidden skills, talents and abilities in a person which even he may be unaware of. It is a future oriented concept and is a powerful tool for employee advancement. The latent skills of a person are tracked and his true potential is evaluated.

An employee with high potential is a good candidate for assuming more responsibilities in future. In western countries, many organizations use potential appraisal as a part of performance appraisal process. However, in India, not many managers are aware of this term though informally every organization makes potential assessments.

Potential appraising is different from appraising performance. Poten­tial refers to abilities of an employee which are currently not brought to use by an organization. Potential means the talent capacity to under­take higher challenges on job in future.

Example of Potential appraisal

A good salesman need not be a good manager in the sales function since the job of a sales manager requires managerial qualities apart from selling skills.

Potential appraisal aims at identifying and assessing the capabilities of an individual to perform higher level of functions or responsibilities. It forms the basis for decisions associated with the promotions and succession planning.

In potential appraisal, attributes like velocity (speed and direction in which the employee is progressing), people and customer (listening skills, interpersonal relationship) orientation, focus on results, initiative etc. are assessed.

Objectives of potential appraisal:

• Identify the abilities of an employee in order to evaluate whether that employee is suitable for future assignments or otherwise, and
• Occupy higher positions in the organizational hierarchy and undertake higher responsibilities because past performance may not be a good indicator for future and higher role.
• Inform employees about their future roles;
• Make suitable corrections in training efforts from time to time;
• Inform employees about they must do something for their career prospects;
• Help organization for suitable succession plan;
• Improve quality and quantity of performance of an employee; and
• Give proper feedback to the employees for their potential.

Features of Potential appraisal

Potential appraisal forms an important part of HRM in finding out the hidden talents of employees.

The following are the features of potential appraisal:

• Helps assess the employees’ capacities, which pave way for them to give their best performance
• Helps assess an organization’s ability to develop future managers
• Helps assess the employees’ analytical power, which indicates the ability to analyze problems and examine them critically
• Helps build creative imagination, which is the ability of presenting an existing thing in an unconventional and new manner
• Helps analyze the sense of reality, which refers to an employee’s way of interpreting a situation
• Helps develop leadership skills, which refer to the abilities to direct, control, and harmonize with people.

Four Main Mechanisms of Potential appraisal

Potential appraisal presupposes the existence of clear-cut ‘job or role descriptions’ and ‘job or role specifications’, i.e., qualities needed to perform the role.

The mechanisms that could be used for potential appraisal are discussed below:

1. Rating by Superior

The potential of a candidate could be rated by the immediate supervisor who is acquainted with the candidate’s work and also his technical capabilities.

2. Psychological Tests

Managerial and behavioural dimensions can be measured through a battery of psychological tests.

3. Games

Simulation games and exercises (assessment centre, business games, in-basked, role play, etc.) could be used to uncover the potential of the candidate.

4. Performance Records

Performance records and ratings of the candidate on his previous jobs could be examined carefully on various dimensions such as initiative, creativity, risk-taking ability, etc., which might play a key role in discharging his duties in a new job.

Merit Rating is also known as performance appraisal or performance evaluation. It is a systematic process for measuring the performance of the employees in terms of job requirements.

It utilizes various rating techniques for comparing individual employees in a work group in terms of personal qualities or deficiencies and the requirements of their respective jobs. It is an established fact that people differ in their abilities and aptitudes. These differences are natural to a great extent and cannot be eliminated even by providing same training and education facilities to them.

There will be some differences in the quality and quantity of work done by different workers even on the same job. Therefore it is essential for the management to know these differentials so that employees having better abilities may be rewarded and the wrong selection and placement maybe restricted or avoided.

Concepts and Definitions of Merit Rating

According to Scot and Spriegel

“Merit-rating of an employee is the process of evaluating the employee’s performance on the job in terms of the requirements of the job”. It is a technique of assessing the worth of an employee with reference to job requirements.

According to Dale Yodder

“Refers to all formal procedures used in working organizations to evaluate personalities and contribution and potential of group members”. In the words of Yodder all types of methods used in evaluating the worth of employees for the organization are termed as performance appraisal.

