Right Issues of Shares, Types, Procedure, Advantages and Disadvantages

Rights issues refer to the method by which a company offers additional shares to its existing shareholders in proportion to their current holdings. This process allows shareholders to maintain their ownership percentage and avoid dilution of their shares. Rights issues are typically offered at a discounted price to encourage participation and raise capital for the company. Shareholders have the option to purchase the new shares within a specified timeframe, and if they choose not to exercise their rights, they can sell them in the market.

Types of Rights Issue of Shares:

1. Renounceable Rights Issue:

In a renounceable rights issue, existing shareholders have the option to sell their rights to purchase additional shares to another party. This means that if a shareholder does not wish to buy the new shares, they can transfer their rights to another investor. This type of issue provides flexibility and liquidity to shareholders.

2. Non-Renounceable Rights Issue:

In a non-renounceable rights issue, shareholders cannot sell their rights to others. They must either exercise their rights to purchase the new shares or let them lapse. This type of issue is more straightforward, as it does not allow for the transfer of rights, and typically ensures that the company raises the required capital from its existing shareholders.

3. Fully Underwritten Rights Issue:

In a fully underwritten rights issue, an underwriter agrees to purchase any shares not taken up by existing shareholders. This ensures that the company raises the full amount of capital it seeks, even if some shareholders choose not to participate. Underwriting provides security for the company, reducing the risk associated with the rights issue.

4. Partially Underwritten Rights Issue:

In a partially underwritten rights issue, only a portion of the shares offered in the rights issue is underwritten by an underwriter. This means that the company takes on some risk, as it may not raise the total desired capital if shareholders do not fully subscribe to the offer.

5. Bonus Rights Issue:

Bonus rights issue combines the features of a bonus issue and a rights issue. In this case, shareholders receive the option to purchase additional shares at a discount, and the company may also distribute bonus shares simultaneously. This approach is used to reward existing shareholders while raising capital.

6. Preemptive Rights Issue:

In a preemptive rights issue, existing shareholders are given the first opportunity to purchase additional shares before the company offers them to new investors. This helps maintain the shareholders’ proportionate ownership in the company and protects them from dilution.

Procedure for Rights Issue of Shares:

1. Board Approval:

The first step involves obtaining approval from the Board of Directors. The board must discuss and approve the proposal for a rights issue, including the number of shares to be issued, the issue price, and the ratio of rights shares to existing shares.

2. Preparation of Offer Document:

A detailed offer document or prospectus must be prepared, outlining the terms of the rights issue, the rationale for the issue, the pricing, and the implications for shareholders. This document should also include financial statements and disclosures as required by law.

3. Shareholder Approval:

In most cases, a rights issue requires the approval of shareholders through a special resolution at a general meeting. The company must provide adequate notice to shareholders, including details of the proposed rights issue and the agenda for the meeting.

4. Regulatory Filings:

The company must file the necessary documents with the regulatory authorities, such as the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) and the Registrar of Companies (ROC). This includes submitting the prospectus and obtaining approval for the rights issue.

5. Announcement of the Rights Issue:

Once all approvals are obtained, the company announces the rights issue to the public and shareholders. This announcement typically includes the record date (the date on which shareholders must be on the company’s books to be eligible for the rights issue) and the details of the offer.

6. Rights Entitlement:

Existing shareholders receive rights entitlement letters detailing their entitlement to subscribe to additional shares based on their current holdings. The letter specifies the number of shares they are entitled to purchase, the issue price, and the subscription period.

7. Subscription Period:

Company sets a subscription period during which shareholders can exercise their rights. This period typically lasts a few weeks, during which shareholders can choose to subscribe to the additional shares.

8. Receiving Applications and Payment:

Shareholders who wish to participate in the rights issue must submit their applications along with the requisite payment for the shares they wish to purchase. The company may offer multiple payment methods, such as bank transfers or cheques.

