Doctrine of Indoor Management and exceptions

The Doctrine of Indoor Management is a legal principle that protects outsiders dealing with a company. It says that people dealing with a company in good faith are entitled to assume that the internal procedures and rules of the company have been properly followed, even if in reality they have not.

Origin

This doctrine was first established in the English case:

  • Royal British Bank v. Turquand (1856)

In this case, the court held that an outsider (the bank) could assume that the company had followed its internal rules in borrowing money, even though internal approvals were missing.

⚖ Legal Position in India

Indian courts have accepted this doctrine and applied it consistently. It is a counterbalance to the Doctrine of Constructive Notice, which binds outsiders to the public documents of the company (e.g., Memorandum and Articles of Association).

Key Features

  1. Protects outsiders who act in good faith.

  2. Assumes that internal procedures (e.g., board resolutions, approvals) have been complied with.

  3. Ensures business convenience and trust in corporate dealings.

  4. Especially important when companies do not disclose their internal governance openly.

Examples

  • If the Articles of Association say that borrowing must be approved by a resolution, and an officer borrows money, the lender can assume the resolution has been passed—even if it wasn’t—unless they had reason to doubt it.

  • A contract signed by a managing director is valid unless the outsider knows that the MD didn’t have the authority.

Exceptions to the Doctrine of Indoor Management

The protection offered by the doctrine is not absolute. There are important exceptions where the outsider cannot claim protection:

1. Knowledge of Irregularity

If the outsider knew about the internal irregularity, they cannot claim protection.

🧾 Example: A supplier knows that a manager is acting without board approval but still proceeds with the deal.

2. Suspicion of Irregularity

If the circumstances are suspicious and would make a reasonable person inquire further, failure to do so loses the protection.

🧾 Example: A company secretary signs a large contract alone, without any board member. This may raise suspicion.

3. Forgery

The doctrine does not apply to forgery. A forged document is void, and no one can rely on it, even in good faith.

🧾 Example: A forged share certificate issued by an employee is not binding on the company.

4. Acts Outside Apparent Authority

If the act done is clearly beyond the powers of the officer (ultra vires), the company is not bound.

🧾 Example: A clerk signing a loan agreement beyond their role.

5. Negligence by Outsider

If the outsider fails to verify facts when it is easy to do so, courts may not offer protection.

🧾 Example: Not checking the authority of a director for a high-value transaction.

Meaning, Contents, Forms of Articles of Association and its Alteration

Articles of Association (AoA) is a key legal document required for the incorporation of a company. It outlines the internal regulations and governance structure of the company, setting the rules for how it will be managed and controlled. While the Memorandum of Association (MoA) defines the company’s relationship with the external world, the AoA focuses on its internal functioning. Together, these documents form the company’s constitution, determining its objectives and operational framework.

AoA must be submitted to the Registrar of Companies (RoC) during incorporation and must align with the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013 in India. It governs aspects like the conduct of board meetings, the appointment of directors, share transfers, and the rights and duties of shareholders.

Meaning of Articles of Association:

Articles of Association is a legal document that outlines the rules for a company’s internal management and procedures. It defines the responsibilities of the directors, the processes for making decisions, the rights and duties of shareholders, and the company’s rules for issuing and transferring shares. The AoA provides a framework for running the company’s day-to-day operations and ensuring smooth governance.

While the MoA defines the company’s objectives and limits, the AoA allows for flexibility in how those objectives are achieved. It acts as a contract between the company and its members (shareholders), as well as among the members themselves, ensuring that the company is managed in accordance with agreed rules and practices.

Contents of Articles of Association:

Companies Act, 2013, provides significant flexibility in drafting the Articles of Association, allowing companies to customize their internal regulations.

  1. Share Capital and Variation of Rights

AoA outlines the company’s share capital structure, including the different classes of shares (e.g., equity shares, preference shares), and their respective rights and restrictions. It also specifies the process for issuing new shares, altering share capital, and varying the rights attached to different classes of shares.

  1. Transfer and Transmission of Shares

This section of the AoA provides the rules for transferring shares between shareholders, including the procedure for the sale or gift of shares. It also covers the transmission of shares in the event of the death or insolvency of a shareholder. The AoA may include restrictions on share transfers, especially in the case of private limited companies, where shares cannot be freely transferred.

  1. Board of Directors

AoA specifies the composition of the Board of Directors, their powers, and the procedures for their appointment and removal. It may include details about the minimum and maximum number of directors, the qualifications required to become a director, and the process for filling vacancies on the board. Additionally, it governs the roles and responsibilities of the board in managing the company’s affairs.

  1. Meetings and Voting Rights

AoA outlines the rules for holding meetings of the board and shareholders, including the notice period, quorum requirements, and procedures for passing resolutions. It also specifies the voting rights of shareholders and directors, including whether decisions are made by simple majority or special resolution.

  1. Dividends and Reserves

AoA defines the procedure for declaring and distributing dividends to shareholders. It includes the company’s policy on retaining profits for reserves, the amount to be distributed as dividends, and the process for calculating and paying dividends to shareholders.

  1. Borrowing Powers

This section defines the borrowing powers of the company, including the authority of the Board of Directors to raise loans or issue debentures. It outlines the terms and conditions under which the company can borrow funds, including any limitations on borrowing.

  1. Accounts and Audits

AoA specifies the rules regarding the maintenance of accounts, auditing of financial statements, and the appointment of auditors. It may also detail the financial year of the company and the process for approving and filing annual financial statements.

