Tag: organizational culture

A static environment can quickly antiquate an organization. Therefore, change is a constant and necessary requirement for organizations to stay competitive and survive in this volatile global economy. Organizational change can help streamline business processes and eliminate redundant systems or groups. However, it can also have negative consequences. To minimize the negative impacts, strategic change in an organization should always seek to achieve advancement in both business and employee performance. The overall change process should reflect a “win-win” situation for both the organization and its employees.

The Process of Change

To implement sustainable organizational change, companies employ a three-prong phased approach. The most important and difficult phase of the process is unfreezing, which involves identifying and unlearning wrong past behavior that are sometimes ingrained in an organization’s culture. The most significant indicator of success at this phase is employee acceptance. If an organization manages employee resistance promptly and effectively at this stage, it will ensure the success of the next two phases. The second phase, changing, involves replacing past behavior with new behavior through significant redevelopment and training. Refreezing, the final phase of the process, reinforces and sustains the new behavior through continued visibility and measurement of success. One reinforcement technique is the employment of a praise and reward system. Praise and reward systems elicit high performance and motivate employees to embrace change.

Employee Resistance to Change

A changing organization should not ignore the human element. It is important to change business activities within a company. If employees are not involved or are not willing to accept change, the process is likely to fail. Employees resist change because they are afraid that to lose a job or have to take on additional responsibilities that an employee is either unqualified or unequipped to handle. Using encouraging and inspiring techniques to implement change demonstrates to an employee that she is not being forced to accept change, but is an integral part of the process. An employee feels like a significant contributor in the work place environment when he is part of a successful revolution.

Employee Turnover

After a major reorganization, businesses typically undergo some employee turnover. An employee may feel that the environment is too unstable and might seek employment elsewhere where she feels more secure. High employee turnover can severely affect an organization’s productivity due to loss of skilled workers and the need to recruit and train new people. Sometimes the loss of resources can also result in loss of business revenue as an employee may take key accounts with him. To abate employee resistance and turnover, an organization should initiate a deliberated change management process that explains the significance and implications of the change and guides employees afterward.

Deteriorating Work Climate

Organizational changes that lead to ambiguity and job uncertainty create a declining work environment, which can negatively affect the economic health of an organization. The most detrimental impact is mortality, which is a clear sign that a business transformation has gone horribly wrong. An organization can die when change occurs too quickly or erratically. In a deteriorating environment, employees become self-preserving, less productive, unmotivated and fearful. Avoiding ineffective changes and implementing positive ones will promote a productive corporate culture and prevent organizational death.

Ways in Which Organizations Achieve Growth

• Licensing: “License your most advanced technology,” advised Peters, who argued that truly proprietary technologies are quickly becoming extinct. Peters and other consultants contend that competitors will soon copy whatever a company develops in the realm of technology (and other areas), so it may make good sense for a company to turn to licensing. This creates cash flow for the company to fund future research and development.
• Joint Venture/Alliance: This strategy is particularly effective for smaller firms with limited resources. Such partnerships can help small business secure the resources they need to grapple with rapid changes in demand, supply, competition, and other factors. Forming joint ventures or alliances gives all companies involved the flexibility to move on to different projects upon completion of the first, or restructure agreements to continue working together. Subcontracting, which allows firms to concentrate on those aspects of their business that they do best, is sometimes defined as a type of alliance arrangement (albeit one in which the parties involved generally wield differing levels of power). Joint ventures and other business alliances can inject partners with new ideas, access to new technologies, new approaches, and new markets, all of which can help the involved businesses to grow. Indeed, establishing joint ventures with overseas firms has been hailed as one of the most potentially rewarding ways for companies to expand their operations. Finally, some firms realize growth by acquiring other companies.
• Sell Off Old Winners: Some organizations engaged in a concerted effort to grow divest themselves of mature “cash cow” operations to focus on new and innovative product or service lines. This option may sound contradictory, but analysts note that businesses can command top prices for such tried and true assets. An addendum to this line of thinking is the divestment of older technology or products. Emerging markets in Latin America and Eastern Europe, for instance, have been favourite places for companies to sell products or technology that no longer attract high levels of interest in the United States. These markets may not yet be able to afford large quantities of state-of-the-art goods, but they can still benefit from older models.
• New Product Development: Creation of new products or services is a primary method by which companies grow. Indeed, new product development is the linchpin of most organizations’ growth strategies.
• New Markets: Some businesses are able to secure significant organizational growth by tapping into new markets. Creating additional demand for a firm’s product or service, especially in a market where competition has yet to fully develop, can spur phenomenal growth for a small company, although the competitive vacuum will generally close very quickly in these instances.

