Tag: Minority Shareholders

The income from capital gains is not an income which accrues or arises from day-to-day during a specific period but it arises at fixed point of time, namely, on the date of the transfer of a capital asset. Specifically, the income from capital gains is the amount by which the sale price of a capital asset, net of any expense incurred in connection with the sale of the asset, exceeds the acquisition cost of the capital asset. The taxation of capital gains is justified by the taxation policy and law on the premise that capital gains increases the ‘ability to pay’ capacity of the person receiving such a gain.

The provisions related to taxation of capital gains were first introduced in 1947 and then in 1956 and then said section 12B in Income tax Act, 1922 was retained as such in the relevant provisions in Income tax Act, 1961.

Charging sections – Sections 45, 46 and 46A

The charging section explains the subject matter of taxation. Thus, there is one charging section for each head of income for salaries, income from house property, business income and income from other sources. However, for capital gains, there are three independent and separate charging sections:

(i) Section 45: Capital gains

(ii) Section 46: Capital gains on distribution of assets by companies in liquidation

(iii) Section 46A: Capital gains on purchase by company of its own shares or other securities

Section 45 is the general provision while sections 46 and 46A are special provisions.

Incomes to be taxed under the head, ‘Capital Gains’

Thus, the following incomes are taxable as ‘capital gains’:

The situs/location of capital asset matters only for non-resident assessees and not to others. In the cases of Non-resident assessees, if capital asset located outside India is transferred outside India and sale proceeds are received outside India, no taxability to capital gains arises in view of section 5 of the Act. Such assessees will be liable to be taxed under section 9(1) (i) in respect of capital gains accruing or arising “through the transfer of any capital asset situate in India”.

Important Definitions in capital gains

Meaning of Transfer [Section 2(47)]

“Transfer”, in relation to a capital asset, includes:

(i) Sale, exchange or relinquishment of the asset;

(ii) Extinguishment of any rights in relation to a capital asset;

(iii) Compulsory acquisition of an asset;

(iv) Conversion of capital asset into stock-in-trade;

(v) Maturity or redemption of a zero coupon bond;

(vi) Allowing possession of immovable properties to the buyer in part performance of the contract;

(vii) Any transaction which has the effect of transferring an (or enabling the enjoyment of) immovable property; or

(viii) Disposing of or parting with an asset or any interest therein or creating any interest in any asset in any manner whatsoever.

Transactions which are not regarded as transfer [Section 47]

Following transactions shall not be regarded as transfer (subject to certain condition). Hence, following transaction shall not be charged to capital gains:

Full Value of Consideration

Full value of consideration is the consideration received or receivable by the transferor in lieu of assets, which he has transferred. Such consideration may be received in cash or in kind. If it is received in kind, then fair market value (‘FMV’) of such assets shall be taken as full value of consideration.

However, in the following cases “full value of the consideration” shall be determined on notional basis as per the relevant provisions of the Income-tax Act, 1961:

Cost of Acquisition

Cost of acquisition of an asset is the amount for which it was originally acquired by the assessee. It includes expenses of capital nature incurred in connection with such purchase or for completing the title of the property.

However, in cases given below, cost of acquisition shall be computed on notional basis:

* Terminal Depreciation/Balancing Charge:

1. a) Balancing Charge = Sales Consideration – WDV of the depreciable asset
2. b) Terminal Depreciation = WDV – Sales Consideration

Foreign currency cash flows:

• Record cash flows (those cash flows which arise from transactions in foreign currency) in functional currency.
• Cash flows of a foreign subsidiary shall be translated at the exchange rates between functional currency and foreign currency.
• Exchange rate at the date of cash flows shall be applied. Ind AS 21 permits the use of exchange rate that approximates the actual rate.
• Unrealized gains and losses arising from changes in foreign currency exchange rates are not cash flows. However, the effect of exchange rate changes on cash and cash equivalents is reported in the statement of cash flows in order to reconcile cash and cash equivalents at the beginning and the end of the period. This amount is presented separately from cash flows from operating, investing and financing activities.

Change in ownership (no such concept under AS 3):

1. Cash flows from obtaining / losing control in businesses (including subsidiary) shall be presented separately and classified as Investing activity and disclose the following:

• Total amount of consideration
• Portion of consideration consisting of cash and cash equivalents
• Amount of cash and cash equivalent over which control is obtained / lost
• Assets and liabilities (other than cash and cash equivalent) over which control is obtained / lost summarised in each major category.

2. Cash flow effects of losing control are not deducted from those of obtaining control.
3. Cash paid / received as consideration is reported net of cash and cash equivalents acquired / disposed on account of such transaction.
4. Cash flows arising from changes in ownership in subsidiary that do not result in a loss of control shall be classified as cash flows from financing activities, unless subsidiary is held by investment entity.

Non-cash Transactions:

Many investing and financing activities do not impact cash flows although they do affect the capital and asset structure of an entity. These shall be excluded from the statement of cash flows. Examples:

• Acquisition of assets by means of a finance lease;
• Conversion of debt to equity.
• Issue of bonus shares
• Conversion of term loan into equity shares

Such transactions shall be disclosed in the financial statements indicating investing / financing activity.

Changes in liabilities arising from financing activities (It was an amendment in Ind AS 7 and this provision was not there in AS 3):
• An entity shall provide the following disclosures to evaluate changes in liabilities arising from financing activities including both changes arising from cash flows and non-cash changes:
o changes from financing cash flows
o changes arising from obtaining or losing control of subsidiaries or other businesses;
o the effect of changes in foreign exchange rates;
o changes in fair values; and
o other changes.
• It also applies to changes in financial assets (for example, assets that hedge liabilities arising from financing activities) if cash flows from those financial assets included in cash flows from financing activities.
• Disclosure requirement can be fulfilled by: Reconciliation between the opening and closing balances in the balance sheet for liabilities arising from financing activities.
• If an entity discloses the same with disclosures of changes in other assets and liabilities, it shall disclose financing activities separately.
Disclosures:
• Components of cash and cash equivalents and reconciliation with amount appearing in balance sheet
• Policy adopted in determining composition of cash and cash equivalents
• Significant cash and cash equivalent that are not available for use by the entity (with commentary by management).
Examples: balance in unpaid dividend account, bank balance subject to legal restrictions, earmarked balances, bank balance for share application money / pending allotment of shares.
• Additional information (optional but standard encouraged the following disclosure):
o amount of undrawn borrowing facilities (indicating any restrictions on use)
o cash flows representing increases in operating capacity separately from cash flows required to maintain operating capacity;
o cash flows from operating, investing and financing activities of each reportable segment (same is required by Ind AS 108).

