Tag: Corporate Policies

Management Notes

Causes for success and failure of start-ups in India

indiafreenotesby indiafreenotes0

According to the Startup India Portal, India has about 50,000 start-ups and is the 3rd largest ecosystem in the world. Start-ups are now emerging in tier-II and tier-III cities, such as Pune, Ahmedabad, and Kochi. Further, there is an increase in the investment flows from Chinese, Japanese, and Singapore based investors.

Causes for success

Reasons responsible for the growth of start-ups are:

  • Large Indian Market:

India’s diversity in culture, religion, and language has helped start-ups to create diversified products, according to the needs of a particular community. This becomes their Unique Selling Proposition, which in-turn entices investors to fund the start-up.

  • Fast-moving business environment:

In an uncertain and changing business ecosystem, the companies are under constant pressure to innovate to find a footing in the market. Sometimes, other companies invest or buy the start-ups to increase their own uniqueness.

  • Easy access to funds

The government has set up funds for easy startups in the form of venture capital.

  • Apply for tenders

New companies can apply for government tenders. They are excluded from the “related knowledge/turnover” standards appropriate for typical organizations explaining government tenders.

  • Reduction in cost

The government additionally gives arrangements of facilitators of licenses and brand names. They will give top-notch Intellectual Property Rights Services including quick assessment of licenses at lower expenses.

The government will bear all facilitator charges and the startup will bear just the legal expenses.

  • Tax holidays for three years

New companies will be excluded from income tax for a very long time, they get a certificate from the Inter-Ministerial Board (IMB).

  • R&D facilities

In the R&D area, seven new Research Parks will be set up to give offices to new businesses.

  • Tax saving for investors

Individuals putting their capital additions in the endeavor subsidizes arrangement by the government will get an exemption from capital increases. Thus, this will assist new companies to convince more investors.

  • Choose your investor

After this arrangement, the new companies will have an alternative to pick between the VCs, giving them the freedom to pick their investors.

  • Easy exit

Now, talking about the easy exit then if there should be an occurrence of exit, a startup can close its business within 90 days from the date of use of winding up.

  • No time-consuming compliances

For saving time and money numerous compliances have been facilitated for startups.

  • Meet other entrepreneurs

The government has proposed to hold 2 startup fests yearly both broadly and universally to empower the different partners of a startup to meet.

Causes for failure

Lack of focus

When Bill Gates and Warren Buffet were asked about one factor that was responsible for their success, both replied with one word: focus. To understand how focus can help, let’s look at an example.

Grubhub is a food delivery startup. From the beginning, the company decided to focus only on food delivery. There are a lot of other services that a company like that could offer- pickup of food, catering, and more, but the founders chose to focus on just delivery. The result? They could execute technically and operationally and grow the business successfully.

Lack of funds

In 2018, bike rental startup, Tazzo, shut shop. The reason, as given by one of its funding partners, was a failed product-market fit that led to drying up of funding. Even though the startup had raised a considerable amount of funds, the lack of a profitable business model led to the startup shutting down.

Lack of Product Market Fit

There is no one “Fits in all” formula. It has deeper layers to it. This is more of a framework than a goal. Many-a-times, startups fail to validate their product ideas in the existing market scenario. In today’s competitive world, it is important to bring in a product or service that is both problem-solving and fulfils the customer’s expectations in every way, be it price-related or output-related. You don’t want to be wasting your time and efforts on creating something for which there is ‘no market need’!

Lack of innovation

According to a survey, 77% of venture capitalists think that Indian startups lack innovation or unique business models. A study conducted by IBM Institute for Business Value found that 91% of startups fail within the first five years and the most common reason is – lack of innovation.

Although India is said to have the third-largest startup ecosystem, it doesn’t have meta-level startups such as some of the big names like Google, Facebook, and Twitter. Indian startups are also known for replicating global startups, rather than creating their own startup models.

Among the most innovative Indian startups would be startups like ChaiPoint, Ola, Saathi, and Swiggy, according to a list of 50 most innovative companies in the world.

Fear of Startup Failure

While this fear lives in almost every entrepreneur, some tend to simply stop taking risks. Decision-making is hindered as the key goal becomes to not make even one wrong decision at any costs, thus limiting the startup’s gamut. Such fear can not only restrain but also motivate entrepreneurs when directed in a positive way. Having a negative approach from the start can influence thoughts and behaviour badly.

Poorly Harmonised Team

Any well-to-do startup requires a wide range of expertise in its team of employees and management. It is not hard to find technically proficient people these days. However, it is very difficult to find people who know how to get along with others and can be counted on when managers are not looking over their shoulders. Skills and work approach of the founder and his/her team should complement each other efficiently. Working for a startup can create a sort of pressure for the employees too, but as a founder you need to maintain quality communication with them and exchange thoughts eagerly.

Management Notes

Some important provisions of Banking Regulation Act of 1949

indiafreenotesby indiafreenotes2

Different types of banks, such as commercial banks, cooperative banks, rural banks, and private sector banks exist in India. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is the governing body for regulating and supervising the banks. Banking Regulation Act, 1949 is an Act that provides a framework for regulating the banks of India. The Act came into force on 16th March 1949. This Act gives RBI the power to control the behaviour of banks. This Act was passed as Banking Companies Act, 1949. It did not apply to Jammu and Kashmir until 1956. This Act monitors the day-to-day operations of the bank. Under this Act, the RBI can licence banks, put ​​regulation over shareholding and voting rights of shareholders, look over the appointment of the boards and management, and lay down the instructions for audits. RBI also plays a role in mergers and liquidation.

Objectives of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949

  • To meet the demand of the depositors and provide them security and guarantee.
  • To provide provisions that can regulate the business of banking.
  • To regulate the opening of branches and changing of locations of existing branches.
  • To prescribe minimum requirements for the capital of banks.
  • To balance the development of banking institutions.

Provisons

  1. Prohibition of Trading (Sec. 8):

According to Sec. 8 of the Banking Regulation Act, a banking company cannot directly or indirectly deal in buying or selling or bartering of goods. But it may, however, buy, sell or barter the transactions relating to bills of exchange received for collection or negotiation.

  1. Non-Banking Assets (Sec. 9):

According to Sec. 9 “A banking company cannot hold any immovable property, howsoever acquired, except for its own use, for any period exceeding seven years from the date of acquisition thereof. The company is permitted, within the period of seven years, to deal or trade in any such property for facilitating its disposal”. Of course, the Reserve Bank of India may, in the interest of depositors, extend the period of seven years by any period not exceeding five years.

  1. Management (Sec. 10):

Sec. 10 (a) states that not less than 51% of the total number of members of the Board of Directors of a banking company shall consist of persons who have special knowledge or practical experience in one or more of the following fields:

(a) Accountancy;

(b) Agriculture and Rural Economy;

(c) Banking;

(d) Cooperative;

(e) Economics;

(f) Finance;

(g) Law;

(h) Small Scale Industry.

The Section also states that at least not less than two directors should have special knowledge or practical experience relating to agriculture and rural economy and cooperative. Sec. 10(b) (1) further states that every banking company shall have one of its directors as Chairman of its Board of Directors.

  1. Minimum Capital and Reserves (Sec. 11):

Sec. 11 (2) of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, provides that no banking company shall commence or carry on business in India, unless it has minimum paid-up capital and reserve of such aggregate value as is noted below:

(a) Foreign Banking Companies:

In case of banking company incorporated outside India, aggregate value of its paid-up capital and reserve shall not be less than Rs. 15 lakhs and, if it has a place of business in Mumbai or Kolkata or in both, Rs. 20 lakhs.

It must deposit and keep with the R.B.I, either in Cash or in unencumbered approved securities:

(i) The amount as required above, and

(ii) After the expiry of each calendar year, an amount equal to 20% of its profits for the year in respect of its Indian business.

(b) Indian Banking Companies:

In case of an Indian banking company, the sum of its paid-up capital and reserves shall not be less than the amount stated below:

(i) If it has places of business in more than one State, Rs. 5 lakhs, and if any such place of business is in Mumbai or Kolkata or in both, Rs. 10 lakhs.

(ii) If it has all its places of business in one State, none of which is in Mumbai or Kolkata, Rs. 1 lakh in respect of its principal place of business plus Rs. 10,000 in respect of each of its other places of business in the same district in which it has its principal place of business, plus Rs. 25,000 in respect of each place of business elsewhere in the State.

No such banking company shall be required to have paid-up capital and reserves exceeding Rs. 5 lakhs and no such banking company which has only one place of business shall be required to have paid- up capital and reserves exceeding Rs. 50,000.

In case of any such banking company which commences business for the first time after 16th September 1962, the amount of its paid-up capital shall not be less than Rs. 5 lakhs.

(iii) If it has all its places of business in one State, one or more of which are in Mumbai or Kolkata, Rs. 5 lakhs plus Rs. 25,000 in respect of each place of business outside Mumbai or Kolkata? No such banking company shall be required to have paid-up capital and reserve excluding Rs. 10 lakhs.