Mindset and The Five Stages of Organizational Growth

There are five basic stages of organizational growth. Along the way, there are definitely skill and strategy needs. However, the challenge in each of these stages is to avoid slipping back into a lower stage. This challenge is nearly always a result of mindset.

Stage I: Conception

Just getting an idea past being a wish or a dream and into action and reality is a major event. The conception stage is marked by creating a vision and some level of planning, developing initial partners.  It is also where the first or initial customers are developed.

Mindset Challenges:

• Fear & Self-Doubt: Allowing real-feeling but unsubstantiated fears to guide decision making.
• Over-Optimism: Insufficient acceptance or exploration of inevitable challenges, investment, and effort.
• Being Closed to the Input of Others: Inability to recognize and obtain wise mentors and input.

Practical Challenges:

• Demonstrating profitability: Creating a “paper model” demonstrating how & when profitability (for-profit) or sustainability (non-profit) will be achieved.
• Estimating investment and risk: Estimating what will be required to achieve profitability or sustainability.
• Market Acceptance: Demonstrating that there is demand for what you offer.
• Organizational structure: Clarifying roles and responsibilities, including how decisions will be made, delegated and implemented.
• Financial management & accounting: The tools, the people, the procedures.

Stage II: Birth / Startup

The birth/startup stage is when you launch the business or non-profit. The “Open” sign is on. You’ve created a legal entity. You’ve begun to offering your products or services to the community. You are making a lot of changes and adjustments due to initial feedback. You are likely still learning about your product, your customer and your business model: What is wanted. What isn’t. What works. What doesn’t.

Mindset Challenges:

• Fear and Self Doubt: There will be new fears and challenges that emerge. Interpreting them accurately.
• Ego: When success or survival is on the line it is very easy for ego issues to emerge.
• Trust & Communication: Issues regarding communication, decision making, follow-through, accountability will all emerge here.
• Crisis-only mode: Forgetting to think, plan and act ahead only responding to urgent issues in the moment.
• Sales-only mode: Business development must happen at this stage but systems need to be clarified and developed to support the new business.

Practical Challenges:

• Managing Cash: Running out of money may be a constant threat.
• Adjusting Expectations: The realities of market demand may be slower or faster, lesser or greater than expected or planned on.
• Financial Management & Accounting: Ensuring that the tools are being used, the procedures work and are followed, that you have the right people managing your finances and books.
• Building Relationships & Credibility: Making sure you are known and attracting attention from current and future stakeholders.
• Clarifying The Value You Offer: The value of what we offer is rarely self-evident. Learning to communicate how the customer benefits in ways the customer cares about.

Stage III: Growth & Stability

You’ve made it! The start-up is over. You can walk now. Mostly. You are generating revenue, you’ve developed brand awareness and you are adding new customers. There is growing predictability in your models and approaches. You are learning what works and what doesn’t. However, competition may be a real concern. Customer loyalty may not be strongly developed. You may or may not be financially stable.

Mindset Challenges:

• Trust: Learning to delegate and let go effectively becomes very important.
• Ego: Continuing to learn to give credit and accept responsibility for problems.
• Scarcity vs abundance: Removing any elements of “survival” and “crisis” mode in favour of investment, stability, and growth.

Practical Challenges:

• Cash Flow: Sustaining financial growth and cash flow.
• Making Large Investments: Timing critical staff, facility or equipment decisions with cash flows.
• Competition: Becoming unique by distinguishing yourself from competitors in terms of service, relationship or product.
• Managing workload: Engaging the fruits of success in terms of increases in management, customers, and revenue.
• Financial management: Growth and management depend on good information.