Demat System (short for Dematerialization system) refers to the process of converting physical share certificates into electronic form, enabling investors to hold and trade shares digitally through a dematerialized account. Introduced in India in 1996, the dematerialization process revolutionized the stock market by eliminating the need for physical certificates, streamlining the trading process, and making securities transactions safer, faster, and more efficient. The demat system is managed by depositories such as the National Securities Depository Limited (NSDL) and Central Depository Services Limited (CDSL), which function under the regulation of the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI).

Key Features of the Demat System

• Electronic Form of Securities:

In the demat system, shares, bonds, debentures, and other securities are held in electronic form, eliminating the need for physical certificates. This offers ease of access and ensures that investors can quickly buy, sell, and transfer securities.

• Demat Account:

Similar to a bank account for money, a demat account is an electronic account where securities are stored. Each investor must open a demat account with a Depository Participant (DP), such as a bank, brokerage firm, or financial institution. The DP acts as an intermediary between the investor and the depository (NSDL or CDSL).

• Speed and Efficiency:

Dematerialization process allows for faster trading and settlement of securities. Before dematerialization, the physical transfer of shares took weeks or even months, involving paperwork and delays. Now, transactions are completed in a few days, with real-time updates.

• Safety and Security:

Holding securities in dematerialized form reduces the risk of theft, loss, forgery, and damage associated with physical certificates. The electronic form ensures greater transparency, and investors can track their holdings online through their demat account.

• No Stamp Duty:

No stamp duty is charged on the transfer of dematerialized securities, reducing transaction costs for investors.

• Nomination Facility:

Investors can assign a nominee to their demat account, ensuring that in the event of the account holder’s death, the securities are smoothly transferred to the designated individual.

• Multiple Securities in One Account:

In a demat account, an investor can hold various types of securities, such as shares, bonds, mutual funds, and government securities, in a single account, which offers greater convenience.

Process of Dematerialization:

Dematerialization is the process of converting physical share certificates into electronic form.

1. Opening a Demat Account:

An investor must first open a demat account with a Depository Participant (DP) by filling out an account opening form and submitting the required Know Your Customer (KYC) documents such as proof of identity, proof of address, and a PAN card.

DP provides the investor with a unique Beneficiary Owner Identification (BO ID) number, which is used to identify the account holder in all transactions.

2. Submission of Physical Certificates:

   • After opening a demat account, the investor submits the physical share certificates they wish to dematerialize to the DP along with a Dematerialization Request Form (DRF).
   • The DRF includes details such as the company’s name, the number of shares, and the certificate numbers.

3. Verification and Approval:

   • The DP sends the physical certificates to the relevant company’s Registrar and Transfer Agent (RTA) for verification.
   • Once verified, the RTA approves the dematerialization request, and the physical certificates are canceled.

4. Credit to the Demat Account:

   • After the RTA’s approval, the depository (NSDL or CDSL) credits the corresponding number of shares to the investor’s demat account.
   • The investor receives a notification confirming that the shares have been successfully dematerialized and credited to their account.

5. Trading of Dematerialized Securities:

After dematerialization, the shares can be bought, sold, and transferred electronically through the stock exchanges. Investors can monitor their holdings and transactions online, with settlement occurring in a shorter time frame (T+2 days, where T is the trading day).

Advantages of the Demat System:

• Elimination of Physical Risks:

In the physical form, share certificates were vulnerable to theft, forgery, loss, and damage. The demat system eliminates these risks by holding securities electronically, ensuring safety and security.

• Reduction in Paperwork:

Demat system removes the need for paperwork related to the issuance, transfer, and maintenance of share certificates. This reduces administrative burdens and streamlines the entire process for companies and investors alike.

• Faster Settlement of Trades:

In the pre-demat era, transferring shares involved a lengthy process of physical delivery, verification, and approval, taking several weeks. Now, trades are settled electronically within two days (T+2 settlement), ensuring faster and more efficient transactions.

• Lower Transaction Costs:

By eliminating physical transfers, the demat system reduces costs associated with paperwork, stamp duties, courier charges, and handling fees. Investors benefit from lower transaction costs, making trading more cost-effective.

• Enhanced Liquidity:

Dematerialization has enhanced liquidity in the stock market. Shares held in electronic form can be quickly and easily traded, increasing market efficiency and providing investors with greater flexibility.

• Access to a Broader Range of Securities:

Through a demat account, investors can hold a variety of securities, such as equity shares, bonds, debentures, government securities, mutual funds, and exchange-traded funds (ETFs), all in one place, offering convenience and diversification.

• Transparency and Monitoring:

Investors can easily monitor their holdings, transactions, and portfolio through online access to their demat account. Real-time updates ensure transparency in the management of securities.

• Simplified Pledging of Securities:

Securities held in a demat account can be pledged for loans, offering liquidity to investors. The dematerialized form makes it easier to pledge shares with financial institutions for credit or loan purposes.

Disadvantages of the Demat System:

• Technological Dependency:

Demat system relies on technology, and any system failures or glitches can disrupt trading and access to accounts. Cybersecurity threats and hacking risks are also present in the digital environment.

• Charges and Fees:

While the demat system reduces some costs, investors must pay account maintenance fees, transaction charges, and other service fees to the DP. These charges can add up over time, especially for small investors.

• Loss of Paper Certificates:

Some investors may still prefer holding physical certificates for sentimental reasons or for tangible proof of ownership. The transition to a demat system eliminates the physical representation of ownership.

• Fraud Risks:

Although the Demat system reduces physical fraud risks, it is not immune to other types of fraud, such as unauthorized access to demat accounts, hacking, or insider fraud.

Legal Framework for the Demat System in India

• Depositories Act, 1996:

This act provides the legal framework for the establishment of depositories and facilitates the dematerialization of securities.