  1. Winding Up

AoA includes provisions for the winding up of the company, detailing the process for liquidation and the distribution of assets in the event of the company’s dissolution. It may outline how assets are to be distributed among shareholders, creditors, and other stakeholders.

  1. Indemnity

AoA may include an indemnity clause that provides protection to the company’s officers and directors against liabilities incurred in the course of performing their duties, provided they act in good faith.

Forms of Articles of Association:

AoA can take various forms depending on the type and structure of the company. While there is no prescribed form for the AoA under the Companies Act, 2013, the following are the common types of companies that need to customize their Articles:

  1. Private Limited Companies

Private companies tend to have more restrictive Articles, particularly concerning the transfer of shares and the maximum number of shareholders. The AoA of a private limited company often includes specific provisions limiting the right to transfer shares, setting out processes for director appointments, and defining the company’s internal governance structure.

  1. Public Limited Companies

AoA of public limited companies is generally more flexible compared to private limited companies, particularly in areas like share transfer and raising capital. Public companies must comply with additional regulatory requirements, and their AoA typically includes provisions that align with listing agreements and stock exchange rules.

  1. One Person Companies (OPC)

In the case of One Person Companies, the AoA is relatively simple, as the company has only one shareholder and fewer compliance requirements. The AoA of an OPC will typically focus on the limited role of the single shareholder in managing the company’s affairs.

Alteration of Articles of Association:

Companies Act, 2013, allows for the alteration of the AoA as long as the changes comply with legal requirements and are approved by the shareholders. The AoA is a flexible document, and companies often need to update it to reflect changes in their business environment or governance needs.

Process for Altering the Articles of Association

  1. Board Resolution:

The process for altering the AoA begins with the Board of Directors passing a resolution to propose changes to the Articles. The resolution must specify the reasons for the proposed alteration and schedule a general meeting of the shareholders.

  1. Special Resolution:

The alteration of the AoA requires approval from the shareholders by passing a special resolution in the general meeting. A special resolution requires at least 75% of the shareholders to vote in favor of the changes.

  1. Filing with the Registrar of Companies (RoC):

Once the special resolution is passed, the company must file the altered AoA with the RoC using the prescribed forms (e.g., Form MGT-14). The alteration becomes effective only after the RoC registers the modified AoA.

  1. Approval by Regulatory Authorities:

In certain cases, the alteration may require approval from other regulatory bodies. For example, changes to the AoA of a public company listed on a stock exchange must be approved by the stock exchange or the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI).

Limitations on Alteration:

  • Consistency with the Memorandum of Association:

AoA cannot contain provisions that are inconsistent with the MoA. The MoA takes precedence, and any changes to the Articles must be in alignment with the company’s objectives as set out in the MoA.

  • Statutory Restrictions:

Certain statutory provisions, such as those related to the rights of minority shareholders, cannot be altered without complying with the provisions of the Companies Act.

Doctrine of Ultra-vires

The Doctrine of Ultra Vires is a fundamental principle of Company Law. It defines the legal boundaries within which a company must operate. The term “Ultra Vires” is derived from Latin, meaning “beyond the powers.” In legal terms, any act conducted by a company beyond the scope of its objectives defined in the Memorandum of Association (MOA) is termed as Ultra Vires and hence is void ab initio (invalid from the outset). This doctrine is a key safeguard for investors and creditors, ensuring that the company acts only within its legal capacity.

Origin of the Doctrine:

The doctrine was first established in the landmark English case Ashbury Railway Carriage and Iron Co. Ltd. v. Riche (1875). In this case, the company entered into a contract to finance the construction of a railway in Belgium, which was outside the scope of its MOA. The court held that since the contract was Ultra Vires the company, it was void, even if all shareholders agreed.

Legal Framework in India:

In India, the Doctrine of Ultra Vires is recognized under the Companies Act, 2013, especially concerning the MOA (Memorandum of Association). As per Section 4(1)(c) of the Act, the objects clause must define the main and ancillary objectives of the company. Any act beyond these objectives is deemed Ultra Vires and cannot be legally ratified.

Purpose of the Doctrine:

The main objectives of the Doctrine of Ultra Vires include:

  1. Protecting Investors: It ensures that the capital contributed by shareholders is used only for lawful and intended purposes.

  2. Protecting Creditors: Lenders and creditors are protected by ensuring the company does not engage in unauthorized ventures that could risk insolvency.

  3. Preventing Misuse of Power: Directors and officers are restricted from using company funds or authority for unintended activities.

Types of Ultra Vires Acts:

  • Ultra Vires the Company (Beyond MOA):

Any act not authorized by the MOA is completely void. Neither the shareholders nor directors can ratify such an act.

  • Ultra Vires the Directors but Intra Vires the Company:

If an act is within the MOA but beyond the authority of the directors, it can be ratified by the shareholders.

  • Ultra Vires the Articles but Intra Vires the Company:

Acts beyond the Articles of Association (AOA) but within the MOA can be altered by a special resolution.

Key Implications of the Doctrine:

  • Void and Inoperative

Ultra Vires contracts are void ab initio. No rights, liabilities, or obligations arise from such acts.

  • Directors’ Personal Liability

If directors engage in ultra vires acts, they can be held personally liable for the losses caused.

  • Injunction

Shareholders can apply for an injunction to prevent the company from performing ultra vires acts.