Stage IV: Maturity and Choices

At this stage, the business or non-profit is established. Survival is not the key question. The business has customer awareness and loyalty. It has built marketing gravity so revenue is easier to obtain. It requires less effort and energy to sustain the organization. This is the point where leaders tend to either disengage, bureaucratize or expand.

Disengagement can look like an owner or executive who takes advantage of the decreased leadership need to step away. This may be less attention to detail or less time at work. This can be a good place for owners to bring in a new executive or consider a sale.

Bureaucratizing often happens as a reaction to the unpredictable and crisis mode nature of the startup and survival phases. There is a real need and opportunity for systems & structures to be developed. However, when this happens to primarily serve internal needs as opposed to external (to serve management and staff as opposed to the customer) it’ll begin to undermine the possibility of success or growth.

Expansion means utilizing existing strength, brand, and knowledge to either expand into new markets or offer new lines of services or products.

Mindset Challenges:

• Ego & Reputation: Perceptions of how “I” or “We” are seen can inhibit good decisions.
• Ossification & Complacency: Lack of creativity and rigid thinking, systems or structures that no longer best serve the customer.
• Founder Syndrome: The founder is unable to stop tinkering, changing or rebuilding when structure is needed.
• Personal Identity & self-worth: Outgoing owners or executives may stay too long.

Practical Challenges:

• Financial management: Owners or executives often extend more trust to financial managers or CFO’s at this point. Ensure that good systems & procedures are in place. That oversight remains.
• Moving into New Markets: The organization may need to move into new markets to continue to grow. This may increase management complexity.
• Adding New Products & Services: The organization may need new products or services to grow. Ensuring that competency and culture are protected is important.
• Engaging New Competition: New markets, products or services all mean engaging new competition. Time to revisit those skills.
• Developing Systems & Structure Without Becoming Rigid: Effective growth only occurs with the development of predictable systems and structure. Learn to build ones that promote growth instead of stifling it.

Stage V: Arriving & Thriving

Not every organization reaches Stage V. It is similar to Stage IV with the difference of organizational influence, recognition, and potential impact. It is often an “institution” that others depend or rely on.  After successful expansions, your organization may now be at the top of its industry. It has maturity in the market, systems, and processes. It has a dominant presence. It could still be growing but it may not be. You are again in the place of determining whether or not you will stabilize or expand.

Mindset Challenges:

• Legacy: What does the leader or organization want to be known for?
• Energy: Does the leader still have the drive to expand or maintain?
• Mythical Thinking: “We can’t fail.” Organizations who’ve made it often believe that they can’t make mistakes or lose their position. They stop pursuing excellence and believe they define excellence.
• Ossification: Lack of creativity and rigid thinking, systems or structures that no longer best serve the customer.
• Personal Identity & self-worth: Outgoing owners or executives may stay too long.
• Founder syndrome: The founder is unable to stop tinkering, changing or rebuilding when structure is needed.

(1) Planning:

Planning is one of the major areas where human resource audit can be conducted. Planning of HR requirement and effectiveness of forecasting and scheduling can be ascertained through HR audit. It is to be seen whether the needs of HR were identified in time or not. If there is an indication through audit about inaccurate forecast, the efforts can be made to improve the forecasting techniques for accurate results in future. Through audit management knows whether there is surplus or shortage of manpower.

A review of recruitment and selection practices can be made to meet the future HR requirements. Better programmes and procedure can be adopted by way of cost benefit, budgets. The training programmes can be reviewed in terms of results obtained. Motivation of employees at all levels is the key aspect in HRM. Evaluation of employee motivation will show whether they feel at ease at work and have better prospect if they work hard.

HR auditors should evaluate the communication in the organisation which is one of the major criteria of failure or success. HR auditors should find out the causes of absenteeism, rate of accidents, labour turnover and can make suggestion to improve them. In respect of all these appropriate policies can be formulated by the management.