• SEBI (Depositories and Participants) Regulations, 1996:

These regulations lay down the rules for the functioning of depositories and DPs.

• SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015:

Companies listed on stock exchanges must ensure that their securities are available for trading in dematerialized form.

Understanding your roles and responsibilities should be your first task when appointed. The board of directors is appointed to act on behalf of the shareholders to run the day to day affairs of the business. The board are directly accountable to the shareholders and each year the company will hold an annual general meeting (AGM) at which the directors must provide a report to shareholders on the performance of the company, what its future plans and strategies are and also submit themselves for re-election to the board.

The objects of the company are defined in the Memorandum of Association and regulations are laid out in the Articles of Association.

The board of directors’ key purpose is to ensure the company’s prosperity by collectively directing the company’s affairs, whilst meeting the appropriate interests of its shareholders and stakeholders. In addition to business and financial issues, boards of directors must deal with challenges and issues relating to corporate governance, corporate social responsibility and corporate ethics.

It is important that board meetings are held periodically so that directors can discharge their responsibility to control the company’s overall situation, strategy and policy, and to monitor the exercise of any delegated authority, and so that individual directors can report on their particular areas of responsibility.

Every meeting must have a chair, whose duties are to ensure that the meeting is conducted in such a way that the business for which it was convened is properly attended to, and that all those entitled to may express their views and that the decisions taken by the meeting adequately reflect the views of the meeting as a whole. The chair will also very often decide upon the agenda and might sign off the minutes on his or her own authority.

Individual directors have only those powers which have been given to them by the board. Such authority need not be specific or in writing and may be inferred from past practice. However, the board as a whole remains responsible for actions carried out by its authority and it should therefore ensure that executive authority is only granted to appropriate persons and that adequate reporting systems enable it to maintain overall control.

The chairman of the board is often seen as the spokesperson for the board and the company.

Appointment of directors

The ultimate control as to the composition of the board of directors rests with the shareholders, who can always appoint, and more importantly, sometimes dismiss a director. The shareholders can also fix the minimum and maximum number of directors. However, the board can usually appoint (but not dismiss) a director to his office as well. A director may be dismissed from office by a majority vote of the shareholders, provided that a special procedure is followed. The procedure is complex, and legal advice will always be required.

Roles of the board of directors

The roles of the board of directors include:

Establish vision, mission and values

• Determine the company’s vision and mission to guide and set the pace for its current operations and future development.
• Determine the values to be promoted throughout the company.
• Determine and review company goals.
• Determine company policies

Set strategy and structure

• Review and evaluate present and future opportunities, threats and risks in the external environment and current and future strengths, weaknesses and risks relating to the company.
• Determine strategic options, select those to be pursued, and decide the means to implement and support them.
• Determine the business strategies and plans that underpin the corporate strategy.
• Ensure that the company’s organizational structure and capability are appropriate for implementing the chosen strategies.
• PEST and SWOT analyses
• Determining strategic options
• Strategies and plans

Delegate to management

• Delegate authority to management, and monitor and evaluate the implementation of policies, strategies and business plans.
• Determine monitoring criteria to be used by the board.
• Ensure that internal controls are effective.
• Communicate with senior management.

Exercise accountability to shareholders and be responsible to relevant stakeholders

• Ensure that communications both to and from shareholders and relevant stakeholders are effective.
• Understand and take into account the interests of shareholders and relevant stakeholders.
• Monitor relations with shareholders and relevant stakeholders by gathering and evaluation of appropriate information.
• Promote the goodwill and support of shareholders and relevant stakeholders.

Responsibilities of directors

Directors look after the affairs of the company, and are in a position of trust. They might abuse their position in order to profit at the expense of their company, and, therefore, at the expense of the shareholders of the company.

Consequently, the law imposes a number of duties, burdens and responsibilities upon directors, to prevent abuse. Much of company law can be seen as a balance between allowing directors to manage the company’s business so as to make a profit, and preventing them from abusing this freedom.

Directors are responsible for ensuring that proper books of account are kept.

In some circumstances, a director can be required to help pay the debts of his company, even though it is a separate legal person. For example, directors of a company who try to ‘trade out of difficulty’ and fail may be found guilty of ‘wrongful trading’ and can be made personally liable. Directors are particularly vulnerable if they have acted in a way which benefits themselves.

• The directors must always exercise their powers for a ‘proper purpose’ – that is, in furtherance of the reason for which they were given those powers by the shareholders.
• Directors must act in good faith in what they honestly believe to be the best interests of the company, and not for any collateral purpose. This means that, particularly in the event of a conflict of interest between the company’s interests and their own, the directors must always favour the company.
• Directors must act with due skill and care.
• Directors must consider the interests of employees of the company.

Calling a directors’ meeting

A director, or the secretary at the request of a director, may call a directors’ meeting. A secretary may not call a meeting unless requested to do so by a director or the directors. Each director must be given reasonable notice of the meeting, stating its date, time and place. Commonly, seven days is given but what is ‘reasonable’ depends in the last resort on the circumstances

Non-executive directors

Legally speaking, there is no distinction between an executive and non-executive director. Yet there is inescapably a sense that the non-executive’s role can be seen as balancing that of the executive director, so as to ensure the board as a whole functions effectively. Where the executive director has an intimate knowledge of the company, the non-executive director may be expected to have a wider perspective of the world at large.

The chairman of the board

The articles usually provide for the election of a chairman of the board. They empower the directors to appoint one of their own number as chairman and to determine the period for which he is to hold office. If no chairman is elected, or the elected chairman is not present within five minutes of the time fixed for the meeting or is unwilling to preside, those directors in attendance may usually elect one of their number as chairman of the meeting.

The chairman will usually have a second or casting vote in the case of equality of votes. Unless the articles confer such a vote upon him, however, a chairman has no casting vote merely by virtue of his office.

Since the chairman’s position is of great importance, it is vital that his election is clearly in accordance with any special procedure laid down by the articles and that it is unambiguously minuted; this is especially important to avoid disputes as to his period in office. Usually there is no special procedure for resignation. As for removal, articles usually empower the board to remove the chairman from office at any time. Proper and clear minutes are important in order to avoid disputes.

