by Proportionate Liability in syndicated underwriting refers to the shared responsibility of underwriting among multiple underwriters based on their agreed participation percentage. If an issue is not fully subscribed, each underwriter is liable only for their specific proportion of the shortfall. This mechanism ensures balanced risk distribution, enabling large issues to be efficiently managed while minimizing individual exposure. Proportionate liability is beneficial for both companies and underwriters, as it enhances market confidence and allows underwriting firms to diversify their risk across multiple transactions.
Formation of an Underwriting Syndicate:
An underwriting syndicate is formed when a lead underwriter, also known as the syndicate manager, brings together multiple financial institutions or brokerage firms to collectively underwrite an issue. The lead underwriter determines the share of liability for each participant based on their financial capacity and risk appetite. These agreements are formalized in an underwriting contract, which outlines each underwriter’s responsibilities, commission structure, and risk-sharing arrangements. This collaborative model makes it easier to raise capital for large projects, ensuring that no single entity bears an excessive burden.
Calculation of Proportionate Liability:
Proportionate liability is determined based on the underwriting agreement, which specifies each syndicate member’s percentage commitment. If an issue is undersubscribed, the shortfall is allocated proportionally among the underwriters. The formula used is:
Proportionate Liability = [Underwriter’s Share in % * Total Unsubscribed Shares] / 100
For example, if an underwriter holds 30% of an issue worth ₹10 crores, and there is a ₹2 crore shortfall, the underwriter’s liability would be ₹60 lakhs (30% of ₹2 crores). This ensures that each member contributes fairly to covering the deficit.
Role of Lead Underwriter in Managing Proportionate Liability:
The lead underwriter plays a crucial role in managing proportionate liability by ensuring clear communication among syndicate members, overseeing risk allocation, and handling regulatory compliance. They negotiate underwriting agreements, assign proportionate shares, and coordinate the distribution of securities among participating firms. In case of a shortfall, the lead underwriter ensures that each syndicate member fulfills their liability obligations. This structured approach minimizes disputes and promotes transparency in the underwriting process, helping issuers secure funding smoothly.
Advantages of Proportionate Liability in Syndicated Underwriting
-
Risk Diversification: It prevents excessive financial burden on a single underwriter.
-
Market Stability: It ensures that large public issues are successfully managed.
-
Better Resource Utilization: Firms can participate in multiple underwriting deals.
-
Higher Investor Confidence: Multiple underwriters reduce the risk of issue failure.
-
Regulatory Compliance: It aligns with SEBI and other financial regulations to ensure fair underwriting practices.
By distributing the liability among multiple participants, the model strengthens capital markets and facilitates smoother fundraising for companies.
Challenges and Risks in Proportionate Liability:
-
Dispute Resolution: Differences in liability calculations may lead to conflicts.
-
Financial Risk: If a major underwriter fails to fulfill their obligation, others must cover the shortfall.
-
Regulatory Burden: Ensuring compliance with SEBI and international financial laws requires additional effort.
-
Market Volatility: Economic downturns can increase risk exposure for all underwriters.