(2) Staffing and Development:

Staffing and development is yet another are a need to be evaluated with reference to results obtained, programmes and procedures adopted and policies framed. Staffing is done through recruitment and selection. Here the HR auditors need to evaluate the sources of recruitment and the number of persons hired by the organisation. The success of these programmes depends upon the contributions made by the hired persons in the achievement of organisational objectives.

Auditors have to see whether committed workforce is procured through recruitment and selection programmes. They can then make appraisal of recruitment and selection policies, practices and results. As for results are concerned they depend upon the effectiveness of H.R. policies and practices adopted by the enterprise. For conducting the audit of results the HR auditors need to adopt the methods such as questionnaires, checklists, personal data, and attitude and morale surveys productivity data, and costs, time.

The auditors should thoroughly check the records and statistics and should stress on their accurate maintenance. The information in respect of disciplinary actions, absentees, transfers and promotions are available in records. HR auditors have to examine the procedure and programmes adopted in respect of career and succession planning. The policy for staffing should be formulated in to achieve organisational goals. In this case cream should get due consideration that too without any discrimination.

As for training and development, proper policies need to be formulated by making the SWOT analysis of the existing staff and training and development programmes should be prepared to meet the organisational needs. The cost of training is increasing day by day.

Hence there must be evaluation of specified training and development programme. Auditors should see whether the best practice is adopted or not. They should evaluate the training results in terms of cost per trainee hour, average training hours per employee and revenues per employee per year etc. They can obtain the feedback from reports and records available in the organisation.

Another main element of conducting an HR audit needs to include the effectiveness of the HR department’s people management activities. Areas for auditing under people management include staff performance and employee morale, department organization, responsiveness to employees, day-to-day HR operations, the department’s HR strategies and more.

(3) Organizing:

Organisational structures are meant for facilitating coordination, communication and collaboration. HR auditors have to evaluate effectiveness of organisation structure in attaining the results. They can obtain feedback from the employees and from reports and records. They can check the jobs assigned to the individual employees, authority delegated to the subordinates, special task forces etc. H.R. auditors can also evaluate the policy formulated for encouraging employees to accept change. They can also verify effectiveness of three way communication.

(4) Commitment:

Enterprise wants committed employees. Efforts are taken by the management in this respect for motivating individual and groups of employees. HR auditors have to examine the results of motivation through increase in productivity, improvement in performance and costs. They also have to examine the programmes and procedures followed for job enrichment, wage and salary administration, fringe benefits, morale of employees. They have to verify the satisfaction level of employees through the HR policies adopted by the organisation. A satisfied employee is committed to the work.

(5) Administration:

HR auditors have to examine the style of leadership adopted by the management in dealing with the subordinates. Leadership may be authoritative or participative should be evaluated. One of the benchmark in this respect is delegation of authority.

Delegation is more in participative style. Auditors can assess the results of style of leadership adopted in getting the things done through others by inviting suggestion, going through grievances of the staff, disciplinary actions taken against the subordinates etc. Leadership results can also be visualized if auditors examine the union management relationship and the employees getting promotions.

The auditors also have to examine the position of collective bargaining and its procedure to assess the effectiveness of administration in the organisation. They have to look at the policy of the management in respect of collective bargaining and employee participation in decision making.

(6) Research and Innovation:

Research and innovation is yet another area of HR audit. Here several experiments are conducted and theories are put to test by the experts relating to quality design, marketing etc. Results obtained through this Endeavour can be evaluated on the basis of changes brought about, experiments made and reports and other similar publications.

Auditors can evaluate the results. They can also examine the programmes and procedures adopted for R and D efforts. The management’s policy in respect of R & D efforts can be examined by the auditors and necessary suggestions can be made by them in this regard.

The purpose of the audit is to reveal the strengths and weaknesses in the organization’s human resources system, and any issues needing resolution. The audit works best when the focus is on analyzing and improving the HR function in the organization. The HR audit itself is a diagnostic tool, not a prescriptive instrument.

It is most useful when an organization is ready to act on the findings, and to evolve its HR function to a level where it’s full potential to support the organization’s mission and objectives can be realized.