Role of the chairman

The chairman’s role includes managing the board’s business and acting as its facilitator and guide. This can include:

• Determining board composition and organisation;
• Clarifying board and management responsibilities;
• Planning and managing board and board committee meetings;
• Developing the effectiveness of the board.

Find out more about director development and training.

Shadow directors

In many circumstances, the law applies not only to a director, but to a ‘shadow director’. A shadow director is a person in accordance with whose directions or instructions the directors of a company are accustomed to act. Under this definition, it is possible that a director, or the whole board, of a holding company, and the holding company itself, could be treated as a shadow director of a subsidiary.

Professional advisers giving advice in their professional capacity are specifically excluded from the definition of a shadow director in the companies legislation.

Dividends are a portion of a company’s profits distributed to its shareholders as a reward for their investment in the company. The decision to declare dividends is made by the board of directors, but the process is governed by several legal and regulatory frameworks to ensure fairness, transparency, and adherence to corporate governance norms. In India, the declaration and distribution of dividends are primarily regulated by the Companies Act, 2013, along with rules set forth by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) for listed companies.

Meaning and Types of Dividends:

Dividend is a return on investment for shareholders, paid from the profits of the company. It can be issued in several forms:

1. Interim Dividend:

Declared by the board of directors during the financial year before the finalization of accounts. This is typically paid out of the profits earned during the current financial year.

2. Final Dividend:

Declared at the company’s Annual General Meeting (AGM) after the financial year has ended and the accounts are finalized. It is recommended by the board but requires shareholder approval.

3. Special Dividend:

Paid in extraordinary circumstances when the company has a significant surplus of profits or cash. This dividend is not a regular payout.

4. Stock Dividend (Bonus Shares):

Instead of cash, the company issues additional shares to its shareholders in proportion to their existing holdings.

5. Scrip Dividend:

The company issues a promissory note to the shareholders, promising to pay the dividend at a later date, which can be considered a form of deferred payment.

Legal Provisions for Declaration of Dividends Under the Companies Act, 2013

The provisions governing the declaration and distribution of dividends are laid down under Section 123 of the Companies Act, 2013, along with the Companies (Declaration and Payment of Dividend) Rules, 2014.

1. Declaration of Dividend

Profit Requirement:

Dividends can only be declared out of the following:

• • Current year profits after providing for depreciation and any necessary reserves.
  • Previous year profits that have not been transferred to reserves or used for dividends earlier.
  • Government Grant: If a company has received government assistance in certain situations, this may be considered in specific circumstances.

Free Reserves:

If the company’s profits are insufficient, it can declare a dividend out of its accumulated profits or free reserves, provided that:

• • The rate of dividend does not exceed the average rate of dividends declared in the preceding three financial years.

  • The amount withdrawn from the reserves is not more than 10% of the paid-up share capital and free reserves of the company.

Interim Dividend:

The board may declare an interim dividend out of profits available after providing for depreciation. However, if the company suffers a loss up to the quarter immediately preceding the interim dividend declaration, the interim dividend cannot be declared at a rate higher than the average dividend declared during the preceding three financial years.

2. Depreciation

• The company must provide for depreciation in accordance with Schedule II of the Companies Act, 2013 before declaring dividends.
• Any dividend declared without taking into account depreciation can be considered illegal and can attract penalties for the company and its directors.

3. Transfer to Reserves

Before declaring dividends, companies are required to transfer a certain percentage of their profits to reserves, as per the discretion of the board of directors. However, the Companies Act no longer mandates a specific minimum percentage to be transferred.

4. Dividend on Preference Shares

Preference shareholders are entitled to dividends at a fixed rate before any dividends are declared for equity shareholders. The dividend for preference shares must be paid first, and any arrears of preference dividends must be cleared if applicable.

5. Payment in Cash

Dividends must be paid in cash, cheque, or electronic means. A company cannot declare dividends in kind (i.e., through assets). However, stock dividends (bonus shares) are permissible.

6. Dividend Distribution Tax (DDT)

Finance Act, 2020, abolished the Dividend Distribution Tax (DDT). Earlier, companies were required to pay tax on the dividends distributed. Now, shareholders are liable to pay tax on the dividends they receive based on their individual income tax slabs.

7. Timeframe for Payment

Once a dividend is declared at the AGM, the company must pay the dividend to the shareholders within 30 days from the date of declaration. If the company fails to do so, it attracts penalties and interest charges.

8. Unpaid or Unclaimed Dividend

• If a dividend remains unpaid or unclaimed for 30 days from the date of declaration, it must be transferred to a special Unpaid Dividend Account within 7 days of the expiration of the 30-day period.
• If the dividend remains unclaimed for seven years, it must be transferred to the Investor Education and Protection Fund (IEPF).

Process for Dividend Distribution:

1. Board Meeting:

The process begins with a board meeting where the directors review the financial performance of the company. Based on profitability and liquidity, the board decides whether to recommend a dividend to the shareholders.

2. Declaration at AGM:

In the case of a final dividend, the declaration is made at the Annual General Meeting (AGM) of the company. The shareholders must approve the dividend recommended by the board. Without this approval, the company cannot distribute the dividend.

3. Record Date:

Company must set a record date, which is the cut-off date for determining the shareholders who are entitled to receive the dividend. Only those shareholders whose names appear in the company’s register on this date are eligible for the dividend.

4. Payment of Dividend:

Dividend can be paid via cheque, demand draft, or electronic transfer. The payment must be completed within 30 days of the declaration, failing which the company is subject to penalties.

Penalties for Non-Compliance:

Failure to comply with the rules regarding dividend declaration and distribution can result in penalties for both the company and its officers.

• Imprisonment and Fines:

Under Section 127 of the Companies Act, if the company fails to pay the dividend within 30 days of its declaration, every director who is knowingly a party to this default may be punished with imprisonment for up to 2 years and a fine of ₹1,000 for each day the default continues.

• Interest:

In case of a delayed payment, the company is liable to pay interest on the unpaid dividend at the rate of 18% per annum until the payment is made.

‘Underwriting’ refers to the functions of an under-writer. An under-writer may be an individual, firm or a joint stock company, performing the under-writing function. Under-writing may be defined as a contract entered into by the company with persons or institutions, called under-writers, who undertake to take up the whole or a portion of such of the offered shares or debentures as may not be subscribed for by the public. Such agreements are called ‘Under-writing agreement’.

