Key Management Personnel, Significant influence

Key Managerial Personnel (KMP) or Key Management Personnel refers to the employees of a company who are vested with the most important roles and functionalities. They are the first point of contact between the company and its stakeholders and are responsible for the formulation of strategies and its implementation. The Companies Act mandates certain classes of companies to include such personnel in its ranks. This article looks at this designation which holds a significant place in the Companies Act of 2013.

The definition of Key Managerial Personnel has been made more elaborate in the Companies Act of 2013 as the 1956 Act restricted its scope to a Managing Director, Whole Time Director and Manager. The current definition of the term provides for the inclusion of the Chief Executive Officer (CEO), the Manager, the Managing Director, the Company Secretary, the Whole-Time Director, the Chief Financial Officer (CFO) and such other officers as may be prescribed. For the purpose of this Act, a Key Managerial Personnel (KMP) is considered as an “Officer and an “Officer who is in default”.

It may be noted that companies are prohibited from appointing or employing a Managing Director and a Manager at the same time. Also, no individuals should be appointed or reappointed as the Managing Director, Manager, Whole-Time Director or Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of a Company for a term exceeding five years at a time, and no reappointments are allowed earlier than one year before the expiry of its term (conditions are subject to additional clauses).

Key management personnel are those people having authority and responsibility for planning, directing, and controlling the activities of an entity, either directly or indirectly. This designation typically includes the following positions:

  • Board of directors
  • Chief executive officer, chief operating officer, and chief financial officer
  • Vice presidents

An entity shall disclose key management personnel compensation in total and for each of the following categories

(a) Short-term employee benefits

(b) Post-employment benefits

(c) Other long-term benefits;

(d) Termination benefits

(e) share-based payment.

Compensation includes all employee benefits as defined in Ind AS 19 Employee Benefits including share based payments to employees as per Ind AS 102.  Employee benefits are all forms of consideration paid, payable or provided by the entity, or on behalf of the entity, in exchange for services rendered to the entity. It also includes such consideration paid on behalf of a parent of the entity in respect of the entity.

If an entity obtains key management personnel services from another entity (the ‘management entity’) [See related party definition point (b) (viii)] in such case, the entity should disclose the amount of fees/compensation paid to the management entity.  Generally, the reporting entity pays agreed amount to the management entity and in return management entity pays to its employees i.e., who managed the reporting entity. The details of payment by the management entity to its employees/directors are not required to be disclosed in the reporting entity financial statements.

According to section 203(1) read with Rule 8 of the Companies (Appointment and Remuneration of Managerial Personnel) Rules, 2014 the following companies are mandated to appoint a Whole-time KMP:

  • Every Listed Company
  • Public Companies having paid-up share capital of 10 Crore rupees or more.
  • Public Companies Having paid-up share of 5 Crore rupees or more.
  • Companies having paid-up share capital of 10 Crore rupees or more are mandated to appoint a Company Secretary.

Roles and Responsibilities of Key Managerial Personnel

The Management function of implementing important decisions comes under the responsibilities of Key Managerial Personnel. Here are some of the main Roles and Responsibilities of KMP:

As per Section 170 of the Act, the details of Securities held by the Key Managerial Personnel in the company or its holding, subsidiary, a subsidiary of the company or associated companies should be disclosed and recorded in the registrar of the Books.

KMP has a right to be heard in the meetings of the Audit Committee while considering the Auditor’s Report; however they do not have the right to vote.

According to Section 189(2), Key Managerial Personnel should disclose to the company, within 30 days of appointment, relating to their concern or interest in the other associations, which are required to be included in the register.

Procedure of Appointment of KMP

  • The appointment of key managerial personnel is prescribed under Section 203 of the Act. Every member of managerial personnel is appointed through a resolution adopted by the Board with terms and conditions of appointment and remuneration.
  • A member of managerial personnel can hold the position in one company at a given time. However a member of managerial personnel of a company can be a member of managerial personnel of its subsidiary company.
  • In case of vacancy the Board has the responsibility of filling up within six months from the date of such vacancy.
  • If the company or its Board tries to violate the provision of appointment of managerial personnel, then the company has to suffer from penalty. The company shall be punishable with fine of rupees one lakh which may extend up to rupees five lakh.
  • Every Director and other key managerial personnel shall also be punishable with a fine of Rs.50, 000. If the contravention is continuing, then they would be charged with Rs. 1000 per day after the first offense.

Officer in default

According to section 2(60) of the Act, an ‘officer who is in default ‘shall be liable for any penalty or punishment by way of imprisonment or fine. The officers may include:

Key Managerial Personnel

Whole-Time director’.

Any person who is responsible for maintenance, filing or distributing records or accounts.

Any Director who is aware of the activities taking place is in contravention of the law or the provisions and yet indulges in or participates in it.

Maintenance of Register:

Every Company falling under this provision is required to maintain a register comprising particulars of its Directors and KMPs, which is to be placed at the registered office of the Company. The documents should include the details of securities held by each of them in the company or its holding, subsidiary, subsidiary of a company’s holding company or associate companies. Further requirements of its contents have been mentioned in Rule 17 of the Companies (Appointment and Qualification of Directors) Rules, 2014.

Significant influence

Significant influence is the power to participate in the financial and operating policy decisions of the investee, but is not control of those policies.

IND-AS 28 defines significant influence as under:

Significant influence is the power to participate in the financial and operating policy decisions of the investee but is not control or joint control of those policies.

Purpose of related party disclosures

IAS 24 Related Party Disclosures requires disclosures about transactions and outstanding balances with an entity’s related parties. The standard defines various classes of entities and people as related parties and sets out the disclosures required in respect of those parties, including the compensation of key management personnel.

Disclosures to be made

  • Relationships between parent and subsidiaries should be disclosed irrespective of whether there have been any transactions or not. If the entity’s parent or the ultimate controlling party does not produce consolidated financial statements, then the next senior parent must be named in the consolidated financial statements for public use.
  • An entity must report the compensation to the key management personnel in total and each of the categories such as short term employee benefits, post-employment benefits, termination benefits, share-based payment, and other long-term benefits.
  • If key management services are obtained from another entity, then only the amounts incurred for the provision of such services shall be disclosed.
  • If the entity has transactions with the related party during the financial year, then it shall disclose the nature of such transactions, and also all the details such as amount, outstanding balances including commitments, provision for doubtful debts, and the expense recognised in respect of bad and doubtful debts.
  • The above disclosures will be made separately in respect of a parent, subsidiaries, associate, entities with joint control or significant influence over the other entity, joint ventures in which the entity is the venturer, and key management personnel of the entity or parent and other related parties.

