Evaluation of the Performance of Mutual funds

a. Define the Investment Goals

What is the purpose of my investment? Answer to this should be the foundation of your mutual fund choices. For instance, if you want a regular income with capital protection, you can choose to invest in a debt fund. However, if you have a higher risk appetite and an aim to build your wealth, equities will suit your purpose. So it is crucial to define your financial goal first and then decide your investment. This also has a pivotal role in fund evaluation.

b. Shortlist a few peer Funds to compare

It is difficult to assess a mutual fund in isolation. So, you should always make a small list of comparable funds and continuously compare them. There are many FinTech firms and third party websites that offer free mutual fund screener tools.

c. Check the historical Performance Data

Now every mutual fund handbook comes with a disclaimer stating that past performance is no indicator of future performance. However, this data can help you check how the fund has fared across different market cycles. Consistency can also shed light on the skill of the fund manager. In short, it will be easier for you to find a fund with lower risks but higher returns.

d. Fee Structure of the Fund

A mutual fund company charges you for its services and expertise. Some funds require deft management and quick decisions on whether to buy, sell or hold on to an asset. Please remember that a fund with a higher fee is automatically better. Do check out other parameters too before choosing.

e. Risk-Adjusted Returns

Every fund expects certain risks related to the market and the industry. When fund strategies in such a way that they make more returns against anticipated risks, we call them risk-adjusted returns.

f. Performance against Index

Indexes like Nifty, BSE Sensex and BSE 200 set benchmarks, and all fund performances are evaluated on this basis. Comparing different timelines against the benchmark as well as peers, can be insightful. A well-managed fund won’t fall too hard during a market low.

Why track the Investment Performance

You might have seen the disclaimer that past performance does not indicate the future performance of a fund’. It means that you cannot expect guaranteed returns on investment. Therefore, you need to look beyond the previous years’ returns to assess a mutual fund. Primarily, you should monitor your investments so that you can make informed decisions that can lead to higher returns.

You know that the capital market keeps fluctuating with changes in the overall economic conditions. Such a change disturbs the asset allocation of the portfolio. For instance, an original allocation of 50:50 in equity and debt may change to 60:40 owing to a market rally. It may increase the risk profile of the fund beyond your requirements. Fund evaluation also helps you to compare the performance of your investment against other similar funds. Additionally, a change in fund manager or fundamental attributes of your fund may also trigger an evaluation. Hence, a review and rebalancing might be required to keep the risk profile of the portfolio intact.

How often to Evaluate Fund Performance

The market is subject to fluctuations. However, that doesn’t mean you need to assess the fund performance daily. Ideally, you should evaluate your fund every six months to a year, depending on the tenure of the investment. Evaluating the funds in a shorter period does not give an accurate insight into the performance of your investments. If all this sounds too much, you may invest in regular funds. As qualified intermediaries, they advise you to invest in funds based on your financial goals and risk profile.

Financial Ratios & Fund Performance 

While you may have taken due diligence and advice before investing, you still need to track the performance of your funds. The easiest way to do it is by using the fund fact sheet. In simple terms, the fund fact sheet shows the performance of all the schemes managed by your fund house, including your investment. You must compare these financial ratios with the mutual fund schemes in the same category to understand where your fund stands.

a. Alpha

The fund’s Alpha gives an overview of the fund manager’s skills and strategies and how they fared in the past. It should always be higher than the expense ratio of the fund. Additionally, your fund’s Alpha needs to be higher than the peers, which are at a similar level of beta.

b. Expense Ratio

This is essentially the fee for the fund house for managing your mutual fund. Expense ratios reflects the value-for-money aspect of a fund. It consists of fund management charges and all the other costs related to that of fund management. It impacts your ultimate take-home returns.

c. Benchmark

It is always advisable to compare the fund performance against the benchmark. The benchmark acts as a standard for funds’ performance. If your fund is outperforming the benchmark consistently, it is a sign that the fund is doing well. You can also compare the average return during a specific time frame with its peer funds in the same category.

d. Portfolio Holdings

Look for considerable changes and probable overlapping in the portfolio holdings. The fund needs to hold good quality stocks which have a lower Price to Earnings-per-share (P/E) Ratio vis-a-vis Price to Book Value (P/B) ratio. Additionally, ensure that the fund is investing as per its investment objective. For instance, fund having a high portfolio turnover ratio vis-a-vis lower returns is a bad indicator.

e. Sharpe Ratio

This ratio shows how much extra return you receive for the additional risks you undertake. It is a rule of thumb that higher risks must be compensated more. Moreover, you deserve a reward (excess returns) for the added volatility. Sharpe Ratio tells you how much exactly that reward should be.