  1. Capital Structure (Sec. 12):

According to Sec. 12, no banking company can carry on business in India, unless it satisfies the following conditions:

(a) Its subscribed capital is not less than half of its authorized capital, and its paid-up capital is not less than half of its subscribed capital.

(b) Its capital consists of ordinary shares only or ordinary or equity shares and such preference shares as may have been issued prior to 1st April 1944. This restriction does not apply to a banking company incorporated before 15th January 1937.

(c) The voting right of any shareholder shall not exceed 5% of the total voting right of all the shareholders of the company.

  1. Payment of Commission, Brokerage etc. (Sec. 13):

According to Sec. 13, a banking company is not permitted to pay directly or indirectly by way of commission, brokerage, discount or remuneration on issues of its shares in excess of 2½% of the paid-up value of such shares.

  1. Payment of Dividend (Sec. 15):

According to Sec. 15, no banking company shall pay any dividend on its shares until all its capital expenses (including preliminary expenses, organisation expenses, share selling commission, brokerage, amount of losses incurred and other items of expenditure not represented by tangible assets) have been completely written-off.

But Banking Company need not:

(a) Write-off depreciation in the value of its investments in approved securities in any case where such depreciation has not actually been capitalized or otherwise accounted for as a loss;

(b) Write-off depreciation in the value of its investments in shares, debentures or bonds (other than approved securities) in any case where adequate provision for such depreciation has been made to the satisfaction of the auditor;

(c) Write-off bad debts in any case where adequate provision for such debts has been made to the satisfaction of the auditors of the banking company.

Floating Charges:

A floating charge on the undertaking or any property of a banking company can be created only if RBI certifies in writing that it is not detrimental to the interest of depositors Sec. 14A. Similarly, any charge created by a banking company on unpaid capital is invalid Sec. 14.

  1. Reserve Fund/Statutory Reserve (Sec. 17):

According to Sec. 17, every banking company incorporated in India shall, before declaring a dividend, transfer a sum equal to 20% of the net profits of each year (as disclosed by its Profit and Loss Account) to a Reserve Fund.

The Central Government may, however, on the recommendation of RBI, exempt it from this requirement for a specified period. The exemption is granted if its existing reserve fund together with Securities Premium Account is not less than its paid-up capital.

If it appropriates any sum from the reserve fund or the securities premium account, it shall, within 21 days from the date of such appropriation, report the fact to the Reserve Bank, explaining the circumstances relating to such appropriation. Moreover, banks are required to transfer 20% of the Net Profit to Statutory Reserve.

  1. Cash Reserve (Sec. 18):

Under Sec. 18, every banking company (not being a Scheduled Bank) shall, if Indian, maintain in India, by way of a cash reserve in Cash, with itself or in current account with the Reserve Bank or the State Bank of India or any other bank notified by the Central Government in this behalf, a sum equal to at least 3% of its time and demand liabilities in India.

The Reserve Bank has the power to regulate the percentage also between 3% and 15% (in case of Scheduled Banks). Besides the above, they are to maintain a minimum of 25% of its total time and demand liabilities in cash, gold or unencumbered approved securities. But every banking company’s asset in India should not be less than 75% of its time and demand liabilities in India at the close of last Friday of every quarter.

  1. Liquidity Norms or Statutory Liquidity Ratio (SLR) (Sec. 24):

According to Sec. 24 of the Act, in addition to maintaining CRR, banking companies must maintain sufficient liquid assets in the normal course of business. The section states that every banking company has to maintain in cash, gold or unencumbered approved securities, an amount not less than 25% of its demand and time liabilities in India.

This percentage may be changed by the RBI from time to time according to economic circumstances of the country. This is in addition to the average daily balance maintained by a bank.

Again, as per Sec. 24 of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, every scheduled bank has to maintain 31.5% on domestic liabilities up to the level outstanding on 30.9.1994 and 25% on any increase in such liabilities over and above the said level as on the said date.

But w.e.f. 26.4.1997 fortnight the maintenance of SLR for inter-bank liabilities was exempted. It must be remembered that at the start of the preceding fortnights, SLR must be maintained for outstanding liabilities.

  1. Restrictions on Loans and Advances (Sec. 20):

After the Amendment of the Act in 1968, a bank cannot:

(i) Grant loans or advances on the security of its own shares, and

(ii) Grant or agree to grant a loan or advance to or on behalf of:

(a) Any of its directors;

(b) Any firm in which any of its directors is interested as partner, manager or guarantor;

(c) Any company of which any of its directors is a director, manager, employee or guarantor, or in which he holds substantial interest; or

(d) Any individual in respect of whom any of its directors is a partner or guarantor.

Note:

(ii) (c) Does not apply to subsidiaries of the banking company, registered under Sec. 25 of the Companies Act or a Government Company.

  1. Accounts and Audit (Sees. 29 to 34A):

The above Sections of the Banking Regulation Act deal with the accounts and audit. Every banking company, incorporated in India, at the end of a financial year expiring after a period of 12 months as the Central Government may by notification in the Official Gazette specify, must prepare a Balance Sheet and a Profit and Loss Account as on the last working day of that year, or, according to the Third Schedule, or, as circumstances permit.

At the same time, every banking company, which is incorporated outside India, is required to prepare a Balance Sheet and also a Profit and Loss Account relating to its branch in India also. We know that Form A of the Third Schedule deals with form of Balance Sheet and Form B of the Third Schedule deals with form of Profit and Loss Account.

It is interesting to note that a revised set of forms have been prescribed for Balance Sheet and Profit and Loss Account of the banking company and RBI has also issued guidelines to follow the revised forms with effect from 31st March 1992.

According to Sec. 30 of the Banking Regulation Act, the Balance Sheet and Profit and Loss Account should be prepared according to Sec. 29, and the same must be audited by a qualified person known as auditor. Every banking company must take previous permission from RBI before appointing, re­appointing or removing any auditor. RBI can also order special audit for public interest of depositors.

Moreover, every banking company must furnish their copies of accounts and Balance Sheet prepared according to Sec. 29 along with the auditor’s report to the RBI and also the Registers of companies within three months from the end of the accounting period.

Management Notes

Types of Business Law

indiafreenotesby indiafreenotes0

Tax Law

In terms of business law, taxation refers to taxes charged upon companies in the commercial sector. It is the obligation of all companies (except a few tax-exempted small-time companies) to pay their taxes on time, failure to follow through which will be a violation of corporate tax laws.

Securities Law

Securities refer to assets like shares in the stock market and other sources of capital growth and accumulation. Securities law prohibits businesspersons from conducting fraudulent activities from taking place in the securities market. This is the business law section which penalises securities fraud, such as insider trading. It is, thus, also called Capital Markets Law.

Intellectual property Tax

Intellectual property refers to the intangible products of the working of the human mind or intellect, which are under the sole ownership of a single entity, such as an individual or company. The validation of this ownership is provided by intellectual property law, which incorporates trademarks, patents, trade secrets and copyrights.

Contract Law

A contract is any document which creates a sort of legal obligation between the parties that sign it. Contracts refer to those employee contracts, sale of goods contracts, lease contracts, etc.

Companies Act,2013

With an unprecedented change in the domestic and international economic landscape, India’s Government decided to replace the Companies Act, 1956, with the new legislation. The Companies Act, 2013, endeavors to make the corporate regulations in India more contemporary. In this article, we will focus on the meaning and features of a Company.

The Companies Act, 2013, completely revolutionized India’s corporate laws by introducing several new concepts that did not exist previously. One such game-changer was the introduction of the One Person Company concept. This led to the recognition of an entirely new way of starting businesses that accorded flexibility which a company form of entity can offer, while also providing the protection of limited liability that sole proprietorship or partnerships lacked.

Thus, as we can see, commercial contracts are a very essential part of the business world. Any business during its operation needs to follow all these laws, whether willfully or not. Thus, a person with any venture needs very substantial legal assistance so that any clash in legal matters won’t harm your endeavors.

The Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008

LLP stands for a Limited Liability Partnership. Limited liability partnership definition is an alternative corporate business form that offers the benefits of limited liability to the partners at low compliance costs. It also allows the partners to organize their internal structure like a traditional partnership. A limited liability partnership is a legal body liable for the full extent of its assets. The liability of the partners, however, is limited. Hence, LLP is a hybrid between a company and a partnership. It is not the same as a limited liability company LLC.

The Indian Partnership Act,1932

The Indian Partnership Act 1932 defines a partnership as a relation between two or more parties to agree to share a business’s profits, either all or only one or more persons acting for them all. A partnership is contractual in nature. As the definition states, a partnership is an association of two or more persons. So a partnership results from a contract or an agreement between two or more persons. A partnership does not arise from the operation of law. Neither can it be inherited. It has to be a voluntary agreement between partners. A partnership agreement can be written or oral. Sometimes such an arrangement is even implied by the continued actions and mutual understanding of the partners.

