Determination of Liability in respect of Underwriting contract when fully Underwritten and Partially Underwritten with and without firm Underwriting
Underwriting agreements in securities issuance can vary depending on the level of commitment made by the underwriter. The liability of underwriters in such contracts differs when the issue is fully underwritten versus partially underwritten, and further varies with or without firm underwriting.
Fully Underwritten Contract
In a fully underwritten contract, the underwriter or group of underwriters guarantees the entire issue. This means that regardless of how much of the issue is subscribed to by the public, the underwriter is liable to purchase the unsold portion of the securities at the agreed-upon issue price.
-
Liability of Underwriters: The underwriter assumes full liability, meaning they are legally bound to purchase any remaining shares that investors do not subscribe to. The underwriter’s risk is significant, as they are committed to taking on the entire offering if necessary. This type of underwriting provides a capital guarantee to the issuer, ensuring they will raise the full desired amount of funds.
-
Example: Suppose a company is issuing 1,000,000 shares, and the public subscribes to only 600,000. In a fully underwritten agreement, the underwriter would be responsible for purchasing the remaining 400,000 shares. If the shares are issued at a premium, the underwriter must pay the agreed price, regardless of how the market reacts.
Partially Underwritten Contract
In a partially underwritten contract, the underwriter agrees to guarantee only a portion of the securities being offered. The liability is therefore limited to the agreed-upon amount. The issuer may attempt to sell the remaining shares to the public or through other means, but if the public does not fully subscribe, the underwriter is only required to purchase their part of the issue.
-
Liability of Underwriters: Underwriters are only liable for their specific portion of the offering. This means that if, for example, the underwriter has agreed to purchase 60% of the shares and the public subscribes to 40%, the underwriter will be liable for the 60% they committed to, and the remaining 40% will need to be managed through other channels.
-
Example: In an offering of 1,000,000 shares, if the underwriter has agreed to underwrite 600,000 shares, and the public subscribes to 300,000, the underwriter’s liability would be limited to the 600,000 shares, even if the full offering isn’t subscribed.
Firm Underwriting
Firm underwriting involves the underwriter agreeing to buy a fixed number of shares from the issuer, even if the public does not fully subscribe. This type of underwriting involves a higher level of commitment than regular underwriting, and it’s typically used in situations where there is a need to ensure that the issuer raises the required capital.
-
Liability of Underwriters: In firm underwriting, the underwriter is committed to buying a specific number of shares regardless of public subscription. This differs from non-firm underwriting where the underwriter may back out if the subscription level is too low. The underwriter thus takes on more risk, especially if market conditions are unfavorable.
-
Example: If a company issues 1,000,000 shares and the underwriter commits to purchasing 500,000 shares on a firm basis, the underwriter must buy these 500,000 shares, even if the public subscribes to only 300,000 shares. This ensures that the issuer raises at least the required capital.
Non-Firm Underwriting:
Non-firm underwriting occurs when the underwriter agrees to purchase securities only if they are not subscribed to by the public. In this case, the underwriter has no obligation to buy the unsold portion if there is sufficient public subscription. Non-firm underwriting carries less risk for the underwriter as their liability is contingent upon the public’s interest in the offering.
-
Liability of Underwriters: The liability for the underwriter is contingent on the amount of the offering that remains unsold. If there is over-subscription by the public, the underwriter has no responsibility to purchase additional shares. However, if the offering is undersubscribed, they may be required to step in and buy the unsold shares.
-
Example: In an offering of 1,000,000 shares, if the underwriter agrees to underwrite 500,000 shares on a non-firm basis, and the public subscribes to 700,000 shares, the underwriter would have no further obligation to purchase any unsold shares.
Liability in Case of Over-Subscription and Under-Subscription
-
Over-Subscription: When the offering is over-subscribed, meaning the public subscribes for more shares than are available, the underwriter may reduce their liability proportionally. In a firm underwriting, the underwriter still needs to buy the agreed-upon amount, but in a non-firm underwriting, they may reduce their commitment.
-
Under-Subscription: In the case of under-subscription, the underwriter assumes liability for the unsold portion. In fully underwritten contracts, the underwriter is obligated to purchase all the unsold shares. However, in partially underwritten contracts, the underwriter only needs to buy their portion of the unsold shares, and the remaining unsold shares may be dealt with by other means, such as extending the issue period or reducing the offering.