  • Property Acquired Ultra Vires

If a company acquires property under an ultra vires transaction, it can retain the property unless restitution is possible.

  • Borrowing Powers

If a company borrows funds beyond its authorized powers, it must repay the amount if it still possesses the money or assets bought.

Examples of Ultra Vires Acts:

  • A company whose MOA limits its business to textile manufacturing enters into real estate development — this is ultra vires the company.

  • If the directors enter into a foreign partnership without board approval, it is ultra vires the directors but not the company, and can be ratified.

Criticism of the Doctrine:

  • Too Rigid

It does not allow flexibility for businesses to respond to dynamic market conditions or diversify into new ventures.

  • Outdated in Modern Practice

Modern companies often include very broad objects clauses to avoid the constraints of ultra vires.

  • Can Lead to Inequity

Innocent third parties may suffer even when they act in good faith, as ultra vires contracts are unenforceable.

Current Position in India:

The Companies Act, 2013, has made the objects clause more flexible. Companies now often include broad objectives to reduce the risk of ultra vires actions. Section 245 also allows shareholders to file a class action suit if the company or its management acts beyond its authority.

Furthermore, Section 13 of the Act allows companies to alter the MOA through special resolutions, enabling them to expand their object clause to accommodate new activities — subject to approval from the Registrar of Companies (ROC).

Safeguards Against Ultra Vires Acts:

  • Well-Drafted MOA

Including a wide range of business objectives helps reduce ultra vires risk.

  • Legal Due Diligence

Companies should ensure all contracts and operations are in line with their registered objectives.

  • Board Oversight

Directors must stay updated and ensure compliance with the company’s charter documents.

  • Stakeholder Vigilance

Shareholders and creditors should monitor company actions through AGMs and audits.

Meaning, Contents, Forms and Alteration of Memorandum of Association

Memorandum of Association (MoA) is a fundamental legal document required for the incorporation of a company. It serves as the company’s constitution, defining its relationship with the external world and outlining the scope of its operations. Every company in India, whether public or private, must have a Memorandum of Association to be registered under the Companies Act, 2013. The MoA sets the foundation for a company’s legal existence and binds the company, its shareholders, and all those who interact with the company to the terms contained within it.

Meaning of Memorandum of Association:

Memorandum of Association is essentially a charter or a framework that outlines the objectives, powers, and scope of the company. It defines the company’s boundaries and specifies what the company can and cannot do. The MoA acts as a contract between the company and the shareholders, as well as between the company and the external parties it deals with.

The purpose of the MoA is to ensure that the company operates within its defined objectives, and it provides clarity to shareholders, creditors, and third parties regarding the nature and scope of the company’s business. Any action taken by the company beyond the scope of the MoA is considered ultra vires (beyond the powers) and may be deemed invalid.

Contents of the Memorandum of Association:

Companies Act, 2013, specifies the mandatory contents of the MoA, and each clause plays a significant role in determining the company’s structure and operational framework. The key components of a Memorandum of Association are:

1. Name Clause

The name clause specifies the name of the company. The name must be unique and not identical or similar to any existing registered company. The name must also comply with naming guidelines under the Companies Act:

  • For a Private Limited Company, the name must end with “Private Limited.”
  • For a Public Limited Company, the name must end with “Limited.”

Additionally, the name should not infringe on any trademarks or offend public morality.

2. Registered Office Clause

This clause specifies the registered office of the company, which serves as its official address. It is the location where legal documents, notices, and other communications can be sent. The company must provide the complete address of the registered office upon incorporation, and any changes to the address must be notified to the Registrar of Companies (RoC).

3. Object Clause

The object clause is one of the most critical sections of the MoA, as it outlines the main objectives for which the company is formed. The object clause is divided into:

  • Main Objects: The primary activities the company will undertake. Any business conducted by the company must be aligned with these objects.
  • Ancillary or Incidental Objects: Activities necessary to achieve the main objects.

The object clause restricts the company’s activities to those mentioned in the MoA. Any business conducted outside the scope of this clause is considered ultra vires.

4. Liability Clause

This clause defines the extent of the liability of the company’s shareholders. In a company limited by shares, the liability of shareholders is limited to the unpaid amount on their shares. If the company is limited by guarantee, the liability is limited to the amount each member agrees to contribute in the event of liquidation.

5. Capital Clause

The capital clause specifies the company’s authorized share capital. It mentions the total amount of capital with which the company is registered and the division of this capital into shares of a fixed value. This clause sets a limit on the amount of share capital that the company can issue unless it is altered through a formal process.

6. Subscription Clause

Subscription clause lists the names of the initial subscribers to the Memorandum, who agree to take up shares in the company. It also indicates the number of shares each subscriber agrees to take. Each subscriber must sign the MoA in the presence of at least one witness.

7. Association or Declaration Clause

This clause includes a declaration by the original members, stating their intent to form the company and agree to become its first shareholders. The subscribers to the MoA declare that they wish to associate themselves with the company.

Forms of Memorandum of Association:

Under the Companies Act, 2013, companies can be formed in various categories, and the MoA must reflect the company’s type. The MoA can be drafted in different forms depending on the type of company:

  • Table A: For companies limited by shares.
  • Table B: For companies limited by guarantee but not having share capital.
  • Table C: For companies limited by guarantee and having share capital.
  • Table D: For unlimited companies.
  • Table E: For unlimited companies having share capital.

Each form provides a template for the drafting of the MoA according to the specific type of company being incorporated.