In general, any related party transaction should be disclosed that would impact the decision making of the users of a company’s financial statements. This involves the disclosures noted below. Depending on the transactions, it may be acceptable to aggregate some related party information by type of transaction. Also, it may be necessary to disclose the name of a related party, if doing so is required to understand the relationship.

General Disclosures

Disclose all material related party transactions, including the nature of the relationship, the nature of the transactions, the dollar amounts of the transactions, the amounts due to or from related parties and the settlement terms (including tax-related balances), and the method by which any current and deferred tax expense is allocated to the members of a group. Do not include compensation arrangements, expense allowances, or any transactions that are eliminated in the consolidation of financial statements.

Control Relationship Disclosures

Disclose the nature of any control relationship where the company and other entities are under common ownership or management control, and this control could yield results different from what would be the case if the other entities were not under similar control, even if there are no transactions between the businesses.

Receivable Disclosures

Separately disclose any receivables from officers, employees, or affiliated entities.

When disclosing related party information, do not state or imply that the transactions were on an arm’s-length basis, unless you can substantiate the claim.

Related Party Disclosures, Related Party, Related party Transaction

A related party transaction is a transfer of resources, services or obligations between RE (reported entity) and related party regardless of whether a price is charged or not.

Objective

Related party relationships are a normal feature of commerce and business. Entities frequently carry on their business activities through its subsidiaries, joint ventures, associates and etc.

In general, users presume that the transactions in financial statements are presented on an “arm’s length” basis. However, the presumption may NOT be valid in case of the transactions between the related parties as the terms and conditions of related parties generally different from unrelated parties. Sometimes related parties may not charge anything for their services like interest free loans, free management services etc. Hence the related party relationship will have an effect on the financial position (BS) and operating results (P&L) of the entity.

Operating results and financial position will be affected because of related party relationship even if there is NO transaction between them.  The mere existence of the relationship may be sufficient to affect the transactions of the entity with other parties. For example: a holding company can ask its subsidiary to stop the relationship with a trading partner or it may instruct the subsidiary not to engage in research and development.

Sometimes, transactions would not have taken place if the related party relationship had not existed. For example, a company that sold a large proportion of its production to its holding company at cost might not have found an alternative customer if the holding company had not purchased the goods.

As the related party transactions may not take place at arm’s length, the entity should give sufficient information about the related party relationship and related party transactions so as to make the users understand the financial positions in its perspective. This standard establishes the requirements of such disclosures.

Scope

This standard is applicable to the consolidated & separate financial statements of a parent or investors with joint control/significant influence over an investee – who prepared financial statements under Ind AS 110, Ind AS 27. It is applicable to individual financial statements.

This Standard shall be applied in:

(a) identifying related party relationships and transactions;

(b) identifying outstanding balances, including commitments, between an entity and its related parties;

(c) Identifying the circumstances in which disclosure of the items in (a) and (b) is required; and

(d) Determining the disclosures to be made about those items.

This Standard is NOT applicable in the following circumstances:

  • Entities need not follow the standard if the disclosure under this Ind AS affects the reporting entity’s duties of confidentiality.
  • In case a statute or a regulator or a similar competent authority governing an entity prohibit disclosing certain information which is required to be disclosed as per this Standard disclosure of such information is not required. For example: banks are obliged by law to maintain confidentiality in respect of their customers’ transactions.
  • In case of consolidated financial statements (CFS): Intra group transactions need NOT to be presented as CFS present information about the holding and its subsidiaries as a single reporting entity. This is not applicable for those between an investment entity and its subsidiaries measured at fair value through profit or loss, in the preparation of consolidated financial statements of the group.

This Standard applies only to the below related party relationships.

Disclosures to be made:

  • Relationships between parent and subsidiaries should be disclosed irrespective of whether there have been any transactions or not. If the entity’s parent or the ultimate controlling party does not produce consolidated financial statements, then the next senior parent must be named in the consolidated financial statements for public use.
  • An entity must report the compensation to the key management personnel in total and each of the categories such as short term employee benefits, post-employment benefits, termination benefits, share-based payment, and other long-term benefits.
  • If key management services are obtained from another entity, then only the amounts incurred for the provision of such services shall be disclosed.
  • If the entity has transactions with the related party during the financial year, then it shall disclose the nature of such transactions, and also all the details such as amount, outstanding balances including commitments, provision for doubtful debts, and the expense recognised in respect of bad and doubtful debts.
  • The above disclosures will be made separately in respect of a parent, subsidiaries, associate, entities with joint control or significant influence over the other entity, joint ventures in which the entity is the venturer, and key management personnel of the entity or parent and other related parties.

Related Party

A related party can be a person, an entity, or an unincorporated business.

A related party is a person (individual) or entity that is related to the entity that is preparing its financial statements.

(a) A person or a close member of that person’s family is related to a reporting entity if that person:

(i) Has control or joint control of the reporting entity;

(ii) Has significant influence over the reporting entity; or

(iii) Is a key management personnel (KMP) of the reporting entity or it’s parent entity.

(b) An entity is related to a reporting entity if any of the following conditions applies:

(i) The entity and the reporting entity are members of the same group (which means that each parent, subsidiary and fellow subsidiary is related to the others);

(ii) One entity is an associate or joint venture of the other entity (or an associate or joint venture of a member of a group of which the other entity is a member i.e., associate or joint venture of co-subsidiary);

(iii) Both entities are joint ventures of the same third party;

(iv) One entity is a joint venture of a third entity and the other entity is an associate of the third entity;

(v) The entity is a post-employment benefit plan for the benefit of employees of either the reporting entity or an entity related to the reporting entity. If the reporting entity is itself such a plan, the sponsoring employers are also related to the reporting entity;

(vi) The entity is controlled or jointly controlled by a person identified in (a);

(vii) A person identified in (a) (i) has significant influence over the entity or is a member of the key management personnel of the entity (or of a parent of the entity);

(viii) The entity, or any member of a group of which it is a part, provides key management personnel services to the reporting entity or to the parent of the reporting entity.

Control is the power over the investee when it is exposed or has rights to variable returns from its involvement with the investee and has the ability to affect those returns.

Joint Control is the contractually agreed sharing of control of an arrangement which exists only when decisions about the relevant activities require the unanimous consent of the parties sharing control.

Significant influence is the power to participate in the financial and operating policy decisions of the investee, but is not control of those policies.