In views of Alford and Beaty

“Employees rating is the evaluation or appraisal or the relative worth to the company of a man’s services on his job”. According to his definition the contribution of employees on jobs and their usefulness to the company is assessed under performance appraisal.

Thus according to the above mentioned definitions merit-rating or performance appraisal is a systematic evaluation of employees contribution to the organization in performance of their jobs. This evaluation is normally done by the immediate superior in the organization which is reviewed in turn by his superior. Not only the qualities, but deficiencies are also taken into consideration to improve the performance of employees.

Objectives of Merit Rating

People differ in abilities and aptitudes. Management should know these differences so that employees are assigned jobs according to their capability.

Main objectives of merit rating are as follows:

• To assess the work of employees in relation to their job requirements.
• To consider employees/workers for promotions, transfer, layoffs etc.
• To assess the good and bad points in working of employees and then making suggestions for improvement.
• To help in wage and salary administrations and taking decisions about incentives and increments to be given to the workers.
• To evaluate skill and training capabilities of employees and helping in planning suitable training and development programmes for workers.
• To know the problems faced by workers while doing various jobs.
• To provide a basis for comparison to segregate efficient and inefficient workers.
• To help management in placement/transfer to workers according to their capacity, interest, aptitude and qualifications.
• To help supervisors to know their subordinates more closely for increasing their efficiency and improving productivity.

Process of Merit Rating

Merit rating should be done on the basis of certain standards fixed in advance. The workers should also be in the know of the yardsticks to be used for evaluating them. Unless a proper process is used for evaluation, it will not give good results.

Following process is used for merit rating:

(i) Establishing Standards

The employees/workers will have to be rated against the standards set for their performance. There should be some base on which one may categorize that the performance of a person is good, average, bad etc.

The standards may be in terms of quantity and quality of production in case of workers; personality traits like leadership, initiative, imagination in case of executives, files cleared in case of office staff, etc. These standards will help in setting yardsticks for evaluating performance of the people concerned.

(ii) Communicating Standards to Workers

The standards set for performance should be communicated to the employees. They should know what is expected from them. When the standards are made known to employees, they will try to achieve their performance equal or above them.

Even later on they will not resent adverse reports if they fail to achieve certain standards. It is essential to get feedback from employees whether they have followed the standards as is desired by the management.

(iii) Measuring Actual Performance

The next step in evaluation process is to measure actual performance of employees. The performance may be measured through personal observation, statistical reports, oral reports, written reports, received from the executives concerned.

(iv) Comparing Actual with Standards

The actual performance is compared to the standards set earlier for finding out the standing of workers. The employee is evaluated and judged by his potential for growth and advancement. Deviations in performance are also recorded at this stage.

(v) Discussing Reports with Workers

The assessment reports are periodically discussed with concerned employees/workers. The weak points, good points and difficulties are indicated for helping employees to improve their performance.

The information received by employees influences their performance. It also effects their attitude and work in future. It may be easy to convey good reports but it requires tact to discuss adverse reports with the concerned employees.

(vi) Taking Corrective Action

Evaluation process will be useful only when corrective action is taken on the basis of reports. One corrective action may be in the form of advice, counselling, warning etc. Other action may be in the form of additional training, refresher courses, delegation of more authority, special assignments, coaching etc. These actions will be useful in helping employees to improve their future performance

Importance of Merit Rating

It is an established fact that people differ in their abilities and attitudes. The evaluation of their performance is the most important tool of an organization. This helps in assigning of work according to ability and capacity, spotting people for higher responsibility jobs, and recognising training and development requirements.