Alteration of Memorandum of Association:

Although the MoA is a rigid document that outlines the company’s operational limits, it can be altered under specific circumstances. The process for altering the MoA is governed by the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013. The alteration is allowed only if it is approved by a special resolution of the shareholders and is registered with the RoC.

1. Alteration of the Name Clause

The name of the company can be changed by passing a special resolution in the general meeting. However, if the company is changing its status from a private company to a public company or vice versa, it must also obtain approval from the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT). The change must be registered with the RoC, and a fresh certificate of incorporation must be issued.

2. Alteration of the Registered Office Clause

The registered office can be changed:

  • Within the same city or town: By passing a board resolution and informing the RoC.
  • From one city or town to another within the same state: By passing a special resolution and informing the RoC.
  • From one state to another: Requires approval from both the shareholders and the Regional Director, and a special resolution must be passed. After approval, the RoC must be notified, and the alteration registered.

3. Alteration of the Object Clause

The object clause can be altered by passing a special resolution in the general meeting. Additionally, if the alteration affects the rights of existing creditors, their consent is required. The revised object clause must be filed with the RoC within 30 days of passing the resolution.

4. Alteration of the Liability Clause

The liability clause can be altered only if the company is converting from an unlimited liability company to a limited liability company, or vice versa. Such a change requires the approval of shareholders through a special resolution and must be registered with the RoC.

5. Alteration of the Capital Clause

The authorized share capital of the company can be increased by passing an ordinary resolution at the general meeting. The company must file the relevant forms with the RoC and pay the requisite fees. The change is effective once the alteration is registered.

Allotment of Shares, Types, Rules, Restrictions

Allotment of Shares refers to the process by which a company distributes its shares to applicants who have subscribed during an offering, such as an Initial Public Offering (IPO) or private placement. Once the subscription period ends, the company reviews the applications, determines the allocation of shares, and officially assigns them to the investors. Allotment is done based on the availability of shares and the demand. If the offering is oversubscribed, shares may be distributed on a proportionate basis or through a lottery system, ensuring fairness to applicants.

Types of Allotment of Shares:

  1. Public or Initial Allotment:

This occurs when a company issues shares for the first time through an Initial Public Offering (IPO) or a Follow-on Public Offer (FPO). Shares are allotted to the public based on their applications and may be determined through a fixed price or book-building process. If oversubscribed, allotment is done proportionally.

  1. Private Placement:

Shares are allotted to a select group of investors, such as institutional investors, private equity firms, or wealthy individuals. It doesn’t involve public participation and is often quicker and subject to fewer regulatory hurdles.

  1. Rights Issue Allotment:

Existing shareholders are given the opportunity to purchase additional shares in proportion to their current shareholding, often at a discounted price. Shares are allotted based on the shareholder’s entitlement and their decision to take up the offer.

Rules Regarding Allotment of Shares:

  1. Minimum Subscription Rule:

A company can allot shares only if it receives a minimum subscription of 90% of the total issue within a specified period. If the company fails to achieve this, the issue must be canceled, and the application money is refunded to investors.

  1. SEBI Guidelines (for Public issues):

Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) sets rules for public issues, including requirements for disclosing financial details, ensuring fair pricing, and the process for allotting shares. Companies must follow these guidelines when issuing shares through IPOs or public offers.

  1. Time Limit for Allotment:

Shares must be allotted within a prescribed time frame, usually 60 days from the date of receiving the application. If the company fails to allot shares within this period, it must refund the application money within 15 days. Otherwise, the company is liable to pay interest on the amount.

  1. Return of Allotment:

After allotting shares, the company must file a Return of Allotment (Form PAS-3) with the Registrar of Companies (ROC) within 30 days. This document details the number of shares allotted, the shareholders, and the allotment process.

  1. Listing Requirements:

If the shares are issued through an IPO or public offer, the company must ensure that the shares are listed on a recognized stock exchange. The allotment must comply with the rules and regulations of the stock exchange as well.

  1. Proper Allotment Procedures:

The company must follow proper procedures during the allotment, including board approval, maintaining proper records of applicants, and ensuring fairness in case of oversubscription (proportional allotment or lottery system).

  1. Non-Payment of Allotment Money:

If a shareholder fails to pay the allotment money, the company has the right to forfeit the shares after providing due notice.

Restrictions on Allotment of Shares:

  1. Minimum Subscription:

Company cannot proceed with the allotment of shares unless it receives at least 90% of the total issue as a minimum subscription. If this threshold is not met, the company must refund the application money to investors. This ensures that the company raises adequate capital to meet its objectives.

  1. Approval by Regulatory Authorities:

In the case of public offers, companies must receive approvals from regulatory authorities such as the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) and comply with its guidelines. Any non-compliance can lead to a restriction on the allotment process.

  1. Time Limit for Allotment:

Shares must be allotted within 60 days from the date of receiving the share application. If the company fails to allot shares within this period, the application money must be refunded to the investors within the next 15 days. If not, the company must pay interest at a specified rate.

  1. Prohibition on Allotment Before Filing the Prospectus:

Companies issuing shares to the public must file a prospectus with the Registrar of Companies (ROC) before making any allotment. Allotment without issuing or filing a prospectus is prohibited and can be declared void.

  1. Return of Allotment:

After allotment, companies are required to file a Return of Allotment (Form PAS-3) with the ROC within 30 days of the allotment. If this form is not filed, further allotments may be restricted, and penalties may be imposed.