An organisation has tended to grow bigger, so have the staff departments along with line functions. A time comes when each of them becomes so big that one does not get a fair idea of how they are doing unless special effort is made and studies are undertaken. For the line functions, some indices are available.

In production, for instance, performance can be judged by how much was produced, to what extent schedules were adhered to, at what cost manufacturing was done, what was the unit cost, etc. These figures in themselves are important and they take added meaning when they are compared with, say previous year or years or with the planned and budgeted figures.

Similarly, marketing departments efficiency can be judged by the quantum of sales, sales vis-a-vis competitor’s sales, cost of sales, territories covered, new customers explored, old customers retained, etc.

In case of departments like HR such yardsticks are not readily available. Essentially they have to be evolved according to an organisation’s requirements. Today personnel departments have become big and employ sizable staff and specialists. As such, some kind of audit needs to be undertaken to secret in the functioning of the department. Hence, HR audit comes in the picture.

Method

HR audit is a tool to measure the level of human resources development system.

1. Interview Method:

Top management and senior management (Line managers and employees) are interviewed by the HRD auditor. It is a structured interview designed to solicit information on the perspectives of respondents on the future growth plans and goals of the organization, organization culture, working style, career development, work flow system, leadership style, morale, motivation, vision, mission etc. In view of the time and resources constraints, HRD auditor uses sampling techniques to interview the employees.

2. Questionnaire Method:

HRD auditor designs and administers structured questionnaire to assess the various dimensions of HR development. It is usual practice to test the reliability and validity of the instrument using appropriate statistical technique by conducting a pilot study. Then he has to choose the proper sample size. The questionnaire should accommodate questions reflecting the objectives of HRD audit. It is given to the sample respondents who have to record appropriate response.

3. Observation Method:

HRD manager observes the employees in their natural environment i.e., workplace, canteen, training camps, residential colony to assess the suitability and conduciveness of environment for human resource development.

4. Desk Research Method:

HRD manager collects and uses details relating to performance appraisal report, ethical practices, achievement records, welfare measures, suggestion scheme, career development, frequency of training programmes, feedback of participant trainees, methods used to ascertain training needs, safety practices, accident prevention, incentive and compensation system, etc. He analyses the facts and figures relating to aforesaid areas and arrives at appropriate findings.

This method does not involve interviewing the respondents through a questionnaire or an interview schedule. The entire information is gleaned from the relevant records of the organization.

5. Workshop Method:

Employees are selected either through a sampling technique or through some other norms, for participation in a workshop conducted exclusively for HRD audit purpose. All the participants selected are divided into groups. Different dimensions of HRD are assigned to different groups for SWOT analysis. Then each group is required to prepare a report and make presentation on the themes assigned. The outcomes of the report of each group are deliberated deeply and suggestions are made to the organization. The whole exercise is moderated by the HRD auditor.

6. Task Force Method:

A task force comprising different experts from various domains in the organization is constituted to identify, evaluate and recommend an appropriate solution to the HRD problems identified. HRD manager can work on the accepted recommendations for further development.

Measuring Human Resource costs (HR costs, also called Human Resource costing), is a key component of HR accounting. In this article, we’ll explain what Human Resource costing is, why you should measure costs, how to do it and why just measuring Human Resource costs is not enough.

Reasons

• Predict future costs
• Monitor departmental costs
• Calculate a return of investment (ROI)
• Measure impact and overall success

Remuneration: Remuneration costs include basic pay, dearness allowance, city compensatory allowance, house rent allowance, conveyance allowance, etc. However, these are paid remuneration costs. Organizations are also required to cater for deferred benefits to employees. Certain statutory payments to employees are also accounted under this head, like, contribution to provident fund, pension fund, medical benefits, payment for holiday, sickness, bonus, etc. To retain and attract talent, organizations may also give various fringe benefits to their employees. Even the latest practice to provide stock options to employees involves certain opportunity cost to the organization. The best practice is to delineate such cost elements and arrange the same in the form of a spread sheet. Element-wise cost trends then can be studied over the years and also can be bench-marked with other comparable organizations to understand the nature of variance and to enforce control, wherever necessary.

