by Co-operative federalism is a concept where the Central and State Governments in a federal structure work together in a harmonious and coordinated manner to achieve common national goals. Unlike competitive federalism, which emphasizes autonomy and rivalry, co-operative federalism promotes collaboration, consultation, and joint decision-making between the Union and the states. In India, co-operative federalism is reflected in institutions like the Inter-State Council, NITI Aayog, and Finance Commission, which facilitate dialogue, consensus-building, and distribution of resources. It encourages states to participate in national policymaking while addressing regional needs. This model becomes especially important in areas like healthcare, education, poverty alleviation, disaster management, and infrastructure development, where joint efforts are essential for success.
Co-operative federalism also ensures that diverse interests of various states are considered in framing central policies, thus strengthening the spirit of unity in diversity. The Goods and Services Tax (GST) is a prime example of co-operative federalism in action, where both levels of government came together to create a unified tax structure. In essence, co-operative federalism fosters a sense of partnership between the Centre and states, enhancing democratic governance, national integration, and effective delivery of public services across the country.
Challenges of Co-operative Federalism:
-
Central Dominance
One major challenge to co-operative federalism is the dominance of the Central Government in legislative, administrative, and financial matters. The Constitution provides the Centre with more powers, especially during emergencies. States often feel they are treated as subordinate units rather than equal partners. Excessive use of central agencies and interference in state subjects weakens the spirit of cooperation. This central dominance hampers healthy Centre-State relations, especially when different political parties rule at the Centre and in the states, leading to distrust and tension.
-
Political Differences
Divergent political ideologies between the Centre and states often disrupt the co-operative spirit. When opposition parties rule certain states, there can be reluctance or non-cooperation in implementing centrally sponsored schemes. Mutual accusations and lack of coordination become common, especially on sensitive issues like law and order, resource sharing, or policy execution. This political rivalry weakens institutional cooperation and creates a conflict-oriented federal environment. Instead of collaboration, states may engage in blame games or resist central initiatives, delaying development and negatively affecting public welfare.
-
Financial Inequality
Unequal distribution of financial resources is a persistent obstacle to co-operative federalism. The Centre controls major tax revenues and allocates funds to states through Finance Commissions and centrally sponsored schemes. Many states feel deprived or unfairly treated, particularly when funds are allocated based on population or political considerations. This dependency reduces states’ autonomy and bargaining power. States with poor financial health struggle to implement developmental programs independently, making them heavily reliant on central assistance, which sometimes comes with restrictive conditions or delayed disbursements.
-
Weak Institutional Mechanisms
India’s mechanisms for co-operative federalism, such as the Inter-State Council and Zonal Councils, are often underutilized or function irregularly. These bodies are meant to encourage dialogue, resolve disputes, and facilitate cooperation between the Centre and states. However, infrequent meetings, lack of binding decisions, and inadequate follow-up weaken their effectiveness. Similarly, NITI Aayog, despite being a platform for collaborative planning, is perceived by some states as centrally driven. A lack of robust and regular interaction reduces trust and prevents institutionalized co-operation across tiers of government.
-
Inter-State Disputes
Disputes between states over water sharing, boundaries, resource allocation, or regional development also pose a serious challenge to co-operative federalism. For example, water-sharing conflicts like the Cauvery or Krishna river disputes often lead to legal and political confrontations. These conflicts strain relations not only between the states involved but also between the Centre and states, as the Centre must act as a neutral arbitrator. When states perceive bias in the Centre’s decisions, it erodes trust and discourages the spirit of mutual cooperation and unity.
-
Inconsistent Implementation of Policies
A key challenge is the inconsistent and uneven implementation of national policies and schemes across states. Variations in administrative capacity, political will, and regional priorities often lead to delays or diluted execution of programs such as Ayushman Bharat, PMAY, or NEP 2020. This inconsistency reduces the overall impact of centrally sponsored schemes and frustrates efforts for uniform development. It also reflects a lack of true partnership, where states are treated as implementers rather than stakeholders in policy design and adaptation based on local needs.