  1. Oversubscription and Proportional Allotment:

In cases of oversubscription (when applications exceed the number of shares available), the company is restricted from issuing more shares than initially offered. It must allocate shares on a proportionate basis or through a fair method, such as a lottery system, to ensure equitable distribution.

  1. Restrictions on Allotment to Certain Investors:

  • Foreign Investors: Allotment to foreign investors must comply with the Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) guidelines. Companies cannot allot shares to foreign nationals or institutions without adhering to these rules.
  • Restricted Categories: Allotments may be restricted for certain categories of investors, such as related parties or company insiders, without appropriate board approvals or shareholder resolutions.
  1. Non-Payment of Allotment Money:

If the allotment money is not paid by the applicant within the specified time, the company has the right to forfeit the shares. The allottee loses their entitlement to the shares and any amount already paid.

  1. SEBI Regulations (for Listed Companies):

For listed companies, allotment of shares must comply with SEBI’s guidelines, including transparency, proper disclosures, and fair pricing. Failure to adhere to these regulations can restrict further share allotments.

  1. Lock-in Period:

For certain types of shareholders, especially promoters and institutional investors in private placements, a lock-in period may apply. During this period, these shareholders are restricted from selling or transferring their shares.

Calls on Shares

Reputed companies require the applicants to send the full value of the shares along with the applications. This is because, the Companies Act does not prohibit companies to collect the entire amount at the time of issue itself. But the usual practice of the companies is to collect a certain percentage of the face value of the shares on application and allotment and the balance in one or more installments known as calls.

A call may be defined as a demand made by the company on its shareholders to pay a part or the whole of the unpaid balance within a specified time. Lord Lindley says that the expression “Call” denotes both the demand for money and also the sum demanded.

The following points should be noted, in this context, so that the reader can understand what a call really means.

  1. Time for Making the Call: The call can be made at any time during the life time of the company or during the course of winding up. During the life time, the call should be made by the Board of Directors and during the course of winding up, it should be made by the liquidator.
  2. Obligatory: Each shareholder is obliged to pay the amount of call as and when the call is made. But, this liability arises only when the call is made and not before.
  3. Debt Due: As soon as a call is made, the call amount shall become a debt due from the shareholders to the company.
  4. Consequences of Default: If a shareholder fails to pay the call amount, the company can enforce payment of the amount together with interest or can forfeit the shares.
  5. Calls and Other Payments: A call is different from other payments made by a shareholder. The amounts paid on application and allotment are not calls. Similarly, if a company requires the shareholders to pay the entire amount either on application or on allotment, it is not a call under this Act.

Legal Provisions Relating to the Calls

The statutory provisions relating to the making of calls can be summed up as follows:

  1. Call should Bona fide: The power to make call is generally in nature of a trust and so it can be exercised bona fide and for the benefit of the company. It should not be made for private ends. It means the directors or the liquidator can make the call only when there is a bona fide need for funds.
  2. Uniformity: The calls should be made on an uniform basis on all the shares falling under the same class. If a call is made only on some shareholders of the same class but not on others or a greater amount is demanded from some shareholders and a lesser amount from others of the same class, the call is not valid.
  3. Provisions of the Articles: The calls should be made strictly in accordance with the provisions of the Articles. If this is not done, the call will be invalid.

Procedure for making Calls

Generally, the procedure for making calls is incorporated in the Articles of most companies. If a company has its own Articles, it should follow the provisions of its Articles. If not, the regulations specified in Table A of the Act shall apply.

The following provisions of Table A can be noted at this stage.

  1. The power to make calls generally vests in the Board of Directors.
  2. The calls should be made by passing a resolution at the meeting of the Board.
  3. The call money should not exceed 50% of the face value of the share at one time. However, companies may have their own Articles and raise this limit.
  4. There must be at least 30 days interval between two successive calls.
  5. When a call is made a letter known as “Call Letter” or “Call Notice” should be sent to all the shareholders of the same class.
  6. The notice should also specify the amount of the call, place of payment etc. and should be sent at least 14 days before the last date for payment.
  7. The Board of directors has the power to revoke or postpone a call after it is made.
  8. Joint shareholders are jointly and severally liable for payment of calls.
  9. If a member fails to pay call money, he is liable to pay interest not exceeding the rate specified in the Articles or terms of issue. The directors are free to waive the payment of interest.
  10. If any member desires to pay the call money in advance, the directors may at their discretion accept and pay interest not exceeding the rate specified in the Articles.
  11. A defaulting member will not have any voting right till call money is paid by him.

Difference between Share & Stock

Share

A share is defined as the smallest division of the share capital of the company which represents the proportion of ownership of the shareholders in the company. The shares are the bridge between the shareholders and the company. The shares are offered in the stock market or markets for sale, to raise capital for the company. The shares are movable property which can be transferred in a manner specified in the Articles of Association of the company.

The shares are mainly divided into two categories: Equity shares and Preference shares.

Equity shares are the common shares of the company which carries voting rights while Preference shares are the shares which carry preferential rights for the payment of dividend and also for the repayment of capital in the event of winding up of the company.

The shares of a company can be issued in three ways:

  • Par
  • Premium
  • Discount

Stock

The stock is a mere collection of the shares of a member of a company in a lump sum. When the shares of a member are converted into one fund is known as stock. A public company limited by shares can convert its fully paid-up shares into stock. However, the original issue of stock is not possible. For the conversion of the shares into stock the following conditions are to be fulfilled in this regard:

  • The Articles of Association should specify such conversion.
  • The company should pass an Ordinary Resolution (OR) in the Annual General Meeting (AGM) of the company.
  • The company shall give notice to the ROC (Registrar of Companies) about the conversion of shares into stock within the prescribed time.