Underwriting services are provided by some large financial institutions, such as banks, insurance companies and investment houses, whereby they guarantee payment in case of damage or financial loss and accept the financial risk for liability arising from such guarantee. An underwriting arrangement may be created in a number of situations including insurance, issues of security in a public offering, and bank lending, among others. The person or institution that agrees to sell a minimum number of securities of the company for commission is called the Underwriter.

A newly formed company enters into an agreement with an under-writer to the effect that he will take up shares or Debentures offered by it to the public but not subscribed for in fully by the public. Such an agreement may become necessary when a company issues shares or debentures for the first time to the public, or subsequently when it is in need of working capital.

When the company does not receive 90 per cent of issued amount from public subscription, within 120 days from the date of opening the issue, the company cannot proceed with allotment. In such a case, the company must refund the amount of subscription. In the case of a new company, it cannot obtain a certificate to commence function.

A company is not sure whether the shares or debentures offered for subscription may be taken up by the public. There arises a risk to ensure the success of issue. Therefore, companies resort to underwriting in order to ensure that sufficient number of shares or debentures would subscribed for. Thus, risk-bearing or uncertainty bearing is an important function of an underwriter.

Thus, an underwriter is a person who undertakes to take up the whole or a portion of the shares or debentures offered by a company to the public for subscription as may not be subscribed for by the public, prior to making such an offer. The company has to pay a commission to such an underwriter. It is known as underwriting commission. It is, of course, a type of insurance against under-subscription.

Need for underwriting

Investigate your credit history. Underwriters look at your credit score and pull your credit report. They look at your overall credit score and search for things like late payments, bankruptcies, overuse of credit and more.

Order an appraisal. Your underwriter will order an appraisal to make sure that the amount that the lender offers for the home matches up with the home’s actual value.

Verify your income and employment. Your underwriter will ask you to prove your income and employment situation.

Look at your debt-to-income ratio (DTI). Your DTI is a percentage that tells lenders how much money you spend versus how much income you bring in. An underwriter examines your debts and compares them to your income to ensure you have more than enough cash flow to cover your monthly mortgage payments, taxes and insurance.

Verify your down payment and savings. The underwriter also looks at your savings accounts to make sure you have enough savings to supplement your income or to use as a down payment at closing.

Functions of a Broker in Underwriting:

Broker is a person who helps in subscribing the shares. A broker is one who finds buyers for the shares or debentures of the company and gets the brokerage on the number of shares or debentures subscribed by the public through him. Underwriter is different from a broker. An underwriter is a person who agrees to take a specified number of shares or debentures, in case, not subscribed by the public.

That is, an underwriter is liable to take up shares in case the public fails to subscribe whereas a broker is not liable. Underwriter gets underwriting commission and a broker gets brokerage. Underwriter gives a guarantee whereas a broker does the service of placing the shares.

Thus, the function of an underwriter is of great economic significance since he himself assumes the risk of uncertainty on behalf of the company making public issue of shares or debentures. A broker, on the other hand, does not assume any such risk. Underwriting acts as a sort of insurance or guarantee against the danger of not receiving minimum subscription.

Sub Underwriting:

An underwriter may himself enter into a sub-agreement with other persons, called sub- underwriters, whereby he transfers a part of his underwriting risk. Just like re-insurance, sub- underwriting helps in spreading the risk. An underwriter may appoint several underwriters to work under him. However, the sub-underwriters have no privacy of contract with the company. They get their commission from the underwriter and are also responsible to him.

Importance of Underwriting:

1. Underwriting acts as a sort of insurance or guarantee against the danger of not receiving minimum subscription, in the absence of underwriting agreement, there is always uncertainty regarding subscription of shares of debentures by the public. The guarantee of the underwriters removes the uncertainty.
2. When shares or debentures are sold through underwriters, there arise more confidence amongst the public. This is because underwriters undertake shares or debentures of only those companies which are sound concerns and whose future is bright.
3. Underwriting creates an impression regarding sound status of a company. It increases the goodwill of the company.

Promoter occupies a unique and pivotal position in the process of company formation. They play a crucial role in turning a business idea into reality by undertaking various activities that culminate in the incorporation of a company. Despite not being formally recognized as an officer or agent of the company in the legal sense, the promoter holds a position of trust and responsibility. Their duties, powers, and liabilities are shaped by their relationship with the company they promote, and this relationship is regulated by principles of equity and statutory provisions under the Companies Act, 2013.

Role and Position of Promoter:

The promoter is neither an employee nor an agent of the company because the company does not exist at the time of promotion. However, their role is fundamental, as they are responsible for all the preliminary actions that lead to the creation of the company. The legal framework places the promoter in a fiduciary position, meaning they are expected to act with honesty, integrity, and transparency.

1. Fiduciary Position of the Promoter

Promoters are considered fiduciaries to the company they are forming. A fiduciary is a person entrusted with the responsibility of acting in the best interest of another party—in this case, the prospective company. As fiduciaries, promoters are bound by a duty of loyalty and good faith toward the company and its future shareholders.

• Acting in Good Faith:

The promoter must act honestly and with loyalty toward the interests of the company. They should not exploit their position for personal gains at the expense of the company.

• Avoiding Conflicts of Interest:

Promoters must avoid any situation where their personal interests conflict with the interests of the company. If a promoter stands to gain personally from a transaction, they must fully disclose this to the company’s shareholders.

• Full Disclosure of Material Facts:

If the promoter stands to gain from any contracts or arrangements they enter into on behalf of the company, they must fully disclose these facts to the future shareholders or directors. Failure to disclose any such interests could lead to legal consequences.

The fiduciary duty of a promoter begins from the moment they start engaging in activities aimed at forming the company and extends until the company is fully incorporated and operational. Any breach of fiduciary duty can result in legal action by the company or its shareholders, either to rescind contracts or seek compensation.

2. Legal Rights of the Promoter

Despite their fiduciary obligations, promoters do have certain legal rights:

• Right to Remuneration:

Promoters are entitled to be compensated for their efforts and expenses incurred during the promotion stage. However, there is no automatic right to payment; they can only receive remuneration if it is specifically agreed upon with the company. This could take the form of cash, shares, or debentures.