Recruitment: Recruitment cost is also another major cost head for HR. Right from developing job specifications to describing job requirements, it includes costs of  recruitment, promotion (through advertising), head hunting, evaluation, interviewing, induction and orientation. A well defined job specification minimizes the search for the right fit and consequent costs. If recruitment plans are to meet short-tern-requirements, it may be better to outsource than go in for direct recruitment. There are many specialized manpower agencies, which make people with required skill sets available on contractual terms. Similarly, internal hiring also needs to be explored vis-a-vis external hiring. Internal hiring involves restructuring and relocation costs, a clear policy on ‘promotion from within’ (wherever recruitment is made for the higher posts), etc. A detailed study on cost of hiring is necessary to explore an alternative recruitment process.

Training Costs: Training costs include, cost for induction period, cost of remuneration for the trainee and trainer, cost of travel for the trainee and the trainer, if any, cost of training materials, imputed cost of machines and equipments, used during the training, cost for development of training modules, cost of training evaluation, cost of material wastage during training, if any, cost of production loss for the trainee and the trainer (if he is within the organization, for in-house training), etc. To accurately ascertain cost of training, it is necessary to develop a checklist or a worksheet, delineating all direct and indirect costs of training. There are various methods of training delivery, which we have discussed in previous posts: Different employee training & development methods. Relative benefits and costs of each such method also need to be weighed to understand the most cost-efficient system. Any training on skill renewal needs to be weighed in terms of expanded skill cycle of the trainees. If the trainees are in the higher age bracket or due to retire within a short span, then offering them voluntary retirement (VR) may be more cost effective than putting them on training for skill renewal and skill change.

Relocation Costs: Many organizations have their policies on periodic relocation of employees as part of their restructuring exercise. This is more appropriate for those who have their units in multiple locations. Such decisions from organizational point of view, involve cost related to disturbance allowance, cost of possible litigation, cost of housing, cost of travel, etc. Many departmental undertakings and public sector units thoughtlessly relocate their employees adding costs to the exchequer. Hence relocation decisions must be cost effective or else this will defeat the purpose, straining organizational viability.

Separation Costs: Relocation also induces separation. There may be other reasons for separation, which may be either for organizational initiative or for individual employees’ reasons. Since separation requires replacement, immediate cost effect is on loss of production. Other costs of separation are redundancy benefits (if separation is organization induced), ex-gratia payments (if any), etc. Since separation follows immediate liquidation of fringe benefits, savings of the organization on this course also need to be considered to compute the actual costs.

Personal Overhead Costs: Personnel overhead costs spread over personnel record keeping, costs for maintaining Human Resources Information Systems (HRIS), cost of personnel decisions and overall costs for maintaining personnel department (salary of the people working in this department). Outsourcing personnel services to a great extent can reduce such cost burden. However, its relative merits and demerits need to be studied.

Support Costs: Some of the employee support services are statutory, while others are offered voluntarily by the organizations. For computing support costs, therefore, it is necessary to distribute these under two different heads and then study their impact. Medical welfare, canteens, safety, security, insurance (medi-claim, etc.), death benefits, parking space costs, etc. are some of the statutory costs for employee support services. While house journal, club membership, music at workplace, long service awards, suggestion schemes, library services, holiday homes, etc., are examples of voluntary support services for employees. Since, employee support services have direct effect on employee motivation, cost curtailment decisions must have reference to this aspect.

Diversity hiring is hiring based on merit with special care taken to ensure procedures have reduced biases related to a candidate’s age, race, gender, religion, sexual orientation, and other personal characteristics that are unrelated to their job performance.

A diversity recruitment strategy defines goals, accountabilities, action items and success measures for attracting, engaging, assessing and hiring diverse talent to drive business success. It is often part of a larger diversity and inclusion strategy, developed to ensure a workforce reflects a company’s customer base and the communities where it operates, and to capitalize on the benefits that can come from a diverse range of backgrounds, experiences and perspectives.