Following points brings out the importance of merit rating:

1. It is a managerial technique to find out the worth/capacity of various workers.
2. It helps in correct placement of workers.
3. Evaluation reports help employees to know their good points and weaknesses. The superiors also counsel their subordinates in improving their performance.
4. It provides a scientific basis for employee’s selection, training, promotion, demotion and any other action required.
5. It provides a basis for fixing wages and salaries and also helps in deciding about pay increases and incentive schemes for work force.
6. Merit rating can be used as basis of sound personnel policy in relation to transfer, promotion of workers.
7. It helps in eliminating personal prejudices and human bias against workers for any reasons.
8. It helps in removing grievances and develops a sense of confidence amongst workers because they will be sure of impartial evaluation process.
9. The workers will be more concerned in improving their performance and it will create more discipline among the employees.
10. It aims at providing data to superiors with which they may judge future job assignments and compensation required.
11. It helps in improving employer-employee relations through mutual confidence which is a result of frank discussions between a supervisor and his workmen.

Advantages of Merit Rating

The following are the advantages of Merit Rating:

1. It provides a scientific basis for judging the capability of employees who will try to improve their performance if it is not up to their satisfaction. Hence it helps in making comparisons.
2. It provides a sound basis for the purpose of promotion, demotion, transfer or termination of employees. Better persons are selected for promotion. The systematic evaluation remains as a part of permanent record.
3. It helps in distinguishing efficient and inefficient workers. In this way it reveals the defects in the selection procedure if any. Those employees who are misfit may be spotted and appropriate action initiated against them.
4. Workers may be given increase in pay or incentives if their performance is good. It helps the management in avoiding spot judgements and replacing it by advance decisions.
5. It develops confidence among the workers since the methods of evaluation are systematic and impartial. Among the workers, a sense of competition develops resulting into increased output hence improved productivity.
6. It creates a congenial atmosphere in which employer-employee relations are improved. Subordinates are motivated to work harder for getting favourable rating.
7. Merit rating is helpful in stimulating and guiding the development of an employee as it points out the weakness of the employees. In this way training requirements can be known and training programme can be accordingly decided.
8. It is a systematic evaluation technique which produces better supervisors and executives. On the basis of merit-rating report, the top management can judge the ability of executives writing such reports.

However, formal merit rating may not take place in case of a small unit where the informal rating can provide all the desired information. In case of a large scale concern, or big industries both employer and employee will be benefited from a systematic performance appraisal.

Limitations of Merit Rating

The various methods of merit rating are subject to the following limitations:

1. There is a tendency to rate employee on the basis of one factor only. It is also known as ‘blending tendency’. If the rater finds that the man is good in one field he will rate him good in all other concerned fields.
2. Each rater may apply his own standards with the result the final ratings simply cannot be compared. For example, a rater may think that ‘satisfactory’ rating is better than ‘excellent’. So clarity in standards is missing.
3. Lenient raters give; high ratings where as strict raters always give low ratings. Hence there is a big difference of ratings between two raters. It is another limitation of merit rating.
4. Generally the raters evaluate employee by keeping them in the average category though some may be falling in the extreme ends of the scale i.e. excellent or worst. So this central tendency is another drawback of this technique.
5. Usually there is a tendency to give high rating to a person who is doing the higher paid job. Merit rating has nothing to do with the job so it is its limitation.
6. Even if a person tries to be fairest rater in performance evaluation, he cannot eliminate bias because of differing perceptions.

Certain unconscious factors such as race, caste, creed, etc. may affect merit rating. If a manager who is less qualified, rates his subordinate who is more qualified, evaluation in such cases may not be fair. The limitations of merit rating explained above can be minimized to some extent by educating and training the raters..

Motivation

Motivation is the word derived from the word ’motive’ which means needs, desires, wants or drives within the individuals. It is the process of stimulating people to actions to accomplish the goals. In the work goal context the psychological factors stimulating the people’s behaviour can be:

• Desire for money
• Success
• Recognition
• Job-satisfaction
• Team work, etc..

One of the most important functions of management is to create willingness amongst the employees to perform in the best of their abilities. Therefore the role of a leader is to arouse interest in performance of employees in their jobs. The process of motivation consists of three stages:-

• A felt need or drive
• A stimulus in which needs have to be aroused
• When needs are satisfied, the satisfaction or accomplishment of goals.

Therefore, we can say that motivation is a psychological phenomenon which means needs and wants of the individuals have to be tackled by framing an incentive plan.