• Right to Reimbursement:

Promoters have the right to be reimbursed for any legitimate expenses incurred in the course of forming the company. This includes legal fees, registration charges, and costs associated with conducting feasibility studies and market research.

3. Liabilities of the Promoter

In addition to fiduciary duties, promoters also face certain legal liabilities. These liabilities primarily arise from the pre-incorporation contracts they enter into and their conduct during the promotion stage.

• Liability for Pre-Incorporation Contracts:

Since the company does not legally exist during the promotion stage, any contracts the promoter enters into on behalf of the company are not legally binding on the company. These are known as pre-incorporation contracts. As a result, promoters may be held personally liable for any obligations arising out of these contracts unless the company, after incorporation, adopts the contracts or a novation (transfer of the contract) takes place.

For instance, if a promoter enters into a contract to buy property or equipment before the company is incorporated, they are personally liable for fulfilling the terms of the contract unless the company agrees to adopt it after incorporation. If the company refuses or is unable to do so, the promoter can be held accountable.

• Liability for Misrepresentation:

Promoters may also be held liable for misrepresentation or fraud if they provide false information in the company’s prospectus or fail to disclose material facts to investors. If investors suffer losses due to such misrepresentation, the promoter may face legal action, including claims for damages.

The Companies Act, 2013, provides stringent measures to protect investors from fraudulent promoters. If a promoter is found guilty of making misleading statements or withholding important information in the prospectus, they may face criminal prosecution, civil liability, and penalties.

• Personal Liability in Case of Failure to Incorporate:

If the promoter fails to complete the incorporation process, they may be held personally liable for any obligations incurred during the promotion stage. The company does not exist yet, and therefore, the promoter is solely responsible for all actions and debts until the company is legally registered.

4. Promoter’s Role Post-Incorporation

The role of the promoter typically diminishes once the company is incorporated. However, some promoters may choose to continue their involvement in the company by becoming directors, shareholders, or holding other managerial positions. In such cases, their relationship with the company changes from that of a promoter to a director or officer, where they take on additional responsibilities under company law.

Once the company is incorporated, the promoter’s primary role as the originator of the business idea is complete. However, any breach of fiduciary duty or misconduct during the promotion stage can still lead to legal consequences post-incorporation.

Promotion Stage is the initial and one of the most crucial stages in the formation of a company. It involves the conceptualization of a business idea, planning the structure, and taking necessary actions to bring the company into existence. The Companies Act, 2013 governs the legal aspects of company promotion in India. A promoter or group of promoters initiates this process, and they play a significant role in establishing the foundation of the business.

Who is a Promoter?

Promoter is an individual or a group of individuals responsible for identifying a business opportunity and taking necessary steps to incorporate the company. They undertake essential functions like assembling resources, handling legal formalities, and launching the company. The promoter is the first point of contact for the company’s incorporation.

Stages in Company Promotion

Stage 1. Discovery of Business Idea

The first step in promotion is the discovery of a business idea. The promoter identifies a business opportunity by studying market demand, availability of resources, and profit potential. The idea must be innovative, practical, and economically viable. This stage lays the foundation of the company and determines the nature and objectives of the proposed business.

Stage 2. Detailed Investigation and Feasibility Study

After identifying the idea, the promoter conducts a detailed investigation to assess feasibility. This includes technical, financial, commercial, and legal feasibility studies. Market research is carried out to analyze demand, competition, cost structure, and profitability. This step helps in minimizing risk and ensures that the proposed company has strong chances of success.

Stage 3. Decision to Form a Company

Once feasibility is confirmed, the promoter decides to form a company. This includes choosing the type of company such as private, public, or one person company. Decisions regarding capital structure, scale of operations, and location of business are also made. This stage transforms the business idea into a concrete plan of action.

Stage 4. Selection of Name

The promoter selects a suitable name for the proposed company. The name should be unique, lawful, and not identical or similar to existing companies. It must comply with the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013 and be approved by the Registrar of Companies. The name reflects the company’s identity and objectives.

Stage 5. Preparation of Memorandum and Articles of Association

At this stage, the promoter prepares the Memorandum of Association and Articles of Association. The Memorandum defines the objectives and scope of activities, while the Articles contain internal rules and regulations. These documents are essential for incorporation and determine the company’s relationship with outsiders and members.

Stage 6. Appointment of Professional Experts

Promoters appoint professionals such as chartered accountants, company secretaries, advocates, and valuers. These experts assist in drafting documents, obtaining approvals, and ensuring legal compliance. Their role is vital in completing technical and legal formalities accurately and efficiently during the promotion stage.

Stage 7. Raising Initial Capital

The promoter makes arrangements for raising initial capital required for incorporation and preliminary expenses. Capital may be raised through personal funds, private investors, or initial subscriptions. In case of public companies, preliminary steps for issue of shares may also be taken. Adequate capital is essential for smooth incorporation and initial operations.

Stage 8. Other Preliminary Contracts

During the promotion stage, promoters may enter into preliminary contracts for purchase of assets, appointment of personnel, or acquisition of property. These contracts are necessary for future operations. Although such contracts are entered into before incorporation, they may be adopted by the company after incorporation.

Responsibilities of a Promoter

1. Conceiving the Business Idea

The promoter identifies a viable business idea, evaluates market potential, and develops a plan to transform the idea into a successful business venture. This includes researching industry trends, customer needs, and potential competitors.

2. Feasibility Study

Before proceeding, the promoter conducts a thorough feasibility study to assess whether the business is practical and profitable. The study includes:

• Technical Feasibility: Evaluating whether the technology or resources required for the business are available.
• Financial Feasibility: Assessing the capital needed, potential sources of funding, expected profitability, and break-even point.
• Economic Feasibility: Evaluating the broader economic environment, government regulations, and market demand.

3. Business Plan Preparation

The promoter prepares a comprehensive business plan that outlines the company’s objectives, strategies, organizational structure, products or services, and market analysis. This plan serves as a blueprint for the future development of the company.

4. Arranging Capital

A crucial role of the promoter is to arrange for the necessary capital to launch the business. The promoter may use personal savings, approach investors, or obtain loans from financial institutions to raise the initial funding required. The amount of capital needed depends on the scale and nature of the business.