The Sale of Goods Act,1930

Contracts and agreements regarding the sale of goods and services are governed under the Sale of Goods ACT, 1930. The sale of commodities constitutes one of the essential types of contracts under the law in India. India is one of the largest economies and a great country where and thus has adequate checks and measures to ensure its business and commerce community’s safety and prosperity. Here we shall explain The Sale of Goods Act, 1930, which defines and states terms related to the sale of goods and exchange of commodities.

The Indian Contract Act, 1872

It is the most prominent business law to exist in our country. It came into effect on 1st September 1872 and applied to the whole of India, with the exception of Jammu and Kashmir. It constitutes 266 sections. The Indian Contracts Act,1872 defines the essentials through various judgments in the Indian judiciary. Specific points for valid contracts are Free consent, consideration, competency, eligibility, etc. A valid contract must include at least two parties, or it will be deemed as null and void.

Management Notes

Resolutions, Meaning and Types, Registration of resolutions

indiafreenotesby indiafreenotes0

Resolutions in corporate meetings are formal decisions passed by a company’s board of directors or shareholders. They are legally binding and serve as documented evidence of the company’s decisions regarding its governance, operations, or strategic plans. Resolutions are integral to corporate decision-making and are required for actions that need the approval of shareholders, directors, or other stakeholders. These resolutions ensure compliance with laws, transparency, and accountability.

Types of Corporate Resolutions:

  • Ordinary Resolution

Ordinary resolution is the most common type of resolution passed at a company’s general meeting. It requires a simple majority—that is, more than 50% of the votes cast by members present and entitled to vote—for approval. Ordinary resolutions cover routine business decisions such as approving annual financial statements, declaring dividends, appointing or reappointing directors and auditors, and approving the remuneration of directors. These resolutions are generally straightforward and do not require special notice. Once passed, they become legally binding and enable the company to carry out ordinary business activities. Ordinary resolutions promote democratic decision-making by reflecting the majority opinion of shareholders on regular company affairs.

  • Special Resolution

Special resolution requires a higher level of approval—typically at least 75% of the votes cast—to pass. This type of resolution is necessary for major decisions that affect the company’s structure or fundamental policies. Examples include altering the company’s Articles of Association, changing the company’s name, reducing share capital, approving mergers or acquisitions, or winding up the company voluntarily. Special resolutions usually require prior notice to members, often specifying the intention to propose such a resolution. The higher voting threshold protects minority shareholders by ensuring that significant changes cannot be made without broad consensus, safeguarding their interests and ensuring corporate stability.

  • Board Resolution

Board resolution is passed during meetings of the company’s Board of Directors. It authorizes decisions related to the management and day-to-day operations of the company. Common examples include approving contracts, opening bank accounts, appointing officers or key executives, authorizing borrowing, or implementing company policies. Board resolutions typically require a majority of directors present and voting to pass. These resolutions enable the board to act collectively and officially document their decisions. Board resolutions are essential for maintaining proper governance and ensuring that managerial actions are authorized and legally valid, providing clarity and accountability in corporate management.

  • Unanimous Resolution

Unanimous resolution is one agreed upon by all members entitled to vote without any opposition. It is often used in small or closely held companies where all shareholders must consent to decisions, ensuring total agreement. Unanimous resolutions may be passed outside formal meetings, via written consent, and are legally binding. This type of resolution is important when the company wants to take swift decisions without convening a meeting, or when unanimity is required by the company’s governing documents for certain actions. Unanimous resolutions provide certainty and prevent disputes by reflecting the collective agreement of all shareholders.

Registration of Resolutions:

Registration of resolutions refers to the formal process of recording and filing the decisions made by the company’s general meetings or board meetings with appropriate governmental or regulatory bodies, such as the Registrar of Companies (RoC) in India. This process involves preparing official documents that detail the resolution, getting them signed and certified, and submitting them within prescribed timelines.

The registration serves multiple purposes:

  • It makes the resolution legally binding.
  • It ensures transparency and public disclosure.
  • It protects the company and its members by providing a formal record.
  • It facilitates regulatory oversight to prevent fraud or misuse of corporate powers.

Types of Resolutions Subject to Registration

Not all resolutions require registration. Generally, special resolutions and some ordinary resolutions that affect the company’s constitution or statutory compliance must be registered. Examples include:

  • Amendments to the Memorandum of Association (MoA) or Articles of Association (AoA)
  • Changes in the company’s name
  • Increase or reduction of share capital
  • Approval of mergers, demergers, or acquisitions
  • Voluntary winding up of the company
  • Appointment or removal of auditors in some jurisdictions

Ordinary business resolutions like approval of annual financial statements or appointment of directors typically do not require registration, though they must be recorded in the company’s minutes.

Process of Registration:

The registration process typically involves the following steps:

  • Passing the Resolution: The resolution must be passed in a validly convened meeting with the required quorum and voting majority.

  • Recording Minutes: The company secretary or authorized person records the minutes, including the text of the resolution.

  • Certification: The resolution and minutes are signed and certified by the chairman or company secretary.

  • Preparation of Filing Documents: The company prepares the required forms and attaches certified copies of the resolution and any supporting documents.

  • Submission to Registrar: The forms and documents are submitted electronically or physically to the Registrar of Companies or relevant authority within the prescribed time.

  • Acknowledgment and Registration: Upon acceptance, the Registrar registers the resolution and issues an acknowledgment or certificate.

Importance of Registration:

Registration of resolutions is crucial for multiple reasons:

  • Legal Validity: Registered resolutions are legally enforceable. Unregistered resolutions may be challenged in court, potentially invalidating company decisions.

  • Public Record: Registration ensures that key decisions are part of the public record, allowing shareholders, creditors, and other stakeholders to access them. This transparency builds trust and accountability.

  • Compliance and Governance: Proper registration demonstrates compliance with statutory requirements, reducing the risk of penalties and enhancing corporate governance.

  • Facilitates Future Transactions: Registered resolutions often form the basis for legal actions like share transfers, borrowing, or contracts with third parties.

Drafting and Passing Resolutions:

Corporate resolutions must be clearly worded and include:

  • The title indicating the type of resolution.
  • A statement of purpose or intent.
  • The details of the decision being approved.
  • The names of members/directors involved in the voting process.

Resolutions are passed through voting mechanisms, such as:

  • Show of Hands: Common for ordinary resolutions.
  • Poll: Ensures weighted voting based on shareholding.
  • Postal Ballot/Electronic Voting: Used for decisions requiring broader shareholder involvement.
Management Notes

Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016

indiafreenotesby indiafreenotes0

The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), 2016 is a comprehensive law introduced in India to address issues of insolvency and bankruptcy in a time-bound and efficient manner. Prior to the IBC, India lacked a uniform legal framework to address corporate insolvency, leading to delayed and often ineffective resolutions. The IBC aims to provide a structured process for resolving corporate insolvency, improving the ease of doing business, and enhancing the credit culture in India.

Background and Objectives:

The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) was enacted in 2016 to consolidate and amend the existing laws relating to insolvency and bankruptcy. It aims to:

  • Provide a time-bound process for resolving insolvency of individuals and businesses.
  • Improve the overall business environment by addressing issues such as non-performing assets (NPAs) and corporate debt.
  • Promote entrepreneurship by offering a clean slate to viable businesses that face insolvency.
  • Protect the interests of creditors and other stakeholders while providing an opportunity for companies in distress to restructure.

The IBC combines various laws and procedures related to insolvency and bankruptcy into one comprehensive code. It also introduces mechanisms for resolving insolvency both for individuals and corporate entities, ensuring transparency, accountability, and fairness in the process.