 (a) An INDIVIDUAL becomes related party to the reporting entity, when that individual or his family’s close member

  • Has Control or Joint control or Significant influence over the reporting entity;
  • Is Key managerial personnel in the reporting entity or it’s parent entity; (Not in co-subsidiary entity)

Close Member of the family:

Close members of the family of a person are those family members who may be expected to influence, or be influenced by, that person in their dealings with the entity including:

(a) That person’s children, spouse (married) or domestic partner (a person who is living with another in a close personal and sexual relationship but not married), brother, sister, father and mother.

(b) Children of that person’s spouse or domestic partner.

(c) Dependents of that person or that person’s spouse or domestic partner.

Related Party as per Companies Act, 2013 According to section 2(76) of the Company’s act, 2013 related party with reference to company means:

i) a director or his relative;

) a key managerial personnel or his relative;

i) A firm, in which a director, manager or his relative;

ii) A private company in which a director or manager or his relative is a member or director.

iii) A public company in which a director or manager is a director and holds along with his relatives, more than 2% of its paid-up capital;

iv) Anybody corporate who’s Board of Directors, managing director or manager is accustomed to act in accordance with the advice, directions or instructions of a director or manager.

v) any person on whose advice, directions or instructions a director or manager is accustomed to act provided that nothing in sub-clauses (vi) and(vii) shall apply to the advice ,directions or instructions given in a professional capacity.

vi) any body corporate which is:

A) A holding, subsidiary or an associate company of such company;

B) A subsidiary of a holding company to which it is also a subsidiary; or,

C) An investing company or the venturer of a company means a body corporate

Related party Transaction

Related Party Transaction can be understood as a deal or arrangement made between two parties or entities that are joined by a pre-existing business relationship or common interest. It is a transfer of resources, services or obligations between a reporting entity and a related party, regardless of whether a price is charged.

All related party transactions require approval of Audit Committee. All contracts that are (1) not in the ordinary course of business but at arm’s length (2) in the ordinary of course of business but not at arm’s length or (3) not in the ordinary course of business and not at arm’s length require prior approval of board of directors or shareholders based on certain thresholds.

Penalties: Any director or any other employee of the company, who had entered into or authorised the contract in violation, as per section 188 of the companies act they are punishable:

a) In case of listed companies, imprisonment upto 1 year or fine from 25,000 to 5 lakhs or both

b) In case of other companies , fine from 25,000 to 5 lakhs.

Main purpose of Related Parties regulation: To regulate transactions between the company, its subsidiaries and its related parties with a view to ensure that such transactions are executed on an arm’s length basis and is transparent and fair manner.

Importance

They provide transparency on how its financial position and financial performance may be affected by transaction with related parties which may or not be conducted on an arm’s length basis.

Under the new law, in relation to every RPT, directors have to necessarily check most importantly the following two criteria:

a) Whether the contracts or arrangements is in the “ordinary course of the business” of the company.

b) Whether the terms and conditions of such contracts or arrangements are on “arms length basis”.

The transaction will be with Related Party in case it is with any of the following:

a) With any Director of Company.

b) With any relative of a Director.

c) With any KMP or relative of a KMP.

d) With any firm in which Director or his relative is a partner.

e) With any private Company in which a Director is a member or Director)

f) With a Public Company in which a Director is a member or Director and additionally holds along with his relative(s) 2% or more paid-up share capital of a Public Company.

g) With a Subsidiary Company h) With an Associate Company in which Company has more than shareholding.

i) With a body corporate which is significantly influenced by a Director of a company.

j) With a person who has control or significant influence over the Company.

Following transactions with above related parties will constitute related party transactions:

a) Sale, Purchase or supply of any goods or material by a Company.

b) Selling or disposing off or buying any property by Company.

c) Leasing of any property by Company.

d) Availing or rendering of any services by Company.

e) Appointment of any agent for purchase or sale of goods, materials, services or property by Company.

f) Any related party’s appointment to any office or place of profit in Company.

g) Company or its subsidiary Company or its associate Company.

h) Underwriting the subscription of any securities or their derivatives of Company To determine a transaction a related party transaction following points to be ensured:

a) The transaction should be entered on an Arm’s length basis.

b) Take prior approval of Audit Committee of the Board in respect of all related party transactions

c) Approval of shareholders through special resolution if the related party transaction during a financial year exceeds 10% annual consolidated turnover of a company.

d) Prior approval of the Board is required in case a related party transaction is not in the ordinary course of business and not on an Arm’s length basis.

Related-party transactions are legitimate activities and serve practical purposes:

They are recognized in corporate and taxation laws.

They have their own standards for accounting treatment.

Systems of checks and balances have been built around them to make sure they are conducted within these boundaries.

Methods of Establishment of cost

Target Costing Phases: Planning, Development and Production

Target costing is a market driven methodology.

There are the three phases of this methodology as under:

(i) Planning:

The products of all competitors are to be analysed with regard to price, sales, quality, technology, and service etc., and after that target cost is to be determined and then market share of one product is to be finalised.

(ii) Development:

Cost structure of the organisation is to be finalised after examining and studying various cost reductions measures and Activity based costing and then a suitable design has to be developed.

(iii) Production:

Production target are fixed and efforts are made to achieve it at the lowest cost without affecting the quality, technology design and its production techniques etc.

Target Costing Approaches (With Equations)

Target costing system has customer orientation. Under the target costing approach, before a firm launches a product (or a family of products), it determines the ideal selling price, establishes the feasibility of meeting that price, and then control costs to ensure that the price is met.

The target costing approach is radically different from the conventional approach for price fixation and cost management.

  1. Conventional Approach:

The conventional approach is cost plus pricing. The approach is to design a product so that it can be produced at the lowest cost, and then a desired margin is added to the estimated cost to determine the selling price of the new product.

We may present this approach in an equation form as follows:

S = C + P

If the firm feels that the price is too high, it modifies the design to reduce the cost and consequently the required selling price. If the firm could not establish the expected selling price, the product is launched at the originally estimated selling price based on the original design.

The other conventional approach is to design a product so that it can be produced at the lowest cost, and then match the cost to the anticipated selling price.

The profit margin is determined as presented in the following equation:

P = S-C

If the profit margin is below an acceptable level, the product is redesigned, if possible, to reduce the cost until the desired profit margin is achieved.

In both the conventional approaches, the focus is on cost reduction and not on cost management. The cost reduction efforts start after the development stage. Both the approaches induce production efficiencies to apply after the product design stage. Therefore, the potential for cost reduction is limited.

A study estimated that at most 10% cost reduction is attainable. Conventional approaches do not compel managers to estimate how much the customer will pay for each element of functionality and quality. Each product used to be conceived as a package of functionality and quality without much scope for modification.