5. Assembling a Team of Directors

The promoter identifies individuals who will be responsible for the company’s management and operational activities. This typically involves the selection of directors, who are then appointed to lead the company in key decision-making processes.

6. Selection of Company Name

The promoter is responsible for choosing a suitable name for the company. The name must be unique and comply with the naming guidelines under the Companies Act, 2013. The promoter applies for the company’s name reservation through the Reserve Unique Name (RUN) service of the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA). The selected name must not infringe on any existing trademarks or company names.

7. Drafting Legal Documents

Promoters play a vital role in the preparation of the company’s foundational legal documents:

• Memorandum of Association (MoA): This document outlines the company’s objectives, scope of activities, and its relationship with external parties. It includes clauses such as the company’s name, registered office, object, and liability clauses.
• Articles of Association (AoA): This document contains the rules and regulations for the company’s internal management, including the responsibilities of directors and shareholders, meeting procedures, and voting rights.

8. Legal Compliances and Preliminary Contracts

The promoter ensures that all legal formalities are completed before the company’s incorporation. This includes obtaining necessary approvals, licenses, and permissions from government authorities.

• Preliminary Contracts:

Sometimes, the promoter enters into agreements (pre-incorporation contracts) with third parties on behalf of the company, such as for the purchase of property, hiring personnel, or acquiring machinery. These contracts become binding on the company only after its incorporation.

9. Negotiating with Stakeholders

In addition to raising capital, the promoter negotiates with key stakeholders, including vendors, suppliers, and service providers, to establish favorable terms of business.

10. Filing the Incorporation Documents

Once the necessary preparations are made, the promoter submits the incorporation documents to the Registrar of Companies (RoC). This includes filing the Memorandum and Articles of Association, details of directors and shareholders, and other necessary forms such as SPICe+.

Role of Promoters in Liability

While promoters are crucial to the formation of a company, they also hold significant liability during the promotion stage:

• Fiduciary Duty

Promoters are legally bound to act in the best interests of the future company. They must not exploit their position for personal gain and must disclose any conflicts of interest to the prospective shareholders.

• Personal Liability for Preliminary Contracts

If the company is not incorporated or if it refuses to adopt the preliminary contracts, the promoter may be held personally liable for such contracts unless they are explicitly transferred to the company post-incorporation.

Incorporation Stage is a crucial phase in the process of forming a company. It marks the legal birth of the company, transforming it from an idea into a separate legal entity. This stage involves complying with various legal formalities, submitting required documents, and receiving the certificate of incorporation, which officially recognizes the company as a distinct entity under the law. In India, the incorporation of companies is governed by the Companies Act, 2013, and the process is administered by the Registrar of Companies (RoC).

Importance of the Incorporation Stage:

The incorporation stage is the most vital step in the process of creating a company. It confers separate legal personality on the business, meaning the company can own property, enter into contracts, sue and be sued, and operate independently of its owners or shareholders. This separation between the company and its owners provides limited liability to shareholders, meaning their personal assets are protected from the company’s debts.

Without incorporation, a business would remain an informal entity with no legal status, and its owners would be personally liable for any obligations incurred by the business. Incorporation, therefore, formalizes the company’s existence and provides a legal framework for its governance and operations.

Steps in the Incorporation Stage:

Incorporating a company involves several legal steps that must be carefully followed to ensure compliance with the Companies Act.

1. Choosing the Type of Company

The first step in incorporation is to determine the type of company that will be formed. Common types of companies in India:

• Private Limited Company: Company with a restricted number of shareholders (up to 200), and shares cannot be freely transferred.
• Public Limited Company: Company that can offer its shares to the public and has no restriction on the number of shareholders.
• One Person Company (OPC): Company with only one shareholder, designed for sole proprietors who want limited liability.

The choice of company type affects the company’s governance structure, regulatory requirements, and ownership flexibility.

2. Choosing a Company Name

Selecting an appropriate name is an essential part of the incorporation process. The name must comply with the naming guidelines provided by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA). The company’s name should be unique, not identical to or too similar to existing companies, and should not violate any trademarks.

Promoters must file a name reservation request with the RoC, using RUN (Reserve Unique Name) or the SPICe+ form, to ensure the chosen name is available. Once approved, the name is reserved for a specified period during which the incorporation must be completed.

3. Drafting the Memorandum and Articles of Association

Memorandum of Association (MoA) and the Articles of Association (AoA) are critical documents that define the company’s structure, objectives, and internal rules.

• MoA:

This document outlines the company’s name, registered office, objectives, liability of shareholders, and share capital. It essentially defines the company’s scope of activities and its relationship with the outside world.

• AoA:

This document governs the internal management of the company, detailing how the company will be run, including rules for conducting meetings, appointing directors, and managing shares.

Both documents must be drafted carefully and submitted along with the incorporation application.

4. Filing Incorporation Documents with the Registrar

Promoter must file several key documents with the RoC to initiate the formal incorporation of the company. The primary document used for incorporation is the SPICe+ (Simplified Proforma for Incorporating Company Electronically Plus) form. This is an integrated web form that allows the company to apply for incorporation, PAN, TAN, GST registration, and other regulatory approvals in one streamlined process.

Documents required for submission include:

• SPICe+ form: Filled with details of the company, directors, and shareholders.
• MoA and AoA: Signed by all subscribers and witnesses.
• Consent to Act as Director (DIR-2): A declaration signed by each director agreeing to serve on the company’s board.
• Proof of Address: For the registered office of the company.
• Identity Proofs: Of all directors and shareholders, including PAN, passport, and Aadhar card.
• Director Identification Number (DIN): For the proposed directors.

5. Payment of Registration Fees

Promoter must pay the requisite registration fees to the RoC, which are calculated based on the authorized capital of the company. The higher the authorized capital, the higher the registration fee. This fee covers the costs associated with processing the incorporation documents and issuing the certificate of incorporation.

6. Verification and Approval by the Registrar

Once the documents are submitted and fees are paid, the RoC reviews the application. If all documents are in order and comply with the legal requirements, the RoC approves the incorporation and issues the certificate of incorporation. This certificate signifies that the company has been officially registered and has become a separate legal entity.