Features of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016:

  1. Insolvency Resolution Process: The IBC sets out a clear, standardized process for insolvency resolution. It is divided into three primary parts:
    • Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP): A process for resolving insolvency of companies and limited liability partnerships (LLPs). The process is initiated by creditors, who can file a petition with the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT).
    • Individual Insolvency Resolution Process (IIRP): For individuals and partnership firms, the IBC provides a process to address insolvency situations.
    • Liquidation: In cases where a resolution plan fails, the company may undergo liquidation, where its assets are sold to settle outstanding debts.
  2. Time-Bound Process: The IBC mandates that the insolvency process be completed within 180 days (extendable by another 90 days). This is to ensure that resolution or liquidation occurs without unnecessary delays. The time-bound nature of the process is crucial in preserving the value of distressed assets and ensuring a quicker recovery for creditors.
  3. Resolution Professional: During the insolvency resolution process, an external expert known as a “Resolution Professional” is appointed. The Resolution Professional manages the affairs of the company and works with creditors and other stakeholders to come up with a resolution plan that maximizes the recovery value of the company. The professional is responsible for overseeing the process and ensuring that the interests of all parties are protected.
  4. Committee of Creditors (CoC): The IBC establishes a Committee of Creditors, composed of financial creditors, which has the power to approve or reject resolution plans. The CoC plays a central role in the insolvency process, and their decision is binding on the debtor company. The committee also oversees the role of the Resolution Professional.
  5. Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI): The IBBI is the regulatory authority responsible for overseeing the functioning of the insolvency and bankruptcy framework. It is tasked with laying down the regulations and ensuring that professionals involved in the process, including Resolution Professionals and Insolvency Professionals, adhere to the standards set by the law.
  6. Creditor’s Hierarchy and Recovery Process: The IBC provides a clear hierarchy of creditors during the resolution process. Secured creditors (such as banks) are given priority, followed by unsecured creditors. Shareholders, however, are the last in line when it comes to recovery. This ensures that creditors’ interests are prioritized in the distribution of proceeds from asset sales.
  7. Adjudicating Authorities: The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) and the Debt Recovery Tribunal (DRT) are the primary adjudicating authorities under the IBC. The NCLT resolves disputes related to the corporate insolvency process, while the DRT is responsible for individual insolvency matters. Appeals can be filed with the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) and the Appellate Tribunal for Debt Recovery.
  8. Cross-Border Insolvency: The IBC allows for cooperation between Indian courts and foreign courts in cases involving cross-border insolvencies. This ensures that assets held by an Indian company abroad or foreign creditors can participate in the insolvency proceedings. This provision helps multinational companies and foreign creditors resolve insolvency issues efficiently.

Advantages of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code:

  • Faster Resolution:

IBC ensures quicker resolution of insolvency cases compared to earlier methods. With a fixed timeline, the process helps to minimize delays.

  • Improved Credit Market:

IBC has led to a cleaner and more transparent credit market by providing a legal framework that ensures quicker recovery of debts and reducing defaults.

  • Higher Recovery Rate:

Creditors can expect a higher recovery rate compared to the earlier approach, where a significant portion of their debt went unpaid due to prolonged legal battles.

  • Reduction in Non-Performing Assets (NPAs):

The introduction of IBC has contributed to the reduction of NPAs in the banking sector, improving the financial health of banks and financial institutions.

  • Promotes Entrepreneurship:

By offering a mechanism for revival, the IBC allows businesses to restructure their operations rather than be forced into liquidation. This encourages entrepreneurship and reduces the fear of failure.

Management Notes

Consequences of Winding up

indiafreenotesby indiafreenotes3

The term “consequences of winding up” refers to the legal and practical effects that arise once a company enters into the process of winding up, either voluntarily or through an order by the Tribunal. It signifies the formal beginning of the end of a company’s existence and impacts all aspects of its operations, structure, and responsibilities.

When a company is under winding up, it is no longer permitted to carry out business activities except those necessary for the closure process. The company’s directors lose their executive powers, which are then transferred to a liquidator appointed to manage the liquidation. This person takes over the assets, settles liabilities, and ensures fair distribution of any remaining funds to shareholders.

Another key consequence is that all ongoing or new legal proceedings against the company are paused or require prior approval from the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT). The company is subject to close regulatory oversight to ensure that creditors, employees, and shareholders are treated equitably.

Once all obligations are resolved, the company is dissolved and removed from the Register of Companies. From that point, the company ceases to be a legal entity, and all corporate existence ends. The consequences ensure an orderly, lawful closure of business.

  • Dissolution of the Company

The most significant consequence of winding up is the dissolution of the company. Once the company has completed the liquidation process and all legal requirements are met, it ceases to exist as a legal entity. The company’s name is struck off the register of companies by the Registrar of Companies (RoC), and it no longer holds any legal rights or obligations.

  • Termination of Business Operations

Winding up means the termination of the company’s business activities. It can no longer carry on any of the operations it previously undertook. The focus shifts from day-to-day business to liquidating assets and resolving outstanding liabilities. All contracts and dealings are brought to an end, although some may continue temporarily for the purpose of liquidation.

  • Liquidation of Assets

During winding up, the company’s assets are sold off, and the proceeds are used to settle its debts. The liquidator is responsible for identifying and valuing the company’s assets, including property, inventory, and receivables. The funds are then distributed to creditors, and any remaining surplus is given to shareholders.

  • Settlement of Liabilities

One of the primary objectives of the winding-up process is to settle the company’s debts. The company must fulfill its obligations to creditors, which may include banks, suppliers, employees, and other stakeholders. If the company’s assets are insufficient to cover its debts, creditors may only receive a partial payment.

  • Impact on Shareholders

Once the liabilities are settled, the remaining funds (if any) are distributed among the shareholders. However, in the case of insolvency, shareholders often do not receive anything. Shareholders risk losing their investments, especially when the company’s liabilities exceed its assets.

  • Disqualification of Directors

The directors of the company may face disqualification from holding future directorships in other companies, particularly if the winding up is due to misconduct, fraud, or negligence. They may also be held personally liable if it is found that they acted improperly during the company’s operations.

  • Termination of Employee Contracts

The winding-up process leads to the termination of employee contracts, unless otherwise determined by the liquidator. Employees may receive severance pay or unpaid wages as part of the liquidation process, but their claims rank lower than those of secured creditors. In some cases, employees may not receive the full amount owed to them if the company lacks sufficient assets.

  • Legal Proceedings Cease

Once winding up begins, legal proceedings against the company are generally halted, except in cases of fraud or other exceptional circumstances. The liquidator takes over the role of defending the company in ongoing legal matters, and any legal actions for debt recovery are channeled through the liquidation process.

Management Notes

Preparation of Minutes of Meeting

indiafreenotesby indiafreenotes2

The minutes of a meeting are the official written record of the discussions, decisions, and actions taken during a formal meeting. They provide a comprehensive account of the key points deliberated and serve as a reference for participants and stakeholders. Properly documented minutes are vital for legal compliance, organizational transparency, and tracking progress.

Purpose of Minutes of Meeting:

  1. Documentation: Minutes capture the essence of the meeting, including the agenda, discussions, and resolutions.
  2. Accountability: They ensure that responsibilities assigned during the meeting are tracked and executed.
  3. Reference: They act as an official record for reviewing past decisions and actions.
  4. Legal Compliance: For corporate meetings, such as board or shareholder meetings, minutes are a legal requirement under company law.

Structure of Minutes

  1. Header: Includes the meeting title, date, time, venue, and type (e.g., board meeting, annual general meeting).
  2. Attendance: Lists the names of participants, including those present, absent, or excused.
  3. Agenda Items: Summarizes the topics discussed during the meeting.
  4. Discussion Points: Provides a brief overview of key points raised by participants.
  5. Decisions Made: Records resolutions, approvals, or actions agreed upon.
  6. Action Items: Details the tasks assigned, responsible persons, and deadlines.
  7. Conclusion: Notes the meeting’s end time and the date of the next meeting, if applicable.

Steps to Write Effective Minutes:

  1. Prepare Before the Meeting: Familiarize yourself with the agenda and distribute it to attendees in advance.
  2. Record Key Points: Focus on capturing essential details like decisions, action points, and deadlines. Avoid unnecessary commentary.
  3. Use Clear Language: Write in a concise, formal, and neutral tone to ensure clarity.
  4. Organize Chronologically: Follow the sequence of the agenda items discussed.
  5. Review for Accuracy: Cross-check with meeting participants or the chairperson to confirm the accuracy of the notes.

Benefits of Maintaining Minutes:

  1. Transparency: Minutes foster an environment of openness and accountability in decision-making.
  2. Continuity: They provide continuity for participants who may not have attended the meeting, keeping them informed.
  3. Dispute Resolution: Official records can clarify misunderstandings or resolve disputes.
  4. Audit Trail: They serve as evidence for audits, legal matters, or regulatory inspections.

Best Practices

  1. Use Templates: Employ a consistent format or template for uniformity.
  2. Timely Circulation: Share minutes promptly to ensure tasks are started on time.
  3. Digital Archiving: Store minutes electronically for easy retrieval and backup.
Management Notes

International Trade Laws Objectives Set 2

indiafreenotesby indiafreenotes3
  1. The exchange of goods and services are known as …………………………
  • Domestic Trade
  • International Trade
  • Trade
  • None of these.