  1. Target Costing Approach:

Under the target costing approach, firms work backward from customers’ need and willingness to pay. Target costing takes cost as the dependent variable, while conventional approaches take selling price or profit as the dependent variable.

The relationship between the variables can be presented as follows:

C = S-P

The target costing approach recognizes that there is a trade-off between price, cost, functionality, and quality. Managers examine this trade-off at the development stage of the product, and optimize on the product functionality and quality within the parameters of estimated selling price, target cost, target volume and target launch date.

Costing Types:

  1. Job Costing:

Under this method costs are collected and accumulated for each job or work order or project separately. Each job can be identified separately and hence becomes essential to analyze the costs according to each job.

Normally production consists of distinct jobs or lots so that order number can identify costs. A job card is prepared for each job for cost accumulation. This method is suitable for Printers, Machine tool manufacturers, Foundries, and general engineering workshops.

  1. Contract Costing:

Contract costing does not in principle differ from job costing. When the job is big and spread over long period of time, the method of contract costing is used. A separate account is kept for each individual contract. Civil engineering contractors, constructional and mechanical engineering firms, builders, etc use this method.

In contracts, when it is agreed to pay an agreed sum or percentage to cover overheads and profit to the contractors, it will be termed as ‘cost plus costing’. The term cost here refers to the prime cost. Usually government contracts are assigned in this basis.

  1. Batch Costing:

This is an extension of job costing. A batch may represent a number of small orders or group of identical products passed through the factory in batch. Each batch is treated as a cost unit and cost is ascertained separately.

The cost per unit is determined by dividing the cost of the batch by the number of units produced in a batch. The manufacturers of biscuits, garments, spare parts and components mainly use this method.

  1. Process Costing:

A process refers here to a stage of production. If a product passes through different stages, each distinct and well defined, then in order to ascertain the cost at each stage or process, the process costing is used. Under this method, a separate process account is prepared and all costs incurred in that process are charged.

Normally the finished product of one process becomes the raw material of the subsequent process and a final product is obtained in the last process. As the products are manufactured in continuous process, this is also known as continuous costing. Process costing method is generally followed in textile units, chemical industries, refineries, tanneries, paper manufacture, etc.

  1. Operation Costing:

It is a further refinement of process costing. It is suitable to industries where mass or repetitive production is carried out or where the goods have to be stocked in semi-finished stage, to enable the execution of special orders, or for the convenient use in later operations. In this method, the cost unit is an operation. It is used in cycle manufacturing, automobile units, etc.

  1. Unit Costing:

This is also known as single or output costing. This method is suitable for industries where the manufacture is continuous and units are identical. This method is applied in industries like mines, quarries, cement works, brick works, etc.

In all these industries there is natural or standard unit of cost, for example, tonne of coal in collieries, tonne of cement, one thousands of bricks, etc. The object of this method is to ascertain the cost per unit of output and the cost of each element of such cost.

Here the cost account takes the form of cost sheet or statement prepared for a definite period. The cost per unit is determined by dividing the total expenditure incurred during a given period by the number of units produced during that period.

  1. Operating Costing:

This is suitable for industries, which render services as distinct from those, which manufacture goods. This is applied in transport undertakings, power supply companies, gas, water works, municipal services, hospitals, hotels, etc.

It is used to ascertain the cost of services rendered. There is usually a compound unit in such undertakings, for example, tonne-kilometres or passenger-kilometres in transport companies, kilo-watt-hour in power supply, patient-day in hospitals, etc.

  1. Multiple Costing:

It is also called as composite costing. It represents the application of more than one method of costing in respect of the same product. This is suitable for industries where a number of component parts are separately produced and subsequently assembled into a final product. In such industries each component differs from others as to price, materials used, and manufacturing processes.

So it will be necessary to ascertain the cost of each component. For this purpose process costing may be applied. To ascertain the cost of the final product batch costing may be applied. This method is used in factories manufacturing cycles, automobiles, engines, radios, typewriter, aero plane and other complex products.

Differences between Traditional and Activity based costing

Activity based costing

Activity based costing is a method of cost allocation of overhead costs such that, for each different activity, a different cost driver is applied which is best suited for that activity. The cost driver is specifically selected for each activity.

The activity-based costing method also solves the problem of erroneousness that comes in a traditional approach. It helps to distinguish between profits that are profitable or profits that are not profitable.

ABC is the most accurate and difficult to implement that’s why it is best suited for a company or firm with high overhead costs compared to a small company that offers services. Companies that manufacture a large number of products with different varieties prefer ABC because it gives exact data of the costs of every product.

Traditional Costing:

Traditional costing is a costing method used to allocate overhead costs based on a single cost driver according to the consumption of a volume of production resources. This single cost driver can be based on machine hours, labor hours etc. and is used for all the different activities.

Traditional costing is beneficial when the overhead of the business or firm is not so much compared to the direct cost of production. Trading Costing generally gives exact costs figures when the product is very good in amount and change in overhead rate does not create major change while measuring the cost of production.

It is not expensive as activity-based costing to implement. It is used usually for external exports because it is easier and more understandable for outsiders. Traditional costing is good methods for those manufacturers who produce only make few different goods.

Activity Based Costing Traditional Costing
Definition This is used for finding the indirect costs. This method is for finding the cost for the products in advance.
Advantages It gives the profit of the product accurately. Workers will be more productive to do the work.
Disadvantages The benefits will be limited. It is not helpful when we determine the overhead costs for general purposes.
Activity Types Unit level and Facility level. Unit level, facility level, product level, and batch level.
Costing Method Less expensive costing method. More expensive costing method

Meaning of Costing Methods

Costing method is the approach or style or tactic adopted by an organization to collect cost data in a more appropriate manner. There are several methodologies utilized by different organizations, which is determined by the nature of products being manufactured.

Under Cost Accounting, costing methods are categorized into two groups; namely;

  • Job Costing
  • Operation Costing

Various methods of costing are as under:

Unit Costing: If production is made in different grades, costs are ascertained grade wise. Per unit cost is calculated on the basis of units produced. This method is applicable to steel production bricks, mines and flour mills etc.

Job Costing: This method is applicable where work is undertaken to customers. This method is used in repair shops printing press and interior decoration etc.

Features:

  1. Production is undertaken against customer’s order.
  2. Each job is clearly distinguishable from the other, and hence requires a special treatment.
  3. The cost is ascertained for each job, since there is no uniformity in the flow of production from department to department.
  4. A separate cost sheet is maintained for each job. Each job is given a certain number by which it is identified. The cost sheet provides information regarding details of costs incurred, the data of commencement, completion of the job etc.