After the conversion of shares into the stock, Register of members of the company will show the stock held by each member, in place of shares held by them. Although, there should not be any change in the voting rights of the members. In addition to this, there is no effect on the transferability of shares. Instead, they can now be transferred in the fraction. They are of two types: Common Stock and Preferred Stock.

As per Section 61, Companies Act, 2013, the company can convert its shares which are fully paid up, into stock. A Share is the smallest unit into which the company’s capital is divided, representing the ownership of the shareholders in the company. A ‘Stock‘ on the other hand is a collection of shares of a member that are fully paid up. When shares are transformed into stock, the shareholder becomes a stockholder, who possess same right with respect to the dividend, as a shareholder possess.

All the shares are of equal denomination, whereas the denomination of stock differs. When one wants to invest in shares, he/she must be aware of the difference between shares and stock, along with the conditions, when shares are converted into stock. Take a read of the article, in which we have discussed, the entire concept of these two.

Share Stock
Meaning The capital of a company, is divided into small units, which are commonly known as shares. The conversion of the fully paid up shares of a member into a single fund is known as stock.
Is it possible for a company to make original issue? Yes No
Paid up value Shares can be partly or fully paid up. Stock can only be fully paid up.
Definite number A share have a definite number known as distinctive number. A stock does not have such number.
Fractional transfer Not possible. Possible
Nominal value Yes No
Denomination Equal amounts Unequal amounts

Mis Statement and Their Remedies

Mis-Statements in Prospectus:

Mis-statements and false statements in the prospectus are instruments by which dishonest company promoters may practice fraud on the public money. In order to prevent this practice the law imposes certain duties and liabilities on those persons who are responsible for such issues.

If, however, the prospectus contains any mis-statement of a material fact or if the prospectus wants in any material fact, two types of liabilities will arise.

They are:

(1) Civil Liability

(2) Criminal Liability

Before discussing the above we are to know the liability which may arise for Untrue Statement. It is the duty of the authors of the prospectus to see that the prospectus does not contain any untrue statement which may mislead the public.

According to Sec. 65 of the Companies Act, Untrue Statement’ in connection with a prospectus shall deem to include:

(i) A statement which is misleading in the form and context in which it is included, and

(ii) An omission which is calculated to mislead.

In short, untrue statement means and includes any statement which is not only a false statement but also a statement which creates a wrong impression of actual fact. Concealment of material fact is also treated as mis-statement or untrue statement.

Now we are going to highlight the civil and criminal liabilities that may appear due to mis-statement in the prospectus:

(1) Civil Liability:

Sec. 62(1) of the Companies Act states that such persons are liable to pay compensation for any loss or damage which any person may suffer from the purchase of any share or debenture on the basis of the untrue statement. Consequently, a person who has suffered a loss may claim contribution from the others who were associated relating to issue of prospect until it appears that he was guilty of fraud while the others were not proved to be guilty.

(2) Criminal Liability:

According to Sec. 63(1) of the Companies Act, every person who has authorised the issue of a prospectus containing untrue statements shall be punishable with imprisonment which may extend to two years or with fine which may extend to Rs. 5,000 or both.

Penalty:

Sec. 68 of the Companies Act provides that a person shall not, either knowingly or recklessly, by making any statement, promise or forecast which is false, deceptive or misleading or, by any dishonest conceal­ment of material facts, induce or attempt to induce another person to enter into or to offer to enter into any

(i) Agreement for acquiring, disposing-off, subscribing for or underwriting shares or debentures;

(ii) Agreement, the purpose or pretended purpose of which is to secure a profit to any of the parties from the yield of shares or debentures, or by inference to fluctuations in the value of shares or debentures.

Otherwise, he shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which may extend to 5 years or with fine which may extend to Rs. 10,000 or with both.

Persons who are liable for untrue statements in the prospectus:

According to Sec. 62 (1) of the Companies Act, the following persons are liable and punishable for untrue statements in the prospectus:

(a) Every person who is a director of the company at the time of the issue of the prospectus;

(b) Every person who has authorised himself to be named and is named in the prospectus either as a director or as having agreed to become a director, either immediately or after an interval of time;

(c) Every person who is a promoter of the company; and

(d) Every person who has authorised the issues of the prospectus.

Defence available in an action on the prospectus:

The parties against whom the proceeding have been taken for mis-statement in the prospectus may use certain pleas as their defence:

  1. Defences against the Civil Liability:

According to Sec. 62(2) of the Companies Act, no decree for damage shall be passed if the person charged can prove any one of the followings:

(a) Withdrawal of consent:

A person is not liable if he withdrew his consent before the issue of the prospectus.

(b) Issue without knowledge and consent:

If the person can prove that the prospectus was issued without his knowledge or consent and, after becoming aware of its issues, he gave public notice that the same was issued without his knowledge and consent.

(c) Statement of an expert:

If the statement which is alleged to be untrue purports to be a statement of an expert or a copy or of a valuation report of an expert, the person charged can be discharged from his liability if he can prove:

(i) It is a fair and correct copy or representation or extract of the expert’s statement;

(ii) He had reasonable grounds to believe;

(iii) The expert had given his consent to the issue of the prospectus;

(iv) The expert had not withdrawn his consent before registration.