 

  1. Which of the following is not considered as factors of production?
  • Land
  • Labour
  • Money
  • Capital

 

  1. Trade between two countries is known as ………….
  • External
  • Internal
  • Inter-regional
  • None of Above

 

  1. International Trade is most likely to generate short-term unemployment in:
  • Industries in which there are neither imports nor exports
  • Import-competing industries
  • Industries that sell to domestic and foreign buyers.
  • Industries that sell to only foreign buyers

 

  1. Free traders maintain that an open economy is advantageous in that it provides all the following except:
  • Increased competition for world producers
  • A wider selection of products for consumers
  • Relatively high wage levels for all domestic workers
  • The utilization of the most efficient production methods

 

  1. Which of the following is not a benefit of international trade?
  • Lower domestic prices
  • Development of more efficient methods and new products
  • A greater range of consumption choices
  • High wage levels for all domestic workers

 

  1. Which is not an advantage of international trade:
  • Export of surplus production
  • Import of defence material
  • Dependence on foreign countries
  • Availability of cheap raw material

 

  1. Trade between two countries can be useful if cost ratios of goods are …………..
  • Equal
  • Different
  • Undetermined
  • Decreasing

 

  1. Foreign trade creates among countries ………………
  • Conflicts
  • Cooperation
  • Hatred
  • Both a. and b.

 

  1. All are advantages of foreign trade except ………….
  • People get foreign exchange
  • Cheaper goods
  • Nations compete
  • Optimum utilization of countries’ resources

 

Q.2. Fill in the blanks.

  1. International Trade means trade between …………………. (Provinces/ Countries/ Regions)
  2. Two countries can give from foreign trade if ………… are different. (Effect/ Tariff/ Cost)
  3. ………….. encourages trade between two countries. (Different tax system/Reduced tariffs/ National currencies)
  4. Drawback of protection system is ……… (Consumers have to pay higher prices/ Producers get higher profits/ Quality of goods may be affected/ All above)
  5. ………….. is a drawback of free trade. (Prices of local goods rise/ Govt. looses incomes from custom duties/National resources are underutilized)
  6. International trade is possible primarily through specialization in production of …… goods. (All/ One/ Few)
  7. A country that does not trade with other countries is called …… country. (Developed/ Closed/ Independent)
  8. Policy of Protection in trade ……… (Facilitates trade/ Protects foreign producers/ Protects local producers/ Protects exporters)
  9. The largest item of Indian import list is ……….. (Consumer goods/ Machinery/ Petroleum/ Computers)
  10. Trade between two states in an economy is known as …… (External/ Internal/None)

 

SET 2

Q.1. Multiple Choice Questions.

  1. Who among the following enunciated the concept of single factoral terms of trade?
  • Jacob Viner
  • G.S.Donens
  • Taussig
  • J.S.Mill

 

  1. ‘Infant industry argument’ in international trade is given in support of:
  • Granting Protection
  • Free trade
  • Encouragement to export oriented small and tiny industries
  • None of the above

 

  1. Terms of trade that relate to the Real Ratio of international exchange between commodities is called:
  • Real cost terms of trade
  • Commodity terms of trade
  • Income terms of trade
  • Utility terms of trade

 

  1. The main advantage in specialization results from:
  • Economies of large-scale production
  • The specializing country behaving as monopoly.
  • Smaller Production runs resulting in lower unit costs.
  • High wages paid to foreign workers.

 

  1. Net export equals ……
  • Export * Import
  • Export + Import
  • Export – Import
  • Exports of service only

 

  1. A tariff ………………….
  • Increase the volume of trade
  • Reduces the volume of trade
  • Has no effect on volume of trade
  • Both a. and c.

 

7. Terms of Trade of developing countries are generally unfavourable because …….

  • They export primary goods
  • They import value added goods
  • They export few goods
  • Both a. and b.

 

  1. Terms of Trade a country show ……………
  • Ratio of goods exported and imported
  • Ratio of import duties
  • Ratio of prices of exports and imports
  • Both a. and c.

 

  1. Terms of trade between two countries refer to a ratio of …..
  • Export prices to import prices
  • Currency values
  • Export to import
  • Balance of trade to Balance of payments

 

10. Rich countries have deficit in their balance of payments ……..

  • Sometimes
  • Never
  • Alternate years
  • Always

 

Q.2. Fill in the blanks.

  1. BOP means balance of Receipts and payments of …… (all banks/ State bank/ Foreign exchange by a country/ Government)
  2. Favourable trade means exports are ……. than imports. (More/ Less/ Neutral)
  3. Net barter terms of trade is also known as …. Terms of trade.(Commodity/ Income/Utility)
  4. ….. is not a factor affecting TOT. (Reciprocal demand/ Size of demand/ Price of demand)
  5. If tariff is higher, then the imports will …… (Increase/ Decrease/ Same as before)
  6. ……. has given the concept of reciprocal demand. (Mills/ Adam/ Ricardo)
  7. ……… is the curve, which expresses the total demand for one good (imports) in terms of the total supply of another good (exports). (Offer/ Official / Corporate)
  8. Balance of payment is prepared by an economy ……. (Yearly/ Monthly/ Weekly)
  9. …….. kinds of accounts are included in BOP. (2/ 3/4)
  10. …….is not a type of disequilibrium in BOP. (Cyclical/ Seasonal/ Frictional/ Disguised)

 

SET 3

Q.1. Multiple Choice Questions.

  1. The first classical theory of International Trade is given by …………………..
  • Keynes
  • Adam Smith
  • Friedman
  • Heckscher-Ohlin

 

  1. In classical theory of International Trade, the exchange of goods and services takes on the basis of ………….. system?
  • Barter
  • Money
  • Labour
  • capital

 

  1. If capital is available in large proportion and labour is less, then that economy is known as ……………..
  • Capital Intensive
  • Labour Intensive
  • Both a. and b
  • None of above

 

  1. In Heckscher Ohlin theory, what is assumed to be same across the countries?
  • Transportation cost
  • Technology
  • Labour
  • capital

 

  1. Opportunity cost is also known as ……………………
  • Next Best alternative
  • Transformation cost
  • Both a. and b
  • None of above.

 

  1. Factor proportions theory is also known as the
  • comparative advantage theory
  • laissez faire theorem.
  • HeckscherOhlin theorem
  • product cycle model.

 

  1. Trade between two countries can be useful if cost ratios of goods are:
  • Equal
  • Different
  • Undetermined
  • Decreasing

 

  1. According to Hecksher and Ohlin basic cause of international trade is:
  • Difference in factor endowments
  • Difference in markets
  • Difference in political systems
  • Difference in ideology

 

  1. The theory explaining trade between two countries is called:
  • Comparative disadvantage theory
  • Comparative cost theory
  • Comparative trade theory
  • None of the above

 

  1. David Ricardo presented the theory of international trade called:
  • Theory of absolute advantage
  • Theory of comparative advantage
  • Theory of equal advantage.
  • Theory of total advantage

 

Q.2. True or False.

  1. Absolute advantage theory is given by Adam Smith.

True

  1. Ricardo has supplemented Absolute advantage theory.

 True

  1. Heckscher and Ohlin have given comparative cost advantage theory of International Trade.

False

  1. Multilateral trade means one country comes into trade with more than one country.

True

  1. Opportunity cost means unforgiving cost.

False

  1. Modern theory of International Trade is given by Ricardo.

False

  1. 2×2×2 model of International Trade is known by Heckscher Ohlin model.

True

  1. Transformation cost is also known as opportunity cost.

True

  1. Gravity model of trade was first used by Jan Tinbergen.

True

  1. Adam Smith advocated free trade and specialized.

True

 

Set 4

Multiple Choice Questions.

  1. GATT was made in the year ………………..
  • 1945
  • 1947
  • 1950
  • 1951

 

  1. The new world Trade organization WTO., which replaced the GATT came into effect from____
  • 1ST January 1991
  • 1st January 1995
  • 1st April 1994
  • 1st May 1995

 

  1. 5 banks of BRICS nations have agreed to establish credit lines in ….. currencies.
  • Legal
  • Plastic
  • Crypto currency
  • National

 

  1. Where was the 11th meeting of BRICS Trade Ministers held from 13 Nov 2019 – 14 Nov 2019?
  • Shanghai
  • Beijing
  • Tokyo
  • Brasilia

 

  1. What is the name of the SAARC satellite to be launched on May 5, 2017?
  • South Asia Satellite
  • South Asian Association Satellite
  • South East Asia satellite
  • SAARC satellite

 

  1. Full form of SAFTA is ……………………..
  • South Asia Free Trade Agreement
  • South Asia Foreign Trade Agreement
  • South Asia Framework Trade Agreement
  • Both a and b

6. Which of the following commitments has not been made by India to WTO?

  • Reduction in tariffs
  • Increase in quantitative restrictions
  • Increase in qualitative restrictions
  • Trade related Intellectual Property Rights

 

  1. The European Union was formally established on …..
  • November, 1993
  • April, 1995
  • January, 1997
  • May, 1996

 

8. SAARC was established in …..

  • 1980
  • 1985
  • 1990
  • 1995

 

  1. NAFTA came into effect in …..
  • 1990
  • 1994
  • 1998
  • 2004

10. The dominant member state of OPEC is ……………..

  • Iran
  • Iraq
  • Kuwait
  • Saudi Arabia

 

Q.2. Fill in the blanks.