9. Allotment of Shares:

After the subscription period closes, the company processes the applications and allocates shares to shareholders based on their subscriptions. The company must ensure that the allotment is done on a pro-rata basis, in line with the entitlements outlined in the rights entitlement letters.

10. Credit of Shares:

Once shares are allotted, they are credited to the demat accounts of the shareholders. For shareholders who have not opted for dematerialization, physical share certificates may be issued.

11. Post-Issue Compliance:

After the rights issue, the company must comply with ongoing reporting and disclosure requirements, including updating its share capital structure and informing regulatory authorities about the successful completion of the rights issue.

Advantages of the Rights Issue of Shares:

1. Capital Raising Without Debt:

One of the primary advantages of a rights issue is that it allows companies to raise capital without incurring additional debt. This helps maintain a healthy balance sheet and reduces the burden of interest payments, enabling the company to invest in growth opportunities or enhance its financial stability.

2. Maintaining Shareholder Control:

Rights issue provides existing shareholders the opportunity to maintain their proportional ownership in the company. By offering new shares at a discounted price, shareholders can avoid dilution of their voting rights and ownership percentage, ensuring that they retain control over the company’s future direction.

3. Flexibility for Shareholders:

Rights issues offer flexibility to shareholders. They can choose to exercise their rights and purchase additional shares at a favorable price, sell their rights to other investors, or let the rights expire. This flexibility allows shareholders to make decisions that best suit their financial situations and investment strategies.

4. Attracting New Investors:

The discounted price offered in a rights issue can attract new investors, which can enhance the company’s shareholder base. By encouraging existing shareholders to invite others to purchase shares, a rights issue can help the company broaden its appeal in the market.

5. Positive Market Signal:

Rights issue can be perceived as a positive signal about the company’s future growth prospects. It demonstrates that the company is proactive in raising funds for expansion or strategic initiatives. This can bolster investor confidence and potentially improve the company’s stock price.

6. Cost-Effective Capital Raising:

Compared to other methods of capital raising, such as public offerings or private placements, rights issues can be more cost-effective. The administrative and regulatory costs associated with rights issues are generally lower, allowing the company to allocate resources more efficiently.

7. Improving Financial Ratios:

Issuing shares through a rights issue can improve various financial ratios, such as the debt-to-equity ratio. By raising capital through equity rather than debt, companies can strengthen their financial position, making them more attractive to potential investors and creditors.

Disadvantages of the Rights Issue of Shares:

1. Dilution of Share Value:

If existing shareholders choose not to participate in the rights issue, their ownership percentage will decrease, leading to dilution of their share value. This can negatively impact their voting power and overall influence within the company.

2. Potential Market Reaction:

The announcement of a rights issue can sometimes lead to a negative market reaction. Investors may perceive it as a sign that the company is in financial trouble or lacks sufficient internal funds, which can lead to a decline in the share price and investor confidence.

3. Increased Administrative Burden:

Conducting a rights issue involves significant administrative tasks, including preparing prospectuses, legal compliance, and communication with shareholders. This can divert management’s attention and resources from other critical business operations.

4. Limited Access to New Investors:

Rights issues primarily target existing shareholders, which may limit the opportunity for the company to attract new investors. This focus on current shareholders can restrict the potential for a broader market appeal and new capital influx.

5. Uncertainty of Subscription:

There is no guarantee that all existing shareholders will exercise their rights to purchase additional shares. If the subscription rate is low, the company may not raise the intended capital, putting financial plans at risk.

6. Short Timeframe for Decision-Making:

Rights issues typically have a limited subscription period, which can pressure shareholders to make quick decisions. Some shareholders may feel rushed, leading to suboptimal choices regarding their investment strategy, such as selling their rights without thoroughly evaluating the company’s prospects.

7. Possible Negative Impact on Financial Ratios:

While a rights issue can improve certain financial ratios, it may also adversely affect others. For example, if the company issues a large number of shares without corresponding growth in profits, it may lead to a decrease in earnings per share (EPS), which can be viewed negatively by the market.