(d) True Statement:

The person charged can escape from his liability if he can prove that he had reasonable ground to believe and did, up to the time of the allotment of shares or debentures, believe that the statement was true.

  1. Defences available to an expert:

Sec. 62(4) states that an expert whose opinion was included in the prospectus can use the following as defence:

(a) Withdrawal of consent:

After giving consent, he withdrew it in writing before delivery of a copy of the prospectus for registration.

(b) Knowledge of untrue statement:

If the person, on becoming aware of the untrue statement, withdrew his consent in writing and gave public notice with reasons thereof, after delivery of the copy of the prospectus to and before allotment.

(c) True statement:

He was competent to make such statement and he had reasonable grounds to believe and did up to the time of the allotment of shares and debentures, believe that the statement was true.

  1. Defense’s against Criminal Liability:

Sec. 63(1) states that a person charged in a criminal court will be acquitted if he can prove any one of the following:

(a) That the statement was immaterial, or

(b) That he had reasonable grounds to believe and did, up to the time of the issue of the prospectus, believe that the statement was true.

Prospectus, Statements in view of prospectus

Sec. 2(36) of the Companies Act describes a prospectus as any document issued as a prospectus and includes any notice, circular, advertisement or other document inviting deposits from the public or inviting offers from the public for the subscription or purchase of any share in, or debentures of a body corporate.”

In other words, it is a document which invites deposits from the public or invites offers from the public for the subscription of shares in, or debentures of, a company. The words “inviting deposits from the public” were added by the Companies (Amendment) Act, 1974.

Features and Characteristics of Prospectus:

(i) It is a document issued as a prospectus;

(ii) It is an invitation to the member of the public;

(iii) The public is invited to subscribe to the shares or debentures of the company;

(iv) It includes any notice, circular, advertisement inviting deposits from the public;

(v) It is a document by which the company procures its share capital needed to carry on its activities.

Forms and Contents of the Prospectus:

Sec. 56 states that every prospectus must

  1. State the matters specified in Part I of Schedule II, and
  2. Set out the reports specified in Part II of Schedule II.

The Statement in Lieu of Prospectus is a document filed with the Registrar of the Companies ( ROC ) when the company has not issued prospectus to the public for inviting them to subscribe for shares. The statement must contain the signatures of all the directors or their agents authorized in writing. It is similar to a prospectus but contains brief information. The Statement in Lieu of Prospectus needs to be filed with the registrar if the company does not issues prospectus or the company issued prospectus but because minimum subscription has not been received the company has not proceeded for the allotment of shares.

If a public company does not invite the public to subscribe for its shares but acquires to have money from private sources it may not issue a prospectus. In the circumstances, the promoters are required to prepare a draft prospectus which is known as ‘Statement in lieu of Prospectus’ which must contain the information required to be disclosed by Schedule III of the Act.

Sec. 70(1) states that a company having a share capital which does not issue a prospectus shall not allot any of its shares or debentures unless at least 3 days before the allotment of shares or debentures there has been delivered to the Registrar for registration a statement in lieu of prospectus.

The statement shall be signed by every person who is named therein as a director or proposed director of the company or by his authorised agent in writing. It shall be in the form and contain particulars set out in Schedule III of the Act.

Sec. 70(4) lays down that, in contravention of Sec. 70(1), the company and every director of the company, who wilfully authorizes or permits the contravention shall be punishable with fine which may extent to Rs. 1,000.

Similarly Sec. 70(5) also states that where the statement in lieu of prospectus contains any untrue statement, the persons responsible, for the issue thereof, may be punished by imprisonment which may extend to 2 years or with fine which may extend to Rs. 5,000, or with both.

Red Herring Prospectus:

A Red Herring Prospectus is a document which is submitted by an issuer company who intents to have public offerings of securities (i.e.; stock or bonds). It is associated with an Initial Public Offering (IPO). It must be filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The term Red herring comes from the tradition where young hunting dogs in Great Britain were trained in order to follow a scent by the use of ‘Red’ (i.e. salted and smoked) herring (i.e., kipper).

It is interesting to note that this pungent fish would be dragged across a trail until the puppy learned to follow the scent. But the term is used in prospectus simply due to disclosure statement which is printed in red ink on the cover which clearly states that the issuing company is not attempting to sell its shares.

Contents of Red Herring Prospectus:

(a) Purpose of the issue;

(b) Proposed offering Price Range;

(c) Promotion expenses;

(d) Copy of the underwriting agreement;

(e) Underwriter’s commission and discount;

(f) Disclosure of any option agreement;

(g) Balance Sheet;

(h) Net proceeds to the issuing company;

(i) Earning statement for .last three years;

(j) Legal option on the issue;

(k) Copies of the Articles of Incorporation of the issuer; and

(l) Names and addresses of all offices, underwriters, directors and stockholders owning 10% or more of the existing outstanding stock.

Share Capital, Features, Types

Share Capital refers to the total amount of capital raised by a company through the issue of shares to shareholders. It represents the ownership interest of shareholders in the company and forms a major part of the company’s funding. Share capital is divided into Equity shares and Preference shares, and it can be further categorized into authorized, issued, subscribed, and paid-up capital. The concept of share capital is crucial in determining voting rights, dividends, and the extent of liability of shareholders. It enables companies to raise long-term funds without incurring debt and provides investors with an opportunity to share in profits and ownership.