  1. Headquarter of WTO is in ………….. Geneva/USA/Germany.
  2. Before WTO, ……………… was working instead of that. GATY/ GATR/ GATT.
  3. …………….. round negotiations initiated the establishment of WTO. Uruguay/ Urdun/ Urbuny .
  4. India had joined WTO in the year …………. (1995/ 1996/ 1997)
  5. In …………….. , SAARC was established. (1985/ 1986/ 1987)
  6. The first SAARC summit was organized at …….. (Dhaka/ Kathmandu/ Nepal)
  7. ……..is not a country in SAFTA. (India/ Nepal/ Pakistan/ USA)
  8. ……… countries are member of OECD. (34/ 35/ 36)
  9. ………… is not a country under OECD. (Norway/ Canada/ China)
  10. ………….. are the member states of European Union. (28/ 29/30)
Management Notes

Auditors, Meaning, Types, Appointment, Powers, Duties & Responsibilities, Qualities

indiafreenotesby indiafreenotes2

Auditor is an independent professional appointed to examine and verify the financial statements and records of a company, ensuring their accuracy, legality, and compliance with applicable accounting standards and laws. Under Section 2(7) of the Companies Act, 2013, an auditor is a person appointed to audit the financial records of a company and express an opinion on the fairness of its financial position.

The main role of an auditor is to conduct an audit, which is a systematic examination of financial books, vouchers, and documents. The purpose is to provide a true and fair view of the company’s financial health, detect fraud or errors, and ensure compliance with the provisions of the Companies Act and accounting standards prescribed by ICAI (Institute of Chartered Accountants of India).

The Companies Act mandates that every company, except certain small and one person companies, must appoint an auditor in its first Annual General Meeting (AGM), who will hold office for five years, subject to ratification by shareholders. The appointment, qualifications, powers, and duties of auditors are governed by Sections 139 to 148 of the Companies Act, 2013.

Auditors play a critical role in corporate governance by safeguarding stakeholder interests, building investor confidence, and promoting transparency and accountability in financial reporting.

Types of Auditors:

Auditors are appointed to ensure financial accuracy, legal compliance, and corporate transparency. Depending on their scope of work and legal status, auditors are categorized into various types. Each plays a unique role in maintaining the integrity of financial reporting and ensuring that companies comply with statutory requirements.

1. Statutory Auditor

Statutory Auditor is appointed under the Companies Act, 2013, to audit the financial statements of a company annually. The appointment is compulsory for most companies except certain small or one person companies. Their audit report is presented in the Annual General Meeting (AGM). They ensure compliance with legal, tax, and accounting regulations, and are typically Chartered Accountants. The report provided by them holds legal importance and is submitted to the Registrar of Companies (ROC).

2. Internal Auditor

Internal Auditor is appointed by the management to evaluate the effectiveness of internal controls, risk management, and governance processes. Their role is not mandatory for all companies but is required for specified classes under Section 138 of the Companies Act, 2013. They function as part of the internal management team and report findings to the Board. Internal auditors are instrumental in improving operational efficiency and preventing fraud within the organization.

3. Cost Auditor

Cost Auditor examines the cost accounting records of a company to ensure that cost control, pricing, and efficiency measures are being properly documented. As per Section 148 of the Companies Act, 2013, companies engaged in manufacturing or production may be required to appoint cost auditors. They ensure that the company adheres to the Cost Accounting Standards issued by the Institute of Cost Accountants of India and submit a cost audit report to the Board and government.

4. Tax Auditor

Tax Auditor conducts audits as mandated under the Income Tax Act, 1961, specifically under Section 44AB. Their main function is to verify that the company complies with applicable tax laws and properly maintains tax-related financial records. Tax auditors prepare the Tax Audit Report (Form 3CA/3CB & 3CD) and help detect misreporting or tax evasion. They ensure proper deductions, declarations, and filings, and are usually Chartered Accountants in practice.

5. Secretarial Auditor

Secretarial Auditor is appointed under Section 204 of the Companies Act, 2013, and is mandatory for listed companies and certain other prescribed companies. They must be a Practicing Company Secretary (PCS). Their role is to examine whether the company complies with legal and procedural aspects of laws like SEBI regulations, the Companies Act, FEMA, and other corporate laws. They issue a Secretarial Audit Report, which forms part of the annual board report.

6. Government Auditor

Government Auditors are appointed by government agencies like the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) of India to audit public sector undertakings (PSUs) and government organizations. Their role is to ensure that public funds are used efficiently and in accordance with applicable financial rules. They detect misuse, non-compliance, or inefficiency in public expenditure. Their audits help Parliament and state legislatures hold government entities accountable.

7. Forensic Auditor

Forensic Auditor specializes in identifying fraud, embezzlement, and financial misconduct within an organization. They investigate suspicious transactions, misstatements, or internal manipulation of accounts. Their reports may be used as legal evidence in courts or regulatory inquiries. Forensic audits are conducted in response to specific concerns rather than as part of regular financial reviews, and these auditors are trained in investigative and analytical skills.

8. Concurrent Auditor

Concurrent Auditor conducts audits on a real-time or near real-time basis, especially in banks and financial institutions. Unlike statutory audits which are annual, concurrent audits are ongoing and help detect irregularities as they occur. They review transactions like loans, deposits, and investments to ensure adherence to internal guidelines, RBI norms, and KYC requirements. Concurrent audits strengthen the internal check system and reduce operational risks.

Appointment of Auditors:

The appointment of auditors is a statutory requirement under the Companies Act, 2013, primarily governed by Sections 139 to 148. The auditor plays a vital role in verifying financial accuracy, ensuring compliance, and maintaining transparency. The Act outlines different procedures for the appointment of first auditors, subsequent auditors, and auditors in government companies.

1. Appointment of First Auditor (Section 139(6))

  • In the case of a company (other than a government company), the Board of Directors must appoint the first auditor within 30 days of incorporation.
  • If the Board fails to do so, the company’s members must appoint the auditor within 90 days at an Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM).
  • The first auditor holds office until the conclusion of the first Annual General Meeting (AGM).
  • For government companies, the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) of India appoints the auditor within 60 days from incorporation. If CAG fails, the Board or shareholders will appoint.

2. Appointment of Subsequent Auditors (Section 139(1))

At the first AGM, shareholders must appoint an auditor who will hold office for five years (subject to ratification, if required, at each AGM).

This applies to all companies except:

  • One Person Companies (OPCs)
  • Small companies

The appointment must be confirmed by passing an ordinary resolution in the AGM.

The company must also file Form ADT-1 with the Registrar of Companies (ROC) within 15 days of the appointment.

3. Appointment in Government Companies (Section 139(5))

  • In the case of a government company, or a company with at least 51% paid-up share capital held by the government, the CAG of India appoints the auditor.
  • This appointment must be made within 180 days from the beginning of the financial year.
  • The appointed auditor will hold office until the conclusion of the AGM.

4. Rotation of Auditors (Section 139(2))

Certain companies (listed and prescribed unlisted public companies) must rotate auditors after a specified term:

  • An individual can be appointed as auditor for one term of 5 years.
  • An audit firm can serve two consecutive terms of 5 years each.
  • After completing the term, a cooling-off period of 5 years is mandatory before reappointment.
  • This provision aims to avoid long-term associations that may compromise auditor independence.

5. Consent and Certificate from Auditor (Section 139(1))

Before appointment, the proposed auditor must:

  • Provide written consent to act as an auditor.
  • Furnish a certificate of eligibility stating that the appointment, if made, will be within the limits prescribed under Section 141 of the Act.

The company must ensure that the auditor satisfies all conditions relating to disqualifications and independence.

6. Filing with ROC – Form ADT–1

  • Once the auditor is appointed, the company is required to file Form ADT-1 with the Registrar of Companies (ROC) within 15 days.
  • This form must be digitally signed and submitted online with the required fee.
  • Non-filing may attract penalties and non-compliance notices.

7. Reappointment of Auditor

A retiring auditor is eligible for reappointment at the AGM, unless:

  • They are disqualified.
  • They have expressed unwillingness.
  • A resolution has been passed for appointment of someone else.

If no auditor is appointed or reappointed at the AGM, the existing auditor continues to hold office until a new one is appointed.

8. Casual Vacancy in Office of Auditor (Section 139(8))

  • If a casual vacancy arises (due to resignation, death, disqualification), it must be filled by the Board of Directors within 30 days.

  • However, if the vacancy is due to resignation, it must be approved by the company at a general meeting within 3 months.

  • In the case of government companies, CAG fills the vacancy.

Powers of Auditors:

Auditors play a vital role in maintaining the financial integrity and transparency of companies. To perform their duties effectively, they are vested with various statutory powers under the Companies Act, 2013. These powers allow auditors to access information, seek clarifications, and report objectively to stakeholders.

The major powers of an auditor are primarily covered under Section 143 of the Companies Act, 2013.

1. Right to Access Books of Account (Section 143(1))

Auditors have the power to access all books of account, financial records, and vouchers of the company at all times, whether kept at the registered office or elsewhere. This includes:

  • Subsidiary company records (if auditing the holding company).
  • Records maintained electronically or physically.