Advantages:

  1. It helps in identifying profitable and unprofitable jobs.
  2. It helps in the preparation of estimates will submitting quotations for similar jobs.
  3. Cost data under job costing enable management in preparing budgets for future.
  4. It enables management to control operational efficiency by comparing actual costs with estimated ones.
  5. Spoilage and defective work can be identified with a specific job and responsibility for the same can be fixed on individuals easily.

Limitations:

  1. It involves too much of clerical work (in estimating cost of material, labour and overheads chargeable to each job). As such it is expensive and laborious.
  2. Being historical in nature, it has all the disadvantages of the historical costing. Hence, it cannot be used as a means of cost control unless it is used with techniques like standard costing.

Contract Costing: Unit cost in a contract is of a long duration and it may continue for more than a year. It is most suitable in roads, bridge, shop building etc.

Process Costing: The method is used in mass production industries. The raw material passes through a number of processes up to a completion stage. The finished product of one process passed through a number of process for the next process. This method is used in chemical works, sugar mills etc.

Service Costing: This method is used where services are provided such as hotels, cinemas, hospitals, transport, electricity companies etc.

Composite Costing: This method is used where a number of components are manufactured separately and then assembled in a final product such as in Scooters, Cars, Air Conditioners etc.

Batch Costing: The cost of a batch is ascertained and each batch is a cost unit. This method is used in readymade garments, shoes, tyres and tubes etc.

Operation Costing: This system is followed where number of operations are involved. It provides minute analysis of costs and ensures greater accuracy and better control.

Speculation Introduction, Meaning and Definition, Objectives, Functions, Types, Strategies

Speculation refers to the practice of buying and selling financial assets, commodities, or other instruments with the primary aim of making a profit from short-term price fluctuations rather than long-term investment or use of the asset. It involves predicting future price movements and taking positions accordingly, often without any intention of actually using or consuming the asset. Speculation is common in stock markets, commodities markets, currencies, and derivatives trading, where price volatility offers opportunities for high returns.

The meaning of speculation lies in taking calculated risks based on market analysis, trends, or sometimes pure instinct, in anticipation of favorable price movements. It differs from investment, which focuses on long-term value and income generation. Economists and financial experts define speculation as the act of committing capital to an asset primarily for potential gain from expected market changes, without regard for its intrinsic value. For example, according to Benjamin Graham, speculation is “an activity which does not meet the criteria of safety and adequate return in the long run.” While speculation can add liquidity and efficiency to markets, it can also increase volatility and carry a high risk of loss, especially for inexperienced participants.

Objectives of Speculation:

  • Profit Maximization

The foremost objective of speculation is to earn profits from expected changes in market prices. Speculators purchase assets, commodities, or securities at lower prices with the expectation of selling them at higher prices, or they sell short expecting to repurchase at lower prices. Unlike investors, who focus on long-term growth and stability, speculators target quick gains within a shorter timeframe. They rely on market trends, price patterns, and economic forecasts to predict fluctuations accurately. By taking calculated risks, speculators aim to maximize returns on capital, often leveraging their positions to amplify profits while accepting the possibility of significant losses.

  • Risk Assumption for Others

Another key objective of speculation is to assume risks that other market participants, such as hedgers and investors, prefer to avoid. Many producers, traders, and investors seek to protect themselves from adverse price movements, transferring such risks to speculators. By willingly taking on these risks, speculators create opportunities for others to operate with reduced uncertainty. This process promotes smoother market functioning and greater participation. In return for accepting the potential of losses, speculators are rewarded when their price forecasts prove correct. Essentially, they serve as the market’s risk-takers, absorbing volatility that others might find detrimental to their operations or investments.

  • Market Liquidity Creation

Speculators actively buy and sell in large volumes, ensuring that there are always participants willing to transact. This activity creates liquidity in the market, allowing other buyers and sellers to enter and exit positions easily without significant price distortions. Liquid markets reduce transaction costs and make price movements more stable and predictable. By continuously participating in trades, speculators ensure that there are minimal delays in executing transactions. Their willingness to take immediate positions—whether buying or selling—helps maintain market depth. This objective benefits the entire financial ecosystem, as liquidity is vital for efficient price discovery and smooth trading processes.

  • Price Discovery

Speculators contribute to the process of determining fair market prices by analyzing supply, demand, news, and global market trends. They buy when they believe prices are undervalued and sell when they think prices are overvalued, thereby influencing prices toward equilibrium. This objective ensures that prices in the market reflect available information and future expectations. Speculators use tools like technical and fundamental analysis to predict market direction. By continuously responding to new data, they accelerate the adjustment of prices to reflect true market value. Their activity often sets benchmarks for others, influencing both short-term trading and long-term investment decisions.

  • Encouraging Market Efficiency

An important objective of speculation is to make markets more efficient by narrowing gaps between buying and selling prices and by reducing regional or time-based price disparities. Speculators identify mispriced assets and quickly act on them, which helps correct inefficiencies in valuation. This action aligns prices with actual market conditions, benefiting all participants. Efficient markets attract more investors and traders, fostering economic growth. Speculators’ constant monitoring of information—economic data, policy changes, and geopolitical events—ensures that prices remain accurate. Their actions prevent prolonged price distortions, which can otherwise harm market confidence and overall stability in both domestic and global trade.

  • Facilitating Hedging Opportunities

Speculation creates opportunities for hedgers to protect themselves against price volatility. Farmers, exporters, importers, and manufacturers often use futures and options markets to hedge against unfavorable price changes. Speculators take the opposite positions in these contracts, making hedging possible. For instance, a farmer can secure a selling price for crops months in advance, knowing that a speculator is willing to buy the contract. This relationship benefits both sides: the hedger minimizes risk, and the speculator gains a potential profit opportunity. Thus, speculation indirectly supports production, trade, and investment by ensuring that risk management tools remain active and effective.

Functions of Speculation:

  • Providing Market Liquidity

A primary function of speculation is to inject liquidity into the market. Speculators actively trade large volumes of assets, ensuring that there are always buyers and sellers available. This constant activity reduces waiting times for transactions and narrows bid-ask spreads, making it easier for others to enter or exit positions. Liquidity also stabilizes prices by preventing sudden and extreme fluctuations due to thin trading. Without speculators, markets might face low participation, higher transaction costs, and slower execution. By keeping the market active, speculation benefits all stakeholders, from short-term traders to long-term investors, ensuring smoother and more efficient market operations.