Confusion over diversity hiring sometimes lies in the mistaken perception that the goal of diversity recruitment is to increase workplace diversity for the sake of diversity.

The goal of diversity hiring is to identify and reduce potential biases in sourcing, screening, and shortlisting candidates that may be ignoring, turning off, or accidentally discriminating against qualified, diverse candidates.

Businesses have started to recognize diversity in the workplace as a business strategy that maximizes productivity, creativity and loyalty of employees while meeting the needs of their clients or customers. If a company is only as good as their employees, then it stands to reason that a great deal of energy should be devoted to hiring the most talented individuals. By branching out to a diverse workforce, employers have access to a greater pool of candidates thereby improving the odds of hiring the best person. In a competitive marketplace, an organization that puts people first regardless of their race, religion, gender, age, sexual preference, or physical disability has an advantage over the other players.

There are more job openings than people looking for work, companies are facing the tightest labor market in almost 50 years, and workforce demographics are changing fast. Employers are stepping up their game to compete and win valued talent, but it’s a candidate’s market and their demands are high when it comes to workplace diversity.

Goals might look something like this:

• Drive and measure the impact diversity and inclusion has on business results.
• Increase diversity at every level of our organization to better reflect our customer base and the communities we serve.
• Recognize, maximize and reward behaviors that foster a diverse and inclusive culture.

Reconsider Job Requirements

Job specifications may include equal employment opportunity statements, but people who write them often don’t think about factors that influence the chances of certain candidates applying.

Bias at the Sourcing Stage

Bias can enter the search and sourcing process whether you’re male or female, white or black, Latino or Asian, European or American. Case in point: Campbell said an analysis of data from the estimated 80,000 recruiters worldwide who use his platform found that when recruiters search for candidates on LinkedIn, regardless of role, they’re more likely to look at male profiles.

In every profession and at every level of seniority, Campbell said, recruiters end up looking at twice as many male as female profiles.

Train to Spot Bias in Screening

Screening is arguably where most bias comes into play, Campbell said. Unconscious bias training can help. Research has shown that hiring managers, whether male or female, rate male candidates as more competent and hirable than identical female candidates for STEM positions.

Work to Ensure a More Balanced Slate

Whether the priority is more diversity based on race, gender, ethnicity or some other dimension, it pays to have a diverse interview slate. A company looking to hire more women may not want to bring in the top four candidates if they’re all men, but swap the top two out for women.

There are several steps that organizations can and should take to promote a diverse work environment:

Create a diversity policy and publicize it.

Your policy should set formal goals and strategies pertaining to creating an equal opportunity environment. Once your policy is in place it should be made public both internally and externally.

Write job descriptions as to not exclude anyone.

Your job description should clearly be written for all types of applicants and should in no way discriminate.

Publicize job openings in different venues to attract a diverse workforce.

Look beyond obvious recruitment methods and venues for good people. There are many sites online that help facilitate equal opportunity employment and include: Yahoo!, En Espanol, Diversity Inc, America’s Job Bank, The Society of Hispanic Professional Engineers, the Society of Women Engineers, the National Society of Black Engineers, and the Black Executive Exchange program.

Be aware of current legislation.

Staying current on the latest discrimination legislation will help you avoid potential litigation.

Once the appropriate steps are taken, learning how to manage the diverse workforce will take some time. It requires education, sensitivity and awareness of how individuals from different cultures handle communication, business etiquette, and relate to management. Promoting workforce diversity requires HR recruitment of competent and qualified employees and the accommodation of individual needs within the context of the work team and the organization.

Get more diversity into your hiring funnel

When hiring managers are pressuring your recruiters to hire critical positions as quickly as possible, it can be easy to forget about adding diversity in your funnel. A data-driven recruiter continuously monitors the funnel to see whether diversity increases or decreases as candidates move through the pipeline.

Keep track of your post-hire data

How your diverse hires fare long-term at your organization reveals important insights about your hiring practices. How long these employees stay at the company, how they perform, and how soon they receive promotions can tell you about the quality of your diverse hires.