Example: An auditor can demand access to ledger entries and bank reconciliations during an audit to verify cash flow.

2. Right to Obtain Information and Explanations (Section 143(1))

The auditor is entitled to seek any information or explanation from company officers that is necessary for performing the audit. It is the duty of the management to provide such information truthfully and promptly.

Example: If a transaction seems suspicious, the auditor can ask the finance officer for contract details or board approvals.

3. Right to Visit Branches (Section 143(8))

If a company has branches in India or abroad, the company’s main auditor can visit those branches to inspect records or may rely on branch auditors. However, they may also request the working papers or clarifications from the branch.

Example: For a retail chain with multiple branches, the auditor may check inventory and cash records at selected outlets.

4. Right to Audit Subsidiaries

If appointed as the auditor of a holding company, the auditor has the right to access financial records of its subsidiaries to form a consolidated audit opinion.

Example: While auditing a parent IT company, the auditor can examine the financials of its overseas subsidiary to ensure accuracy in group reporting.

5. Right to Sign Audit Reports and Report to Shareholders

The auditor has the sole authority to sign the audit report and express an opinion on the financial statements. This report is addressed to the company’s shareholders and becomes part of the Annual Report.

Example: The auditor may issue a qualified opinion if the company has not complied with accounting standards.

6. Right to Attend General Meetings (Section 146)

Auditors have the right to:

  • Receive notices of general meetings (especially AGMs).

  • Attend such meetings.

  • Speak on matters concerning the audit report, financial statements, or any related issues.

Example: An auditor may be asked to clarify certain points in the audit report by shareholders at an AGM.

7. Right to Report Fraud (Section 143(12))

If during the audit, the auditor believes that an offense involving fraud has been committed by company officers or employees, they must report the matter to the Central Government (if above a certain threshold), or the Board/Audit Committee.

Example: If the auditor detects manipulation in inventory records resulting in overstatement of assets, they must report it.

8. Power to Report on Internal Financial Controls (Section 143(3)(i))

For certain companies, the auditor must report whether the company has adequate internal financial controls (IFC) in place and if those controls are operating effectively. This is mandatory for listed companies and other prescribed classes.

Example: If a company lacks segregation of duties in handling cash and approval processes, the auditor must mention it.

9. Right to Examine and Investigate

Auditors have the power to conduct independent examination beyond routine checks if they suspect irregularities. Although this does not give investigative powers like a government authority, it empowers them to dig deeper when red flags arise.

Example: If fixed asset records are inconsistent, the auditor may physically verify assets or seek third-party confirmations.

10. Right to Receive Remuneration

Once appointed, an auditor has the right to receive remuneration as fixed by the company, either by the Board or shareholders depending on the type of company and the nature of appointment.

Duties and Responsibilities of Auditors:

(Under Companies Act, 2013 – Sections 143 to 148)

Auditors play a vital role in safeguarding the financial integrity of a company. Their core duty is to provide an independent and objective view of the financial statements, ensuring accuracy, fairness, and compliance with legal and accounting standards. The Companies Act, 2013, lays down specific statutory duties and responsibilities to ensure accountability and protect the interests of shareholders and the public.

1. Duty to Report on Financial Statements (Section 143(2))

Auditors are required to examine financial statements and provide an audit report that states whether they give a true and fair view of the company’s financial position. They must report whether:

  • Proper books of account have been maintained.
  • Accounting standards have been complied with.
  • Any material misstatements exist.

2. Duty to Inquire (Section 143(1))

The auditor must make specific inquiries into:

  • Whether loans and advances are properly secured.
  • Whether transactions are prejudicial to the interest of the company.
  • Whether personal expenses are charged to revenue.
    These inquiries ensure there is no misuse of company resources or manipulation of accounts.

3. Duty to Report on Internal Financial Controls (Section 143(3)(i))

For listed companies and prescribed others, the auditor must comment on the adequacy and effectiveness of internal financial controls over financial reporting. This includes checking:

  • Risk control mechanisms,
  • Documentation,
  • Authorization systems.

It strengthens corporate governance.

4. Duty to Report Fraud (Section 143(12))

If the auditor believes an offense involving fraud is being or has been committed, they must report it:

  • To the Board/Audit Committee (if below threshold),
  • To the Central Government (if above threshold).
    This duty promotes transparency and accountability.

5. Duty to Comply with Auditing Standards (Section 143(9))

Auditors must follow the auditing standards notified by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI). This includes:

  • Documentation,
  • Audit planning,
  • Evidence collection,
  • Ethical conduct.

Failure to comply may lead to disciplinary action.

6. Duty to Express Independent Opinion

Auditors must maintain independence and objectivity throughout the audit process. They must not be influenced by company management or personal relationships. Their audit opinion must be based only on facts and evidence.

7. Duty to Attend General Meetings (Section 146)

Auditors have the duty (and right) to:

  • Attend the Annual General Meeting (AGM),
  • Respond to shareholder queries on financial matters,
  • Clarify points related to the audit report.

This strengthens auditor accountability to shareholders.

8. Duty to Preserve Confidentiality

While auditors must access and examine confidential company records, they are duty-bound to maintain confidentiality. They must not disclose sensitive company information to outsiders unless legally required.

9. Responsibility Towards Subsidiaries

When auditing a holding company, the auditor must verify and report on the financial information of subsidiaries as well. They are responsible for ensuring consolidated financial statements are accurate and reflect group performance.

10. Responsibility in Case of Resignation

If the auditor resigns, they are required to:

  • File a statement with the company and Registrar (Form ADT-3),
  • Indicate the reasons for resignation,
  • Ensure there’s no attempt to avoid responsibility.

11. Responsibility for Reporting Non–Compliance

Auditors must report if the company has failed to:

  • Repay deposits,
  • Pay dividends,
  • Comply with accounting standards,
  • Meet disclosure requirements.

Qualities of a Good Auditor:

An auditor holds a critical role in examining a company’s financial records to ensure accuracy, fairness, and legal compliance. To carry out this responsibility effectively, an auditor must possess several personal and professional qualities. These qualities help maintain integrity, independence, objectivity, and professional excellence in auditing work.

  • Integrity and Honesty

An auditor must be trustworthy and honest in all professional dealings. Integrity ensures that the auditor presents the financial status of the company truthfully, without being influenced by management or shareholders. Honesty builds confidence among stakeholders that the audit report can be relied upon for decision-making. Any compromise in integrity can lead to misleading financial statements and legal repercussions.

  • Independence and Objectivity

An essential quality for any auditor is independence — both in fact and appearance. The auditor must not have any financial or personal relationship with the company that could influence judgment. Objectivity ensures the auditor’s opinions are based on evidence, not bias or pressure. Independence enhances credibility and helps avoid conflicts of interest in audit conclusions.

  • Professional Competence and Expertise

An auditor must have thorough knowledge of accounting principles, auditing standards, taxation laws, and relevant legal provisions like the Companies Act, 2013. Regular updating of skills is also necessary. This competence allows the auditor to detect discrepancies, suggest improvements, and render an informed opinion on the financial position of the company.

  • Keen Observation and Analytical Ability

A good auditor should have a sharp eye for detail. They must be able to identify inconsistencies in records, spot unusual trends, and detect red flags that indicate possible fraud or misstatements. Analytical ability helps in comparing financial data, ratios, and interpreting them to understand the true financial health of the organization.

  • Confidentiality

Auditors come across sensitive and confidential information while performing their duties. It is essential for them to maintain strict confidentiality and not disclose any information to unauthorized persons unless required by law. This builds trust with the client and ensures that proprietary business information remains protected.

  • Good Communication Skills

An auditor must be able to communicate findings clearly and effectively through oral discussions and written reports. They must interact with clients, staff, and stakeholders to gather information and explain audit results. A well-written audit report must be easy to understand and free of ambiguity, ensuring proper decision-making.

  • Professional Skepticism

A good auditor should not accept evidence at face value. They must apply professional skepticism — a questioning mind and a critical assessment of audit evidence. This quality helps in detecting fraud, misrepresentation, or manipulation in financial statements and ensures the audit is thorough and objective.

  • Patience and Perseverance

Audit work involves examining a vast number of documents, records, and transactions. It may take several rounds of verification and cross-checking. An auditor must have the patience to go through all details meticulously and the perseverance to complete the audit even when facing resistance or delays from the auditee.

  • Time Management

Auditors often work under tight deadlines and must plan their audits in a structured and time-bound manner. Good time management ensures that the audit is completed efficiently without compromising quality. It also helps in prioritizing tasks and allocating time effectively across various stages of the audit process.

  • Impartiality and Fair Judgment

An auditor must be impartial in forming an opinion about the financial statements. They must evaluate evidence and results based on merit and facts, not influenced by personal feelings, relationships, or pressure. Fair judgment ensures the audit report reflects the true and fair view of the company’s financial position.