  • Facilitating Price Discovery

Speculation plays a key role in determining fair asset prices. Speculators analyze news, demand-supply trends, and economic indicators to predict price movements. By buying when they expect prices to rise and selling when they expect declines, they influence prices toward an accurate reflection of current and expected conditions. This continuous adjustment ensures that markets respond quickly to new information. Price discovery benefits producers, consumers, investors, and policymakers by providing transparent and updated pricing signals. Without speculative activity, prices could remain artificially high or low for longer periods, distorting decision-making in production, trade, and investment.

  • Risk Absorption

Speculators assume risks that other market participants avoid, particularly hedgers and conservative investors. For example, in commodity and futures markets, producers and traders can transfer the risk of price volatility to speculators. This allows businesses to focus on production or trade without worrying about market instability. Speculators, in turn, accept the uncertainty in hopes of profiting from favorable price changes. By absorbing these risks, speculation supports business continuity and financial planning. This function ensures that risk is not concentrated in the hands of those unwilling or unable to bear it, promoting a more balanced and stable market environment.

  • Promoting Market Efficiency

Speculation helps remove inefficiencies in the market. Whenever there are pricing errors—such as an asset being undervalued or overvalued—speculators act quickly to exploit these discrepancies. Their trades push prices toward their true value, reducing mispricing and preventing long-term distortions. This function promotes fairness and ensures that market prices accurately reflect available information and future expectations. In an efficient market, resources are allocated more effectively, benefiting economic growth. Speculators’ constant monitoring of developments, including policy changes and global events, ensures that prices adjust rapidly, improving transparency and fairness in financial markets for all categories of participants.

  • Supporting Hedging Mechanisms

Speculation is essential for hedging to function effectively. Farmers, exporters, and manufacturers often use futures or options to protect themselves from price volatility. These hedging contracts require counterparties willing to take the opposite position—usually speculators. Without speculative participation, hedging opportunities would be limited, reducing businesses’ ability to manage risk. By taking on this role, speculators make markets more attractive and accessible for producers and traders. This support encourages greater participation in both domestic and international markets, ultimately strengthening the broader economy by reducing the negative impacts of price instability in commodities, currencies, and financial securities.

  • Encouraging Investment and Trade

By ensuring active markets and predictable pricing, speculation indirectly encourages greater investment and trade. Liquidity, price discovery, and risk-sharing functions create a favorable environment where businesses feel confident to operate. Investors are more likely to participate in markets where they can enter and exit easily, and producers are more inclined to expand output when they can hedge against price drops. This creates a positive cycle of market activity. In this way, speculation is not just about personal profit—it also contributes to economic vibrancy by attracting capital, fostering trade, and promoting innovation across multiple sectors of the economy.

Types of Speculation:

  • Bullish Speculation

Bullish speculation occurs when a speculator expects asset prices to rise in the future. In this strategy, the speculator buys securities, commodities, or currencies at the current price with the aim of selling them later at a higher price, earning the difference as profit. Bullish speculation is common in stock markets, real estate, and commodities. It often arises from positive economic indicators, favorable government policies, or expected demand growth. While profitable during upward trends, it carries risks if the market moves unexpectedly downward. Successful bullish speculation requires careful analysis of trends, market sentiment, and timing to minimize losses and maximize gains.

  • Bearish Speculation

Bearish speculation is based on the expectation that asset prices will fall in the future. Here, the speculator sells assets they do not own (short selling) or sells holdings early to repurchase them later at a lower price. This approach profits from market downturns, often caused by negative news, poor earnings, or unfavorable economic conditions. Bearish speculators analyze signs of declining demand, overvaluation, or market weakness. While it can be highly profitable in falling markets, it is risky because losses can become unlimited if prices unexpectedly rise. This strategy demands precise market timing, risk management, and strong analytical skills.

  • Long-Term Speculation

Long-term speculation involves holding assets for an extended period—often months or years—based on the belief that prices will appreciate substantially over time. This approach is common among investors in real estate, gold, and blue-chip stocks. Long-term speculators focus on macroeconomic trends, technological innovations, and company growth prospects. While less stressful than daily trading, it ties up capital and exposes investors to long-term market risks, such as policy changes, recessions, or disruptive innovations. Successful long-term speculation requires patience, thorough research, and the ability to withstand short-term price fluctuations while waiting for the anticipated long-term upward trend to materialize.

  • Short-Term Speculation

Short-term speculation involves quick buying and selling of assets within a short time frame—ranging from minutes to weeks—to profit from minor price changes. It is common in forex trading, intraday stock trading, and commodity markets. Short-term speculators rely heavily on technical analysis, market news, and rapid decision-making. While the potential for quick profits is high, the risks are equally significant due to market volatility and transaction costs. Success depends on sharp analytical skills, discipline, and the ability to manage emotions under pressure. Short-term speculation is capital-intensive and often better suited to experienced traders than to beginners.

  • Margin Speculation

Margin speculation involves borrowing funds from a broker to trade larger positions than the speculator’s available capital. This leverage magnifies potential gains if the market moves favorably but also increases the risk of substantial losses if prices move against the trader. Margin speculation is common in futures, options, and stock trading. It requires maintaining a margin account, which is subject to margin calls if the account balance falls below the required level. While it offers opportunities for higher returns, it demands careful risk management, strict discipline, and the ability to react quickly to market changes to avoid significant financial losses.

  • Arbitrage Speculation

Arbitrage speculation exploits price differences for the same asset in different markets or forms. The speculator buys in the cheaper market and simultaneously sells in the more expensive one, securing a profit with minimal risk. Common in currency markets, commodities, and stock exchanges, arbitrage requires speed, precision, and access to multiple markets. While pure arbitrage is considered low-risk, opportunities are often short-lived due to market efficiency. Technological tools and algorithms are frequently used to detect and execute arbitrage opportunities instantly. This type of speculation helps align prices across markets, contributing to overall market efficiency and reducing mispricing.

Strategies of Speculation:

  • Position Trading

Position trading is a long-term speculation strategy where traders hold assets for weeks, months, or even years, aiming to profit from significant price trends. Unlike short-term traders, position traders are less concerned with daily market fluctuations and focus on macroeconomic indicators, fundamental analysis, and major market cycles. They invest in assets expected to appreciate substantially over time, such as stocks, bonds, commodities, or currencies. This strategy demands patience, strong research skills, and the ability to withstand temporary losses while waiting for the market to reach targeted levels. Position trading is ideal for speculators seeking larger gains from sustained market movements.

  • Swing Trading

Swing trading involves holding positions for several days or weeks to capture short- to medium-term market swings. Swing traders use technical analysis, chart patterns, and momentum indicators to identify entry and exit points. The goal is to buy low during an upward swing and sell high before the trend reverses, or to short-sell during a downward swing. This strategy requires less time than day trading but more market monitoring than long-term investing. Swing trading can yield substantial profits if trends are accurately identified, but it carries risks from sudden market reversals, news events, or false breakout signals. Timing is crucial.