Morale

Morale can be defined as the total satisfaction derived by an individual from his job, his work-group, his superior, the organization he works for and the environment. It generally relates to the feeling of individual’s comfort, happiness and satisfaction.

According to Davis, “Morale is a mental condition of groups and individuals which determines their attitude.”

In short, morale is a fusion of employees’ attitudes, behaviours, manifestation of views and opinions – all taken together in their work scenarios, exhibiting the employees’ feelings towards work, working terms and relation with their employers. Morale includes employees’ attitudes on and specific reaction to their job.

There are two states of morale:

(i) High morale: High morale implies determination at work an essential in achievement of management objectives. High morale results in:

• A keen teamwork on part of the employees
• Organizational Commitment and a sense of belongingness in the employees mind
• Immediate conflict identification and resolution
• Healthy and safe work environment
• Effective communication in the organization
• Increase in productivity
• Greater motivation

(ii) Low morale: Low morale has following features:

• Greater grievances and conflicts in organization
• High rate of employee absenteeism and turnover
• Dissatisfaction with the superiors and employers
• Poor working conditions
• Employees frustration
• Decrease in productivity
• Lack of motivation

Though motivation and morale are closely related concepts, they are different in following ways:

While motivation is an internal-psychological drive of an individual which urges him to behave in a specific manner, morale is more of a group scenario.

Higher motivation often leads to higher morale of employees, but high morale does not essentially result in greatly motivated employees as to have a positive attitude towards all factors of work situation may not essentially force the employees to work more efficiently.

While motivation is an individual concept, morale is a group concept. Thus, motivation takes into consideration the individual differences among the employees, and morale of the employees can be increased by taking those factors into consideration which influence group scenario or total work settings.

Motivation acquires primary concern in every organization, while morale is a secondary phenomenon because high motivation essentially leads to higher productivity while high morale may not necessarily lead to higher productivity.

Things tied to morale are usually things that are just part of the work environment, and things tied to motivation are tied to the performance of the individual.

Difference between Motivation and Morale

Edwin Flippo (1961) defined morale as ‘a mental condition or attitude of individuals and groups which determines their willingness to cooperate’. Yoder Dale (1972), on the other hand, explained morale as ‘the overall tone, climate, or atmosphere of work perhaps regularly sensed by the members.

If workers appear to feel enthusiastic and optimistic about group activities, if they have a sense of mission about their jobs, and if they are friendly with each other, they are described as having a good or high morale. If they seem to be dissatisfied, irritated, cranky, critical, restless, and pessimistic, they are described as having poor or low morale.’ Elton Mayo defined it as ‘the maintenance of cooperative living’, which means a sense of belongingness.

On the other hand many authors defined morale as a ‘pursuit of a common purpose’, attitude, individual and group job satisfaction, participative attitudes, team sprit etc. Whatever may be the way of defining, it is evident that morale is a cognitive concept, encompassing feelings, attitudes, and sentiments, which together contribute to a general feeling of satisfaction in the workplace.

Like morale, motivation is also a cognitive concept, but it is different from morale on certain important aspects. Motivation stimulates individuals into action to achieve desired goals. It is, therefore, a function of needs and drives. It mobilizes energy, which enhances the potential for morale. Morale on the other hand is the individual or group attitude towards a particular subject. It contributes to a general feeling of satisfaction at the work place.

It is, therefore, the function of freedom or restraint towards some goal. It mobilizes sentiments, which form an important part of the organizational climate. Attitudes and sentiments, that is, morale, per se, affect productivity. High morale is an index of good human relations, which, inter alia, reduces labour turnover, absenteeism, indiscipline, grievances, etc.

Factors which affect morale are, primarily, attitude and job satisfaction levels of individual employees. From an organizational point of view, such factors can be delineated into organizational goals, leadership styles, co-workers’ attitude, nature of work, work environment, and the employee himself.

High morale is conventionally considered as a contributor to high productivity, but such correlation may not always be true. This is because high productivity may be the outcome of many other organizational initiatives, which may be independent of employee morale. Hence, even with low employee morale, high productivity is achievable. This can be illustrated using the model of Keith Davis, as in Figure 1.