Management Notes

Managing Director, Meaning, Appointment, Power, Duties and Responsibility

indiafreenotesby indiafreenotes4

Managing Director (MD) is a director who is entrusted with substantial powers of management of the affairs of the company. According to Section 2(54) of the Companies Act, 2013, a Managing Director is a director who, by virtue of an agreement with the company, or a resolution passed by its board or shareholders, or by virtue of its memorandum or articles of association, is given substantial management powers. These powers are not routine administrative functions but involve strategic and operational control over the company.

The Managing Director plays a central role in the day-to-day functioning and decision-making process of the company. They act as a link between the board of directors and the company’s operational management. Typically, a Managing Director is a full-time employee who receives remuneration, and their actions are binding on the company unless found to be unlawful or beyond their authority.

Only an individual can be appointed as a Managing Director, and a company cannot have more than one Managing Director at a time. The appointment of a Managing Director must comply with the provisions of Section 196, and the terms must adhere to Schedule V if the company has inadequate profits.

The Managing Director holds a position of great trust and responsibility, influencing both corporate strategy and execution.

An analysis of the definition shows that:

  • The managing director must be an indi­vidual
  • He/She must be a member of the Board of Directors
  • He/She must be appointed by virtue of an agreement with the company or of a resolution passed by the company in general meeting or by its Board of Di­rectors or by virtue of its Memorandum or Articles of Association
  • He/She is entrusted with substantial power of management
  • He/She is not entrusted with powers of rou­tine nature
  • He/She shall exercise his powers subject to superintendence, control and direction of its Board of Directors

Appointment of Managing Director:

Managing Director (MD) is a key managerial personnel in a company entrusted with substantial powers of management. The process and conditions for appointment are governed primarily by Section 196 and Schedule V of the Companies Act, 2013.

These powers may be granted:

  • By virtue of articles of association,
  • Through an agreement with the company,
  • Via a board or general meeting resolution,
  • Or through a combination of the above.

The powers must go beyond routine administrative work and should involve real decision-making authority in the operations of the company.

Eligibility Criteria for Appointment of Managing Director:

An individual must meet the following conditions to be appointed as a Managing Director:

  • Must be above 21 years and below 70 years of age. (Above 70 possible by special resolution)
  • Must be a resident in India (if it is a foreign company operating in India).
  • Should not be an undischarged insolvent or convicted of any offence involving moral turpitude.
  • Must not be disqualified under Section 164.

Modes of Appointment:

The appointment of a Managing Director can take place in any of the following ways:

  • By Board of Directors through a resolution,
  • By Shareholders in a general meeting,
  • By Articles of Association, if specifically provided,
  • By an agreement entered into between the company and the individual.

The appointment must be approved by the Board and subsequently by shareholders through a resolution in the next general meeting.

Term of Appointment:

As per Section 196(2) of the Companies Act, 2013:

  • A Managing Director can be appointed for a term not exceeding five years at a time.
  • Reappointment is allowed, but not earlier than one year before the expiry of the current term.

Power of Managing Director:

  • Operational Decision-Making

The Managing Director has the authority to make crucial operational decisions on behalf of the company. This includes overseeing production, sales, purchases, pricing, and day-to-day business activities. They ensure coordination between departments and implement board-approved policies efficiently. These decisions help maintain business continuity and performance, allowing the company to respond promptly to market changes without always seeking board approval.

  • Signing Legal and Financial Documents

One of the core powers of a Managing Director is the ability to sign legal and financial documents on behalf of the company. This includes contracts, cheques, agreements, and compliance-related filings. Their signature represents the company’s commitment in legal and financial dealings. This authority ensures smooth and timely execution of external transactions and reinforces trust with stakeholders like clients, vendors, regulators, and banks.

  • Recruitment and HR Management

The Managing Director often holds the power to recruit and manage the company’s workforce. This includes hiring senior staff, determining compensation, approving promotions, handling disciplinary actions, and setting human resource policies. This power allows the MD to build a strong and capable team aligned with the company’s goals. Effective personnel management is essential to operational excellence and long-term growth.

  • Financial Oversight

The Managing Director has considerable power over financial management, including preparing budgets, allocating resources, approving expenditures, and authorizing investments. They ensure compliance with internal financial controls and legal financial obligations. They also review financial reports and collaborate with the Chief Financial Officer (CFO) to manage profitability and risk. This power is critical in ensuring the financial stability and integrity of the company.

  • Representing the Company Externally

The Managing Director serves as the face of the company in external affairs. They represent the company in legal matters, regulatory bodies, public events, industry forums, and negotiations. Their ability to articulate the company’s vision and defend its interests is vital to public perception and market positioning. This power enables the company to have a unified and authoritative presence in external engagements.

  • Policy Implementation and Monitoring

The board of directors often defines company policies, but the Managing Director is responsible for their implementation. They ensure that decisions taken at board meetings are executed effectively and that performance is monitored against targets. The MD develops operational strategies and measures outcomes to align with company objectives. This role is crucial in turning corporate vision into actionable results and maintaining governance.

  • Liaison with the Board of Directors

The Managing Director acts as a vital communication channel between the management and the board of directors. They report on company performance, strategic developments, challenges, and compliance status. They may also propose future business plans and seek board approvals. This liaison role ensures that the board remains informed and can make timely decisions. It also helps balance autonomy with oversight.

  • Crisis Management and Risk Control

In times of crisis—whether financial, reputational, or operational—the Managing Director exercises strong leadership to manage risks and steer the company to safety. They initiate emergency protocols, communicate with stakeholders, and lead recovery plans. Their quick thinking and authoritative position enable swift decisions that can prevent larger losses. This power ensures business continuity and reflects the MD’s central role in strategic risk management.

Duties and Responsibilities of the Managing Directors are:

  • Fiduciary Duty

The Managing Director (MD) has a fiduciary duty to act in good faith and in the best interest of the company. They must prioritize the company’s goals above personal interests, avoiding any conflict of interest. Their actions should benefit stakeholders including shareholders, employees, and customers. Breach of fiduciary duty can lead to legal action. This duty ensures that the MD remains a trustworthy and ethical leader responsible for safeguarding the company’s reputation and long-term objectives.

  • Compliance with Laws

A Managing Director must ensure the company complies with all applicable laws, rules, and regulations, including the Companies Act, 2013, taxation laws, labour laws, environmental laws, and sector-specific rules. They are responsible for timely statutory filings, holding meetings, maintaining registers, and fulfilling regulatory obligations. Failing to comply may lead to penalties or prosecution. Thus, legal compliance is one of the MD’s most critical responsibilities, reinforcing corporate integrity and protecting the company from legal consequences.

  • Implementation of Board Policies

The MD is tasked with the execution of policies and strategies framed by the Board of Directors. While the board provides direction, the MD ensures day-to-day execution and strategic alignment. They must translate broad policy decisions into actionable business activities, ensure resource allocation, and track implementation progress. Effective execution is essential for achieving corporate objectives. This duty connects strategic governance with operational effectiveness, making the MD a bridge between planning and action.

  • Financial Stewardship

The Managing Director is responsible for ensuring sound financial management and control within the organization. They oversee budgeting, financial planning, cost control, and reporting. The MD must ensure the preparation of accurate financial statements and proper use of financial resources. They work closely with the CFO to maintain solvency, avoid wastage, and comply with financial reporting standards. Strong financial stewardship is vital for maintaining investor confidence and long-term viability of the company.

  • Human Resource Leadership

The MD plays a major role in people management, including hiring key executives, defining HR policies, and fostering an ethical, productive work environment. They ensure employee development, address grievances, promote corporate culture, and retain talent. By encouraging transparency and fairness in employment practices, the MD builds trust and boosts performance. Leadership in HR is essential for aligning employees with organizational goals and creating a sustainable, motivated workforce.

  • Risk Management

Managing Directors are responsible for identifying, evaluating, and mitigating business risks. These may include operational, financial, strategic, or reputational risks. The MD must implement risk control measures, establish internal controls, and ensure business continuity. They must be proactive in managing crises and making contingency plans. By being risk-aware and responsive, the MD protects the company from potential losses and ensures resilience in challenging business environments.

  • Corporate Representation

The MD represents the company in external affairs, including negotiations, regulatory matters, investor meetings, and public communications. Their statements and decisions reflect the company’s position, so they must act professionally and responsibly. This role demands diplomacy, leadership, and deep understanding of the company’s mission. As the face of the organization, the MD must uphold its reputation and build trust among external stakeholders, including government agencies, shareholders, and customers.

  • Reporting to the Board

The Managing Director must report periodically to the Board of Directors about the company’s performance, challenges, forecasts, and compliance status. They provide updates on key metrics, strategic initiatives, and operational issues. This helps the board make informed decisions. Transparent and honest reporting ensures accountability, governance, and alignment between board expectations and management execution. It forms the foundation for strong corporate leadership and effective oversight.

error: Content is protected !!