  • Day Trading

Day trading is a high-intensity speculation strategy where positions are opened and closed within the same trading day, avoiding overnight market risks. Day traders rely heavily on technical analysis, real-time news, and fast execution to capitalize on small intraday price movements. This approach is common in stock, forex, and commodity markets. While profits per trade may be small, frequent trades can accumulate significant gains. However, day trading demands quick decision-making, discipline, and the ability to manage stress under volatile conditions. It also involves high transaction costs and carries the risk of substantial losses if trades move against the trader.

  • Scalping

Scalping is an ultra-short-term trading strategy where speculators aim to profit from very small price changes, often holding positions for seconds or minutes. Scalpers execute dozens or even hundreds of trades daily, seeking to exploit bid-ask spreads, order flow, and small price gaps. This method requires advanced trading platforms, rapid execution, and a deep understanding of market microstructures. While individual trade profits are minimal, the cumulative effect can be significant. Scalping is highly demanding, requiring intense concentration and quick reflexes. However, high transaction costs and market noise make it a challenging strategy, often suited only for highly skilled, experienced traders.

  • Arbitrage

Arbitrage speculation involves simultaneously buying and selling an asset in different markets to profit from temporary price differences. For example, a trader might purchase a commodity where it is cheaper and sell it in a market where it is priced higher. This strategy is considered low-risk because the buying and selling occur almost instantly, locking in profit. However, opportunities are rare and short-lived due to market efficiency and competition from institutional traders. Successful arbitrage requires fast execution, access to multiple markets, and sometimes automated trading algorithms. While relatively safe, profit margins per transaction are usually small and require scale.

  • Trend Following

Trend following is a speculation strategy based on the belief that assets moving in a certain direction will continue to move that way for some time. Traders identify upward or downward trends using moving averages, momentum indicators, and chart patterns, entering trades in the direction of the trend. The goal is to ride the trend until clear signs of reversal emerge. This approach minimizes the need to predict exact turning points but requires strict discipline to exit when the trend ends. Trend following can be applied to stocks, forex, commodities, and futures markets, offering potentially large profits during strong trends.

Hedging Introduction, Meaning & Definition, Objectives, Functions, Types, Strategies

A hedge is an investment that is made with the intention of reducing the risk of adverse price movements in an asset. Normally, a hedge consists of taking an offsetting or opposite position in a related security.

Working

Hedging is somewhat analogous to taking out an insurance policy. If you own a home in a flood-prone area, you will want to protect that asset from the risk of flooding to hedge it, in other words by taking out flood insurance. In this example, you cannot prevent a flood, but you can plan ahead of time to mitigate the dangers in the event that a flood did occur.

There is a risk-reward tradeoff inherent in hedging; while it reduces potential risk, it also chips away at potential gains. Put simply, hedging isn’t free. In the case of the flood insurance policy example, the monthly payments add up, and if the flood never comes, the policyholder receives no payout. Still, most people would choose to take that predictable, circumscribed loss rather than suddenly lose the roof over their head.

Objectives & Functions

The basic purpose of hedging is to secure pro­tection against fluctuation in prices. This protec­tion is secured by shifting the risks of price changes to the professional risk-takers i.e., speculators. The traders who have to buy goods and keep them in stock for considerable periods can meet the possi­ble ups and downs in the prices by hedging their purchases.

Similarly, a manufacturer who manu­factures goods according to a carefully prepared budget can save hi-self from upsetting results of rise in the prices of raw materials by hedging in the futures market. An exporter also can save himself from possible losses due to changes in prices through hedging.

Besides insuring itself against losses from fluc­tuating prices a firm can receive better credit facili­ties from the bank if it hedges its goods.

Types

Commodities

Commodities include agricultural products, energy products, metals, etc. The risk associated with these commodities is known as “Commodity Risk.”

Securities

Securities include investments in shares, equities, indices, etc. The risk associated with these securities is known as “Equity Risk” or “Securities Risk.”

Currencies

Currencies include foreign currencies. There are various types of risks associated with it. For Example, “Currency Risk (or Foreign Exchange (Currency) Exposure Risk),” “Volatility Risk,” etc.

Interest Rates

Interest rates include lending and borrowing rates. The risks associated with these rates are known as “Interest Rate Risks.”

Weather

Interestingly, the weather is also one of the areas where hedging is possible.

Hedging Types

Forward

Forward (or a Forward Contract) is a non-standardized contract to buy or sell an underlying asset between two independent parties at an agreed price and a specified date. It covers various contracts like forwarding exchange contracts for currencies, commodities, etc.

Futures

Futures (or a Futures Contract) is a standardized contract to buy or sell an underlying asset between two independent parties at an agreed price, standardized quantity, and a specific date. It covers various contracts like currency futures contracts, etc.

Money Markets

It is one of the major components of financial markets; today, where short-term lending, borrowing, buying, and selling are done with a maturity of one year or less. Money markets cover a variety of contracts like money market operations for currencies, money market operations for interest, covered calls on equities, etc.

Strategies:

A hedging strategy generally refers to the risk reduction technique of investment. There can be no standard strategy to hedge various financial instruments like forwarding contracts, options, swaps, or stocks because these strategies require constant modification as per the type of market and investment, which requires hedging. To face such situations, a business can implement a few strategies, which are as follows:

Through Options

You can do this by buying a put option to protect a portfolio of the cash market.

Through Asset Allocation

You can do this by diversifying your portfolio with more than one type of asset. E.g., you can invest 70% in equity and the rest 30% in other more stable assets to create a balanced portfolio.

Staying in Cash

It is a ‘No Investment’ strategy. Here, the investor does not invest in any asset and thereby keeps his cash in hand.

Through Structures

You can do this by investing a portion of the portfolio in debt and the other in derivatives. Where the debt portion brings stability to the portfolio, the derivatives help in protecting it from the downside risk.

Advantages of Hedging

  • Hedging limits the losses to a great extent.
  • Hedging increases liquidity as it facilitates investors to invest in various asset classes.
  • Hedging requires lower margin outlay and thereby offers a flexible price mechanism.

Limitations of Hedging:

One might think that hedging provides a com­plete insurance against price changes. This is not correct for hedging has its limitations due to which it may afford only an imperfect protection against losses due to fluctuating prices.