7. Obtaining the Certificate of Incorporation

Certificate of incorporation is the legal document that confirms the company’s formation. It includes the company’s name, CIN (Corporate Identification Number), and the date of incorporation. Once this certificate is issued, the company is legally recognized and can commence its business operations.

8. Post-Incorporation Formalities

After incorporation, the company must complete certain post-incorporation formalities, such as:

• Opening a Bank Account: In the company’s name.
• Issuing Share Certificates: To the subscribers of the MoA.
• Registering for Taxation: Such as GST and professional tax.
• Appointing Auditors: Within 30 days of incorporation.
• Holding the First Board Meeting: Within 30 days of incorporation.

Memorandum of Association (MoA) is a pivotal legal document that lays the foundation for the existence and functioning of a company. It defines the company’s relationship with the external world, setting out its objectives, operational scope, and boundaries. Every company in India is required to have an MoA, which must be submitted at the time of incorporation under the Companies Act, 2013.

MoA serves as a constitution for the company and provides clarity to shareholders, creditors, and third parties regarding the nature and purpose of the business. It outlines what the company can and cannot do, ensuring that its operations remain within defined legal limits. If a company acts beyond the powers outlined in the MoA, such actions are considered ultra vires (beyond the powers) and can be deemed invalid.

Features of Memorandum of Association

1. Defines Scope of Company’s Activities

The most crucial feature of the MoA is that it sets the boundaries within which the company can operate. The company must adhere to its stated objectives, and any activity outside these objectives is considered ultra vires. The MoA ensures that shareholders and external parties know the company’s exact scope of business.

2. Public Document

MoA is a public document once registered with the Registrar of Companies (RoC). This means that anyone, including shareholders, creditors, and the public, can inspect it to understand the company’s objectives and its operational limits. The transparency provided by the MoA allows stakeholders to assess whether the company is operating within its legal framework.

3. Binding on the Company and its Members

MoA serves as a contract between the company and its members (shareholders), as well as between the company and third parties. Once registered, both the company and its members are bound to the clauses of the MoA. Neither the company nor its members can act beyond the provisions of the MoA, ensuring compliance with legal requirements.

4. Contains Key Clauses

MoA consists of several important clauses, each serving a specific function. These are:

• Name Clause: Specifies the name of the company.
• Registered Office Clause: States the location of the company’s registered office.
• Object Clause: Defines the company’s main objectives and any incidental activities.
• Liability Clause: Limits the liability of shareholders.
• Capital Clause: Outlines the company’s authorized share capital.
• Subscription Clause: Lists the initial shareholders and the shares they agree to take up.

Each of these clauses is essential to the company’s structure and operation, and together they provide a complete picture of the company’s legal identity.

5. Rigid Document

MoA is a relatively rigid document that cannot be easily altered. Any changes to the MoA require approval by a special resolution of the shareholders, and in some cases, permission from external authorities, such as the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT). This rigidity ensures that the company’s core objectives and legal framework remain stable.

6. Governs Company’s External Relationships

The MoA plays a critical role in defining the company’s relationship with the external world. It clarifies the company’s legal existence, ensuring that third parties dealing with the company understand its objectives and limitations. This protects both the company and external parties from engaging in activities that could be outside the company’s legal powers.

Articles of Association

Articles of Association (AoA) is a fundamental legal document that governs the internal management of a company. While the Memorandum of Association (MoA) defines a company’s objectives and scope in relation to the external world, the AoA establishes the rules for how the company will conduct its internal affairs. It is a key document that defines the roles and responsibilities of directors, the decision-making process, and the rights and obligations of shareholders.

AoA serves as the company’s internal constitution, laying down the procedures for managing day-to-day operations, including how board meetings are conducted, how directors are appointed or removed, and how shares are issued or transferred. It is a flexible document, which means it can be altered to reflect the changing needs of the company, subject to legal approval.

Features of Articles of Association:

1. Regulates Internal Management

The primary function of the AoA is to regulate the internal management of the company. It outlines the governance framework, detailing the rights, responsibilities, and duties of the company’s directors, shareholders, and officers. This ensures that the company operates efficiently and in accordance with the agreed-upon rules.

For example, AoA may specify how meetings of the board or shareholders are to be convened, the quorum required for those meetings, and how decisions are to be made (simple majority, special resolution, etc.).

2. Defines Rights and Duties of Shareholders

AoA also clearly defines the rights and duties of shareholders, including how they can participate in company decisions. It lays down the voting rights of shareholders, dividend entitlements, and procedures for transferring shares. In the case of private limited companies, the AoA often places restrictions on share transfers to maintain control within a small group of shareholders.

This ensures transparency and provides shareholders with a clear understanding of their rights and the company’s procedures for major decisions.

3. Contractual Nature

AoA acts as a contract between the company and its members (shareholders), as well as among the members themselves. Once it is adopted, all members are legally bound by its provisions. It ensures that shareholders and the company are aligned in terms of governance rules and expectations.

For instance, a shareholder cannot claim ignorance of the rules or procedures set out in the AoA, as it forms a binding contract once the person becomes a shareholder.

4. Flexibility

AoA is more flexible. It can be altered as the company’s needs change over time. Changes to the AoA can be made by passing a special resolution at a general meeting of shareholders, where at least 75% of the members approve the changes.

This flexibility ensures that the company can adapt to changes in the business environment, its ownership structure, or its internal management needs.

5. Conforms to the Companies Act

AoA must be drafted in accordance with the Companies Act, 2013 in India. While companies are free to create their own internal rules, those rules cannot conflict with the provisions of the Companies Act or with the company’s Memorandum of Association.

For instance, a company cannot include provisions in the AoA that allow it to conduct business activities outside its object clause, as defined in the MoA.

6. Facilitates Corporate Governance

AoA plays a critical role in ensuring effective corporate governance. It lays down the framework for appointing directors, conducting board meetings, managing financial affairs, and ensuring compliance with the law. By establishing clear procedures and accountability mechanisms, the AoA ensures that the company operates smoothly and is less prone to conflicts or governance issues.

For example, the AoA may specify the procedure for appointing auditors, approving financial statements, or managing conflicts of interest within the board of directors.

Key differences between Memorandum of Association and Articles of Association