Features of Share Capital:

Share capital is the money raised by a company through the issuance of shares. It forms the financial foundation of a company and signifies the shareholders’ stake in the ownership of the business. The features of share capital reflect its role in corporate structure, investor relations, and financial stability.

1. Permanent Source of Capital

Share capital is a long-term and permanent source of finance for a company. Unlike loans or debentures, it is not repaid during the lifetime of the company. It stays invested in the business to support growth, operations, and expansion. This permanence strengthens the company’s financial structure and gives confidence to creditors. It is repayable only at the time of winding up, subject to the provisions of the Companies Act and satisfaction of liabilities.

2. Ownership Right

Share capital represents the ownership of the company. Shareholders are regarded as owners and not creditors of the company. The extent of their ownership depends on the number and type of shares they hold. Equity shareholders, in particular, have voting rights, control over company decisions, and a share in residual profits. This ownership right makes share capital unique as compared to borrowed funds, where lenders do not hold any ownership interest in the business.

3. Divisible into Small Units

Share capital is divided into small and equal parts called shares. This divisibility allows companies to raise capital from a large number of investors, even with small contributions. Each share has a nominal (face) value, and the shareholders receive share certificates as proof of ownership. This feature makes it easier for the company to mobilize large capital through public participation and offers flexibility to investors to invest as per their capacity.

4. Variety of Types

Share capital can be classified into different types to suit both company requirements and investor preferences. Major types include:

  • Authorized capital: maximum capital a company can raise

  • Issued capital: part offered to investors

  • Subscribed and paid-up capital: actually bought and paid for

  • Equity and preference shares: based on rights and returns

This classification helps companies structure their capital efficiently and offer flexibility in fundraising.

5. Limited Liability of Shareholders

A key feature of share capital is that it comes with limited liability for shareholders. Their financial responsibility is restricted to the unpaid amount on the shares they hold. They are not liable for company debts beyond this amount. This limitation encourages wider public investment as individuals are assured that their personal assets are protected. It distinguishes shareholders from proprietors or partners in firms who may face unlimited liability.

6. Transferability

In the case of public companies, shares representing share capital are generally freely transferable. Shareholders can sell their shares to others without seeking company approval (subject to applicable regulations). This feature ensures liquidity for investors, allowing them to exit when needed. However, in private companies, share transfer is usually restricted by the Articles of Association. Transferability adds flexibility and encourages investment in the corporate sector.

7. Right to Receive Dividends

Share capital entitles shareholders to dividends, which are a share in the company’s profits. While equity shareholders receive variable dividends declared by the company’s board, preference shareholders receive a fixed rate of dividend. Dividends are distributed only out of available profits and are not guaranteed. Still, the right to earn returns in the form of dividends makes shares an attractive investment, aligning investor interests with the company’s success.

Types of Share Capital:

  • Authorized Share Capital

Also known as nominal or registered capital, it refers to the maximum amount of capital that a company is authorized to raise through the issue of shares, as mentioned in its Memorandum of Association (MOA). A company cannot issue shares beyond this limit unless it amends the MOA by passing a resolution and obtaining regulatory approvals. Authorized capital determines the upper ceiling of a company’s financial base and is not necessarily fully issued or subscribed initially.

  • Issued Share Capital

Issued capital is the portion of authorized capital that the company actually offers to the public or investors for subscription. It may be equal to or less than the authorized capital. The company may issue shares in one or more stages, depending on its funding needs. For example, if a company has ₹10 lakh authorized capital and offers ₹5 lakh worth of shares to the public, then ₹5 lakh is the issued capital. It reflects the company’s active fundraising efforts.

  • Subscribed Share Capital

Subscribed capital is the part of issued capital that has been subscribed or agreed to be purchased by investors. It shows how much of the issued capital has actually been taken up by the public or private investors. For instance, if a company issues ₹5 lakh worth of shares and the public subscribes to ₹4 lakh, then the subscribed capital is ₹4 lakh. This type indicates the market response and investor confidence in the company.

  • Called-up Share Capital

Called-up capital is the portion of subscribed capital that the company has asked shareholders to pay. Companies may not ask for the full face value of shares immediately but may demand it in installments. For example, if a shareholder subscribes to 1,000 shares of ₹10 each and the company has called up only ₹6 per share, the called-up capital is ₹6,000. It indicates the actual demand made by the company for capital infusion.

  • Paid-up Share Capital

Paid-up capital is the portion of called-up capital that the shareholders have actually paid to the company. It is the real amount received by the company and forms part of the permanent capital. If some shareholders default in paying calls, then the paid-up capital is less than the called-up capital. For example, if ₹6,000 was called up and ₹5,800 was paid, then the paid-up capital is ₹5,800. It reflects the actual cash inflow from share capital.

  • Uncalled Capital

Uncalled capital is the portion of subscribed capital which has not yet been demanded (or “called”) by the company from its shareholders. This amount can be called in the future if the company needs additional funds. It represents a potential source of funding and is common in cases where shares are not fully paid up. It remains with shareholders until the company makes a formal call.

  • Reserve Capital

Reserve capital is a part of the uncalled capital that the company decides will be called up only at the time of winding up. It cannot be used during the lifetime of the company. The company must pass a special resolution to create reserve capital. It acts as a safety buffer for creditors in the event of liquidation, ensuring that some capital remains available to settle liabilities when the company is dissolved.

error: Content is protected !!