  1. The practice of hedging will provide full measure of protection against changes in prices if the prices in the cash market and futures market move together in perfect harmony with each other. Possibilities of a loss will arise when the prices move in opposite directions and change at differ­ent rates in the two markets. In such a case, the protective mechanism of hedging will fail.
  2. The contracts in the futures market relate to the contract grade or basic grade. On the cash mar­ket, a specific grade other than the contract grade may also be purchased or sold. Hedging will serve its protective purpose only if the prices of the con­tract grade of a futures market and the other grades of cash market move together.
  3. In the futures market, purchases or sales can be made only in terms of the trading units fixed by the exchange concerned. If a manufacturer’s re­quirements fall short of the unit, hedging will be of little use for offsetting losses against profits as be­tween the two markets.
  4. Hedging may not provide enough protec­tion to a manufacturer in case there is a rise in the cost of production, not due to a rise in the price of raw materials but because of increase in wages and other expenses. This will be so because hedging can offset losses only on account of raw materials which are traded at the commodity exchanges. It cannot obviously affect other costs entering the total cost of production.

Speculation v/s Arbitration v/s Hedging

Arbitrage

Arbitrage is the act of buying and selling an asset simultaneously in different markets to profit from a mismatch in prices. Arbitrage opportunities arise due to the inefficiency of the markets. Arbitrage is a common practice in currency trade and stocks listed on multiple exchanges. For instance, suppose the shares of company XYZ are listed on the National Stock Exchange in India as well as the New York Stock Exchange in the US. On certain occasions, there will be a mismatch in the share price of XYZ on the NSE and NYSE due to currency fluctuations. Ideally, after considering the exchange rate, the share price of XYZ on both the exchanges should be the same. However, stock movements, the difference in time zones and exchange rate fluctuations create a temporary mismatch in prices. Seizing the opportunity, arbitrage traders buy on the exchange where the share price is lower and sell the same quantity on the exchange with the higher share price.

Arbitrage opportunities are very short-lived as markets have been designed to be highly efficient. Once an arbitrage opportunity is used, it quickly disappears as the mismatch is corrected. While arbitrage is more common in identical instruments, many traders also take advantage of a predictable relationship between instruments. Generally, the price of a mismatch is exceedingly small. To profit from a small price differential, traders must place large orders to generate adequate profits. If executed properly, arbitrage trades are relatively less risky; however, a sudden change in the exchange rate or high trading commission can make arbitrage opportunities unfeasible.

Speculation

Every trade is based on the expectation of the investor. The markets function only because someone is willing to buy and someone on the other end is willing to buy. The seller generally expects the price to fall and sells to monetise his profit, while the buyer expects the price to rise and hence enters the counter to generate returns. Speculation is the broad term for trading based on expectation, assumption or hunch. The speculation involves considerable risk of loss. The primary driver of speculation is the probability of earning significant profits. Speculation is not limited to financial instruments; it is common in other assets also. For instance, speculation is common in the real estate market. Extreme speculation leads to the formation of asset bubbles like the dot com bubble in the early 2000s and tulip bubble in medieval times. The profit margin can be high in speculative trades, so even small traders can trade based on speculation.

Arbitrage vs speculation

Arbitrage and speculation are two different financial strategies. The major differences between arbitrage vs speculation are the size of the trade, time duration, risk and structure. Only large traders can take advantage of arbitrage opportunities as they are short-lived, and the profit margin is small which requires scale. Speculation doesn’t have any such limitations; even small traders can place bets based on speculation. Speculative trades can last anywhere from a few minutes to several months, but the same cannot be said about arbitrage trades. Arbitrage opportunities arise due to market inefficiencies and disappear as soon as someone utilises it. Arbitrageurs buy and sell the same asset simultaneously. The simultaneous nature of arbitrage trade limits the risk for the trader. On the other hand, the risk of loss remains high in the case of speculative trade as speculative price movements are based on the assumption of many people.

Arbitrageurs

Arbitrage is the simultaneous purchase and sale of equivalent assets at prices which guarantee a fixed profit at the time of the transactions, although the life of the assets and, hence, the consummation of the profit may be delayed until some future date. The key element in the definition is that the amount of profit be determined with certainty. It specifically excludes transactions which guarantee a minimum rate of return but which also offer an option for increased profits. Arbitrageurs are in business to take advantage of a discrepancy between prices in two different markets (Eg : NSE and BSE) . If, for example, they see the futures price of an asset getting out of line with the cash price, they will take offsetting positions in the two markets to lock in a profit.

Hedgers

Hedging is the simultaneous purchase and sale of two assets in the expectation of a gain from different subsequent movements in the price of those assets. Usually the two assets are equivalent in all respects except maturity. Hedgers face risk associated with the price of an asset. They use futures or options markets to reduce or eliminate this risk.

Speculators

Speculation is the purchase or sale of an asset in the expectation of a gain from changes in the price of that asset. Speculators wish to bet on future movements in the price of an asset. Futures and options contracts can give them an extra leverage; that is, they can increase both the potential gains and potential losses in a speculative venture. Day traders are speculators. NB : While Hedgers look to protect against a price change, speculators look to make profit from a price change. Also, the hedger gives up some opportunity in exchange for reduced risk. The speculator on the other hand acquires opportunity in exchange for taking on risk.

Can Speculation / Arbitration / Hedging mitigate financial risk for Companies?

Some financial risks can be shared through financial instruments known as derivatives, futures contracts or hedging. For example, exposure to foreign exchange risk can be mitigated by swapping currency requirements with another market participant. Equally other risks such as interest rate risk can be managed through the use of derivatives. These arrangements are usually managed under the common terms set out in the International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA) master agreement.

Hedging arrangements will influence the cost of debt, and the breakage costs to be included in termination compensation. Hedge counterparties, or possibly a hedging bank, will be a party to the intercreditor agreement to formalize the sharing of security and arrangements on default. To the extent that hedge counterparties benefit from project security, in theory their hedges should also be limited recourse. Similarly, if hedge counterparties get paid out if they suffer a loss when they close out their hedge, then lenders will argue that they should share any windfall profits. These issues will be addressed in the intercreditor arrangements.

Derivatives are used in many functions in project finance transactions, including

  • Interest rate swaps: To manage movements in exchange rates to convert variable rate debt to fixed rate debt;
  • Currency swaps: To manage movements in currency exchange rates; and
  • Commodity derivatives: To fix the price of commodities over time.

The offtake purchaser may agree to bear interest rate risk, by indexing part of its tariff to cost of debt. However, such tariff adjustments to account for interest rate fluctuations are unlikely to be applied at the speed at which interest rate fluctuations can arise, creating a mismatch risk. Guarantees and other credit enhancement mechanisms can be used to mobilize fixed rate debt.

error: Content is protected !!